A revolver recovered after a Kent pursuit was later linked by state laboratory testing to the fatal Skyway shooting.
KENT, Wash. — The break in the killing of U.S. Coast Guard Lt. Connor Overstreet did not come at the Skyway intersection where he was shot. It emerged two days later, about 10 miles away, after police encountered a dark Toyota Prius, pursued it through Kent and recovered a backpack containing a .357-caliber revolver. Weeks of laboratory work and additional investigation would eventually lead authorities to charge 18-year-old Isaiah Bolar with second-degree murder, alleging he either fired the fatal shot or helped or encouraged the person who did.
The sequence illustrates how investigators built the case from separate pieces of evidence rather than from an immediate identification of a gunman. A witness had described a single shot from inside a Prius after a brief verbal confrontation. Surveillance video helped detectives identify characteristics of the car. Kent police later encountered a similar vehicle, which authorities said had been reported stolen. Officers recovered the revolver after the chase, but its significance to the homicide was not yet confirmed. Only after the Washington State Patrol Crime Laboratory reported its findings Sept. 28 did detectives say they had forensic evidence tying that firearm to Overstreet’s death. Bolar was arrested on the murder allegation Oct. 1.
Overstreet, 29, was killed early Aug. 23 while riding rented electric scooters with two friends in Bryn Mawr-Skyway, an unincorporated area south of Seattle. Investigators said the three were traveling near South 124th Street and South Langston Road when people in a passing Prius yelled toward them. An exchange followed. The car continued on before making a U-turn and stopping for roughly five to 10 seconds, according to accounts contained in court records. Overstreet then went toward the passenger side. One of his friends told detectives that Overstreet bent toward the front passenger window before the witness saw a muzzle flash.
One shot was fired. The Prius sped away, investigators said, leaving Overstreet critically wounded in the road. King County sheriff’s deputies arrived after a report of the shooting at about 12:43 a.m. Emergency responders attempted life-saving measures, but Overstreet was pronounced dead at the scene. The initial evidence gave detectives a vehicle description, the accounts of Overstreet’s companions and the surrounding neighborhood to search for video. What investigators did not have was a publicly identified shooter. That distinction remains significant even now: Prosecutors have charged Bolar with murder but have framed their case to cover either his direct participation as the shooter or accomplice liability for assisting or encouraging another person.
Detectives began collecting surveillance recordings from nearby homes and businesses. KIRO 7 reported that court documents described audio capturing people calling toward the Prius and video showing headlight movement consistent with the car making a U-turn, even though the turn itself was outside the camera’s view. Investigators focused on the vehicle’s appearance, including distinctive rims, and circulated a bulletin to other police agencies. The method was incremental. No single image described in the records publicly identified who fired the gun. Instead, the video helped investigators define what kind of car they were seeking and provided a sequence consistent with the surviving friends’ account.
On Aug. 25, a law enforcement camera alerted Kent police to a Prius matching the vehicle of interest. Police also knew the car had been reported stolen, according to local reporting based on court records. Officers tried to stop it. The driver fled, and police eventually deployed spike strips. Bolar was arrested in connection with the pursuit. Authorities said a passenger got out during the encounter carrying a backpack and discarded it in a trash container. The passenger later told investigators that Bolar had handed over the bag. Police recovered the backpack and said it contained the Ruger revolver that would later become central to the murder prosecution.
At that moment, however, investigators had not completed the forensic work needed to say the firearm was the one used to kill Overstreet. That gap affected what happened next. Prosecutors sought bail in the attempting-to-elude matter, but Bolar was released shortly after the Kent arrest. Casey McNerthney, a spokesperson for the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office, later told KIRO 7 that prosecutors handling the pursuit case did not have information from investigators at that time connecting Bolar to the homicide. The eluding prosecution proceeded separately while the gun went to the state crime laboratory and homicide detectives continued building their evidence.
The laboratory analysis took more than a month. Investigators said the Washington State Patrol Crime Laboratory examined the revolver, ammunition remaining in it and ballistic evidence recovered in connection with Overstreet’s death. Detectives received the report Sept. 28. According to court documents summarized by FOX 13 Seattle, the laboratory concluded that the evidence recovered from Overstreet had been fired from the Ruger found after the Kent pursuit. That finding changed the value of the Aug. 25 evidence: A gun recovered during what initially appeared to be a separate stolen-car and eluding investigation was now alleged to be the weapon used in an unsolved homicide.
Detectives also sought digital evidence. Court records described by local outlets say investigators obtained cellphone information associated with Bolar. They said the records were consistent with the phone leaving the Covington area and traveling toward Skyway shortly after midnight on Aug. 23, then moving along a route corresponding with the Prius after the shooting. Phone-location information does not, by itself, identify who pulled a trigger, and prosecutors have not publicly claimed otherwise. In the charging case, it functions alongside the vehicle evidence, witness accounts, recovered firearm and laboratory findings as part of the state’s allegation that Bolar was criminally involved in the killing.
King County sheriff’s detectives and a SWAT team arrested Bolar again Oct. 1, this time on the homicide case. Prosecutors filed a second-degree murder charge and sought $3 million bail. In charging documents, senior deputy prosecutor Donald Raz wrote that the state alleged Bolar either killed Overstreet himself or assisted or encouraged the shooting. Bolar pleaded not guilty at his Oct. 7 arraignment. The defense later sought to reduce bail to $100,000, but a judge rejected that request, according to local reporting. The high bail kept him jailed for several more weeks, even though it was not an order for detention without the possibility of release.
On Nov. 10, FOX 13 reported that Bolar had posted the $3 million bail and had been released. The development shifted the case from an investigative story into a continuing pretrial proceeding in which the accused is no longer being held in the county jail. Overstreet’s sister, Shea, told the station that his family was devastated by the change and had taken some comfort from Bolar’s previous detention. Her statement underscored a difference between the family’s expectations and the legal function of bail: The murder case remains pending regardless of whether the defendant is physically held before adjudication.
The evidence that brought prosecutors to this point still must be tested through the criminal process. Laboratory findings can establish a claimed connection between a weapon and ballistic evidence, while cellphone records and vehicle evidence can help establish movements, but prosecutors still bear the burden of proving every element of the murder charge beyond a reasonable doubt. The public record reviewed in local reporting also leaves unresolved who prosecutors say actually fired from inside the Prius. Their alternative theory of liability expressly preserves that uncertainty while alleging Bolar bears responsibility either way. His not-guilty plea contests the state’s case.
The revolver recovered after the Kent pursuit remains the most direct physical link prosecutors have publicly described between the police chase and Overstreet’s killing. That evidence, along with the cellphone records, surveillance material and witness accounts, can now be challenged through the court process. Bolar has denied the murder allegation through his not-guilty plea, leaving a judge or jury to determine what the collected evidence ultimately proves.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.