A Miami-Dade judge is weighing a release request as the accused man’s lawyers challenge the prosecution’s account of the October confrontation.
MIAMI, Fla. — The prosecution calls it an intentional armed attack on a delivery driver. The defense says Khuslen Saruultuya went to a Miami-Dade apartment complex because his girlfriend feared the driver’s return and that the gun discharged accidentally. Those competing accounts are now shaping a felony case that began with a late-night Uber Eats delivery.
Saruultuya, 33, has pleaded not guilty after being arrested Oct. 12 in connection with a confrontation outside the Pearl Dadeland Apartments. Authorities accuse him of shooting an Uber Eats driver, striking the man in the head with a handgun and threatening to kill him. The defense does not dispute that Saruultuya went to the property after the driver returned there, but it has challenged prosecutors’ description of his purpose and intent. The disagreement came into sharper focus at a Nov. 18 bond hearing, where an investigator testified about a message Saruultuya’s girlfriend allegedly sent saying she was frightened by the driver’s return. The judge heard arguments over whether Saruultuya should remain jailed while the case proceeds.
The defense’s version starts not with the gunfire but with the woman’s reaction to seeing the driver again. Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office investigator Edson Dosantos testified that the driver had first encountered the woman while delivering food in the early hours of Oct. 12. Investigators described the brief conversation as flirtatious from the driver’s point of view. The driver left, finished another delivery and later came back looking for the woman. According to testimony reported from the November hearing, the woman contacted Saruultuya after the driver returned and told him she was scared. Defense attorneys have used that communication to argue that Saruultuya went to the building to protect her rather than to seek out a stranger for an unprovoked attack.
Prosecutors say what Saruultuya allegedly did after arriving is inconsistent with that explanation. The probable cause affidavit says the driver was heading back to his vehicle after failing to locate the woman when Saruultuya arrived in a gray Chevrolet Corvette. The driver told deputies that Saruultuya got out, pointed a handgun toward him and issued loud commands ordering him to lie on the ground. According to investigators, the driver complied. A round was fired and grazed his right buttock, the affidavit says. Authorities then allege that Saruultuya struck the driver in the back of the head with the handgun, causing an open wound measuring about 2 inches.
The alleged threat that followed is another major point in the prosecution’s account. The driver told deputies that Saruultuya ordered him to stand and pointed the firearm toward his head while threatening to kill him. Investigators said Saruultuya’s girlfriend pleaded with him to stop and tried to hold him back as the driver attempted to escape around the Corvette. The driver eventually got away and drove himself to South Miami Hospital. At the November bond hearing, Dosantos testified that the driver reported hearing a gunshot and initially did not know whether he had been hit before the physical assault continued.
The defense has offered a different explanation for the gunshot itself. Saruultuya maintains that the firearm discharged accidentally during the encounter, according to reporting on the bond hearing. That assertion directly conflicts with the prosecution theory that the shot was part of a deliberate assault. The available public reports do not establish that a judge or jury has determined which description is correct. Saruultuya is presumed innocent, and the prosecution would have to prove the charged offenses in court. The bond proceeding concerned pretrial release and was not a trial on guilt or innocence.
Evidence gathered immediately after the confrontation helped deputies focus on Saruultuya. A sheriff’s deputy responded to a gunfire report at the apartment complex at about 3:34 a.m. A witness described an altercation involving a man with a gun and told investigators that the armed person had left in a two-door sports car with a Florida plate. Authorities traced the plate to a 2021 gray Chevrolet Corvette registered to Saruultuya. Around the same period, a South Miami police officer working an off-duty assignment at the hospital alerted law enforcement after the driver arrived with injuries. The driver later identified Saruultuya from a photo lineup, according to investigators.
Deputies arrested Saruultuya at his residence without incident. The shooting investigation then led to another set of allegations when authorities searched the home. Prosecutors have said investigators found baggies containing suspected drugs and more than $11,000 in cash. Court records list a separate felony case containing nine drug counts, including trafficking allegations involving amphetamine, cocaine and an ecstasy-related substance, along with other controlled-substance charges. News reports have identified additional suspected drugs and pills found during the search. Those allegations are being handled separately from the claims involving the delivery driver.
The drug evidence became relevant again during arguments over Saruultuya’s continued detention. Prosecutors cited the suspected narcotics and cash while opposing his release. At an earlier appearance, Saruultuya spoke up as a judge reviewed drug allegations and said the substances were his prescriptions. The judge cautioned him not to discuss his case in court without consulting his lawyer. His statement did not resolve the charges, and the public docket shows the drug prosecution remains a separate criminal matter.
The original encounter began about 50 minutes before the confrontation, according to the arrest affidavit. The driver arrived at the apartment complex around 2:35 a.m. to deliver food. He met the woman outside the main lobby as instructed and spoke to her briefly. Investigators said he later told deputies he had taken a liking to her. He continued working before returning at about 3:25 a.m., hoping to see her again and possibly ask for her phone number. The affidavit says he did not find her and was walking back toward his car when Saruultuya arrived.
That timeline is not, by itself, the disputed part of the case. The major legal questions concern what Saruultuya intended after learning the driver had returned, whether his use of the firearm was deliberate and how the physical confrontation unfolded. Prosecutors point to the alleged commands, gunshot, head injury, death threat and chase as evidence of an intentional attack. The defense points to the girlfriend’s reported message about being frightened and Saruultuya’s claim of an accidental discharge as evidence supporting a different interpretation. Those issues may become central if the case reaches trial.
Miami-Dade court records identify Saruultuya’s defense attorney as Gennaro Cariglio and show that counsel filed a notice of appearance, plea, demand for discovery and demand for a jury trial shortly after the arrest. The docket lists the case as open. An early bond review was held after the arrest, and NBC 6 South Florida reported that bond was denied in connection with the attempted-murder allegation. The later November proceeding gave the defense another opportunity to seek his release and gave prosecutors a forum to present more of their account.
The hearing also illustrates the difference between an arrest affidavit and a fully litigated criminal case. The affidavit records what investigators say witnesses and the driver told them and sets out facts authorities relied on to support an arrest. The defense is entitled to challenge those claims, question witnesses and present a competing account. A bond judge can assess factors related to detention without making a final determination of guilt. Saruultuya’s not-guilty plea means the factual disputes remain open unless they are resolved by a later plea, dismissal or trial.
As of the latest court and news material reviewed, Saruultuya remained accused of attempted murder and aggravated battery with a deadly weapon in connection with the driver’s injuries and faced a separate set of felony drug allegations. The driver has not been publicly identified in the reports reviewed. No trial verdict has been entered, and the prosecution and defense remain divided over whether the confrontation was a deliberate shooting or an encounter in which, as the defense contends, the firearm went off accidentally.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.