Body-camera footage documented the arrest after several witnesses reported the Safety Harbor shooting and described the vehicle that left the scene.
SAFETY HARBOR, Fla. — Multiple 911 callers who witnessed a shooting outside a Safety Harbor bar gave deputies information that helped them find the suspect’s vehicle, leading to the arrest of a man now charged with first-degree murder in the death of his girlfriend, authorities said.
The emergency calls on Oct. 13 became the crucial link between the violence reported near Harbor Bar and the traffic stop that followed. The Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office says Christopher “Dodge” Smith, 40, shot his girlfriend, Jessica Antolini, 30, during an argument and drove away after running over her, with his 5-year-old daughter and a dog in the vehicle. Antolini survived for two days before dying at a hospital. The sheriff’s office then upgraded Smith’s original attempted first-degree murder charge to first-degree murder. He also faces a child abuse charge and has pleaded not guilty through counsel.
The arrest was recorded in video released by the sheriff’s office. Deputies located Smith’s SUV after witnesses described it, then followed the vehicle into the Palm Harbor area. Local reports based on the video said a deputy used a precision immobilization maneuver on Ridgemoor Boulevard, causing the SUV to stop. Smith emerged with his hands raised. As deputies ordered him to the ground and placed him in custody, he repeatedly made clear that his daughter was still inside the vehicle.
The footage then shifted attention from Smith to the back seat. His daughter could be heard crying as deputies removed her and the family dog. The sheriff’s office said neither the child nor the animal was physically injured and both were later reunited with family members. An arrest affidavit says the girl told deputies that her father had shot Jessica. Her reported words became one part of the evidence described by authorities, but like the other allegations in the case, they have not been tested at trial.
Investigators say the events leading to that roadside arrest began less than an hour earlier in downtown Safety Harbor. Smith arrived at Harbor Bar, 840 Main St., at about 8:45 p.m., according to the sheriff’s office. Authorities initially said he left his daughter and the dog in the parking area while he entered the bar. An arrest affidavit later described his purpose as looking for Antolini. Witnesses familiar with Smith told investigators that his behavior stood out as he moved through the bar trying to locate her.
Those witnesses used striking language in the arrest paperwork, saying Smith appeared as if he were “possessed” and was aggressively searching for Antolini. Such descriptions reflect the witnesses’ impressions rather than a medical or legal finding about Smith’s mental condition. Investigators say Smith eventually found Antolini and the pair went outside, where they began arguing. The affidavit says his daughter was able to see at least part of the confrontation. No public record reviewed for this report establishes precisely what started the dispute.
According to detectives, Smith walked toward his vehicle and Antolini followed. Investigators allege that Smith then produced a firearm and shot her. The sheriff’s office says he got into his vehicle with the child and dog and drove away, running over Antolini as he left. Authorities have released more specific injury details in arrest records, but the central allegation is that Antolini suffered both a gunshot wound and injuries from the vehicle. She was rushed to a hospital in critical condition.
The sheriff’s office said several people in the area immediately called 911. Their reports identified the shooting location as the southwest corner of 9th Avenue South and Main Street, just west of Harbor Bar. They also gave dispatchers information about the vehicle that had left the scene. That information allowed patrol deputies to move quickly from responding to the shooting to searching for the SUV. The agency has not publicly identified all of the callers, and their complete statements have not been released in the materials reviewed for this report.
The arrest affidavit describes a separate piece of evidence from the minutes after Smith left the bar. Investigators say Smith called his mother and told her he was bringing his daughter to her because he had “messed up” and “shot Jess.” The reported call is significant because it allegedly occurred before deputies stopped him, but it remains evidence cited by investigators rather than a judicial finding. Authorities have not released a complete recorded interview with Smith or a public account of what he says happened before the confrontation.
For the first two days after the arrest, Smith faced attempted first-degree murder and child abuse charges while Antolini remained hospitalized. The sheriff’s office said Antolini was pronounced dead at 9:14 p.m. Oct. 15 as a result of the injuries she suffered two days earlier. The following day, the agency announced that the attempted-murder charge had been upgraded to first-degree murder. Smith was being held without bond on the most serious accusation, according to court records reported by local media.
The court case began taking shape almost immediately. The Pinellas-Pasco Public Defender’s Office was first appointed to represent Smith and filed a not guilty plea on his behalf. The office later asked to withdraw because of a conflict. A judge granted that request and appointed the state’s Office of Criminal Conflict and Civil Regional Counsel. The change in lawyers does not decide any issue of guilt or innocence. It means Smith’s defense is being handled by a different publicly funded legal office as the murder and child abuse charges proceed.
Antolini’s death also shifted attention to the life behind the name appearing in police reports. Her mother, Suzanne Rys Antolini, released a family statement describing Jessica as a beloved child, cherished sister and treasured friend. The family said she was kind, loving and an advocate for human rights and animal welfare. Friends later echoed that description at a November celebration of life, remembering her smile, humor and the way she made others feel welcome rather than focusing only on the circumstances of her death.
The community response eventually returned to the same area where the 911 calls had begun the police response. A memorial was established near Main Street and 9th Avenue South, and friends gathered at VFW Post 10093 for a celebration of Antolini’s life. A bench was dedicated to her, while purple ribbons were worn as part of a message about domestic violence. Friends said Antolini had been trying to leave what they described as a toxic relationship. That statement reflects their account and is distinct from the allegations prosecutors must prove in the criminal case.
Much of the state’s case, as publicly described so far, rests on witness accounts, the rapid police response, statements attributed to Smith and evidence gathered after deputies stopped his vehicle. How that material will be challenged or presented at trial remains unknown. Smith continues to face first-degree murder and child abuse charges and is presumed innocent unless prosecutors prove those charges in court.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.