Barry Coleman’s case moved from juvenile proceedings to adult court before a judge imposed a longer supervision term than an earlier proposal.
MILWAUKEE, Wis. — Five months after a judge rejected an agreed resolution as too lenient for the allegations, 15-year-old Barry Coleman was sentenced to 10 years in prison for convictions stemming from the gunpoint abduction and ransoming of 7-year-old Jamal White.
The Oct. 9 sentence closed an unusual plea path in a case that began when Coleman was 14 and initially proceeded in the juvenile system. Milwaukee County Circuit Judge David Borowski ultimately imposed 10 years of initial confinement and seven years of extended supervision, with 451 days of credit for time already served. Coleman had pleaded guilty in July to robbery with use of force and possession of a firearm by an adjudicated delinquent. Although the final convictions did not carry the word kidnapping, the circumstances of Jamal’s abduction remained central to the judge’s sentencing decision because dismissed allegations were considered as read-in offenses.
The court had signaled months earlier that any negotiated resolution would receive close scrutiny. In May, prosecutors and the defense presented an agreement that contemplated a robbery plea and a total sentence of 10 years of confinement followed by five years of extended supervision. Borowski declined to accept that proposal, saying in court that simply pointing to Coleman’s age did not sufficiently address allegations that he had actively participated in taking a 7-year-old at gunpoint. The rejection did not determine Coleman’s guilt, but it sent the case back into negotiations and made clear that the court viewed the factual allegations as more serious than an ordinary robbery case.
A revised resolution followed in July. Coleman pleaded guilty to robbery with use of force and possession of a firearm by an adjudicated delinquent. Prosecutors dismissed a kidnapping count involving a dangerous weapon and a charge accusing Coleman, who was younger than 18, of possessing a dangerous weapon. The dismissed matters were read in at sentencing, a procedure that allowed the judge to consider the conduct described in those allegations while sentencing Coleman on the convictions. Reporting before the hearing said the two convictions exposed Coleman to as much as 25 years in combined imprisonment and supervision, including up to 15 years of initial confinement.
At sentencing, Borowski divided the punishment between the two counts rather than imposing a single undifferentiated term. He ordered eight years of confinement and four years of extended supervision for the robbery conviction. He then imposed a consecutive two years of confinement and three years of supervision on the firearm conviction. Together, the sentences produced 10 years behind bars followed by seven years of community supervision. The court also barred Coleman from contacting Jamal, Jamal’s family and the two adult defendants charged in the same underlying episode.
The parties approached the hearing differently from the earlier negotiated plea. Prosecutors asked the court to impose prison but did not demand a specific number of years. The defense sought a total of 10 years made up of five years of initial confinement and five years of extended supervision. Holloway, Coleman’s attorney, argued that his age, childhood trauma and progress in structured treatment supported a sentence that would leave greater room for rehabilitation. She told the court that Coleman had witnessed the shooting death of a person he regarded as a father figure at age 12 and that psychological evaluations had identified trauma-related conditions.
Coleman also spoke for himself. He apologized for taking Jamal and acknowledged that the younger boy had been pleading not to be separated from his family. He said he alone was responsible for his actions and told the court that he understood both at the time and at sentencing that the conduct was wrong. The defense said Coleman had taken part in therapy and restorative justice programming while in custody, and that his academic and behavioral performance had improved. Coleman described plans to finish school, pursue higher education and work after completing his sentence.
The judge said those signs of progress were significant but not controlling. Borowski described the conduct as aggravated and heinous and said Coleman’s age was the central reason he was not imposing a more severe period of initial confinement. The judge’s comments placed Coleman’s developmental status alongside the details contained in the criminal complaint: a child chased from outside his home, a handgun present, a waiting vehicle and an abduction that became a demand for money and jewelry. The resulting sentence was therefore longer in total supervision than the rejected May proposal even though the initial confinement remained at 10 years.
According to investigators, the events of July 11, 2025, grew out of a robbery plan rather than an original plan to seize a child. Co-defendant Corey Williams told detectives that Coleman had discussed robbing Jamal’s mother and brought Fabian Johnson into the plan. Authorities said a white Jeep Renegade went to the family’s neighborhood after the intended target was not found. Investigators alleged that the focus shifted first toward Jamal’s father and then, when the father escaped the immediate confrontation, toward the boy himself.
Surveillance video described by authorities showed Johnson displaying a gun as Coleman chased Jamal behind the residence. Investigators said Coleman was also armed and carried the child back toward the Jeep. Williams was accused of driving. Jamal’s father told police he heard his son calling for him as the vehicle left. After the abduction, authorities alleged, Johnson communicated a demand for $100,000 in cash and jewelry in exchange for Jamal’s return. The child was held overnight at a residence several miles away.
The case triggered an Amber Alert and an intensive search. Police found Jamal the following day at a residence near North 39th and West Lloyd streets. He was physically unharmed. Jamal later told investigators that while he was being held he played with toys, watched cartoons and ate food. Williams was also located at the property. Investigators said Williams acknowledged his involvement and provided an account of the planning, though the allegations in his own pending criminal case remain subject to adjudication.
Coleman’s move into adult court meant his case followed a different legal route than it would have if it had remained entirely within juvenile jurisdiction. By December 2025 he had been formally charged as an adult, and a court commissioner set cash bond at $100,000. From there, the case moved through negotiations, the rejected May resolution, the July guilty pleas and finally the October sentencing. That procedural history became important because Borowski repeatedly made clear that he regarded the facts behind the convictions, rather than merely their titles, as essential to deciding punishment.
The sentencing resolved Coleman’s prosecution but not the entire case. Johnson and Williams have pleaded not guilty to charges tied to Jamal’s abduction. The latest available reporting showed Johnson headed toward a December trial and Williams scheduled for a December status conference. Their cases remain pending, and the allegations against them must be proven in court. For Coleman, the remaining legal consequence is the sentence itself: 10 years of confinement, less his time-served credit, followed by seven years under extended supervision.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.