The teenage victim required surgery after the 2025 shooting, while the 17-year-old who fired the shot now faces decades in state custody.
LANCASTER, Pa. — More than $13,000 in medical expenses became part of the punishment imposed on a Lancaster teenager whose single gunshot severely injured another juvenile, with a judge ordering restitution in addition to a state prison sentence of 9 1/2 to 20 years.
The restitution order puts a financial figure on only one part of the harm described in court. Prosecutors said the victim was struck in the face and suffered severe damage to the jaw that required surgery. The juvenile survived, but officials have not released a detailed public account of the teenager’s recovery or identified the victim. The court ordered 17-year-old Jay-Quan Edward Williams to repay more than $13,000 associated with the medical bills after he admitted responsibility for the October 2025 shooting.
Williams pleaded guilty Sept. 24 to attempted criminal homicide, two counts of aggravated assault, recklessly endangering another person and three firearm offenses. Lancaster County Judge Thomas Sponaugle then sentenced him to a minimum of 9 1/2 years and a maximum of 20 years in state prison. The sentence closed a case that began when Williams was 16 and another teenager was taken from a Lancaster street to a hospital after what prosecutors described as a brief argument that escalated into gunfire.
The defense framed the sentencing around the damage done to two young lives. Williams did not make a statement when the court offered him the opportunity to speak, but his attorney told Sponaugle that the events had permanently changed the lives of both teenagers. The attorney said it was fortunate that the victim survived and told the court Williams was remorseful. The defense acknowledged that an apology could not undo the consequences and presented Williams as accepting responsibility through his guilty pleas.
Sponaugle’s response focused on the speed with which those consequences developed. The judge described the case as profoundly sad and said Williams had thrown away a major part of his own future in a matter of seconds. That assessment came against the background of a victim facing surgery and medical bills and a defendant, still only 17 at sentencing, receiving a state prison term that can extend to 20 years.
The confrontation happened during the afternoon of Oct. 8, 2025, near Culliton Park in the 200 block of West Strawberry Street. Prosecutors said surveillance video showed Williams with a group of juveniles that included the victim. The interaction became increasingly tense. According to the Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office, Williams questioned whether the victim wanted to die and then displayed a handgun he had been carrying concealed in his waistband.
What happened next was important to prosecutors’ account because the victim was moving away rather than toward Williams. Authorities said the teenager walked away and began talking with another person. Williams then fired one round, striking the victim in the face, and fled. The publicly released prosecution account does not describe a physical attack on Williams immediately before the shot or an exchange of gunfire. The case ultimately ended with Williams admitting attempted criminal homicide and the other offenses rather than contesting the evidence at trial.
Lancaster City police were sent to the area shortly after 3 p.m. Officers found the wounded person and arranged transportation to a medical facility. Early police announcements did not disclose the full extent of the injuries while detectives worked the scene. Later filings and statements from prosecutors described a gunshot wound to the cheek and serious injury to the jaw requiring surgical intervention. Those medical consequences later formed the basis for the restitution imposed at sentencing.
The identity of the injured juvenile has remained outside the public reports reviewed for the case. That distinction matters because the legal proceedings focused publicly on Williams, who was charged as an adult, while authorities continued referring to the injured person as a juvenile or victim. Prosecutors also did not release detailed information about the victim’s age, family or current condition. The available record establishes the injury, surgery and medical expenses without supplying a fuller personal history.
Police arrested Williams on Oct. 10, two days after the shooting. He was charged with attempted criminal homicide, two counts of aggravated assault, reckless endangerment, possession of a firearm by a minor, carrying a firearm without a license and possession of a firearm by a person prohibited from having one. Lancaster police listed him as 16 at the time of the arrest and said the case would proceed against him as an adult.
That charging decision put Williams in the adult criminal process even though he remained a minor. When he waived his preliminary hearing on Nov. 6, 2025, the charges moved forward to Lancaster County Court. The district attorney’s office said at the time that he remained in the Lancaster County Youth Intervention Center in lieu of $250,000 bail. Authorities also noted that, because Williams was a juvenile, he was not eligible to lawfully carry the concealed firearm described in the case.
The guilty pleas came nearly a year after the shooting. Williams admitted the attempted homicide charge as well as both aggravated assault counts and all four remaining offenses identified by prosecutors. That plea meant the evidence did not have to be tested before a jury. It also changed the legal posture of the case: statements that began as accusations after his arrest became conduct that Williams formally admitted in court when entering his pleas.
The restitution order adds a separate consequence to the incarceration. The prison term punishes the criminal conduct, while restitution addresses documented economic loss suffered by the victim. Prosecutors identified the amount as more than $13,000 and linked it to the teenager’s medical expenses. Nothing in the available reports indicates that the figure represents the total personal impact of the injury, including any future treatment or nonmedical effects; it is the amount the court ordered Williams to pay based on the record before it.
The sentence also reflects the range of conduct covered by Williams’ pleas. The prosecution was not limited to the injury itself. It included attempted homicide and aggravated assault, the danger created for another person and three separate restrictions on Williams’ possession and carrying of the firearm. The district attorney’s office said Assistant District Attorney Andrew Harbaugh prosecuted the case, while Lancaster City Bureau of Police Officer Brandon McCormick filed the charges that began the court proceedings.
The case therefore ends with two different forms of consequence attached to the same brief encounter: years of imprisonment for Williams and an enduring medical aftermath for the juvenile who was shot. What remains publicly unknown is how fully the victim has recovered. Authorities have confirmed the surgery and the medical expenses but have not released further health details, and the victim has remained unnamed in the official accounts reviewed for this report.
Beyond the prison term, the restitution order is the clearest public measure of the shooting’s financial toll. Williams was ordered to pay more than $13,000 toward the injured teenager’s medical bills, an obligation tied to treatment after the shooting. Officials have not said whether additional medical care will be required or provided a fuller account of the victim’s recovery.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.