College student allegedly stabs music instructor he called a goodie two shoes

Alexander William Cusey told investigators he bought the weapon a day before his percussion lesson with the instructor, according to court records.

MORRIS, Minn. — The most serious charge against a University of Minnesota Morris student accused of stabbing his percussion instructor turns in large part on what prosecutors say happened before the two entered a music practice room: Alexander William Cusey allegedly bought a knife one day earlier because he planned to kill the instructor.

Cusey, 21, is charged with attempted first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree assault causing great bodily harm and two counts of second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon in connection with the Sept. 29 attack. The criminal complaint describes an encounter that lasted only a short time but alleges preparation before it began, including the knife purchase and statements Cusey made afterward about his intentions. Prosecutors must prove those allegations in court. A criminal complaint establishes the accusations and the basis asserted for them; it is not a finding that the defendant committed the crimes charged.

The allegation of advance planning distinguishes the state’s attempted-murder theory from a case based only on an impulsive violent confrontation. According to a later report on the charging document, Cusey told police that he bought the knife the day before the attack. In a recorded interview, he allegedly said he had purchased it because he was going to kill his instructor. Investigators also said Cusey described waiting in a percussion practice room with his mallets and trying to appear normal before the instructor arrived. Prosecutors allege that when the instructor turned to open a bag, Cusey drew the knife and attacked.

The instructor survived. Court records say he suffered stab wounds to an arm and two or three cuts to the right side of his head. Cusey allegedly told medical personnel after the attack that he had tried to stab the instructor in the neck and heart but had not succeeded in landing those blows. The instructor was able to leave the practice room and reach another university employee’s office for help. That escape shifted the episode from an encounter inside a small instructional space to an emergency response involving staff members, campus public safety and additional officers.

Authorities were called to the Humanities and Fine Arts building at about 4:02 p.m. When a campus public safety officer reached the lower level, a staff member was holding shut a door leading to a hallway lined with small music practice rooms. The staff member said the injured instructor had come to his office and identified Cusey as the attacker. An officer supplied a tourniquet to help with the instructor’s bleeding. Other officers arrived, called for Cusey to come out with his hands up and arrested him after he stepped into the hallway. Investigators later reported finding a knife in a percussion practice room.

The allegations in the complaint became more serious as investigators recorded what Cusey was said to have told doctors and officers. At the hospital, where he received treatment for a cut to a finger, Cusey allegedly said he had been trying to kill his percussion instructor. In a later interview, he described hating the instructor and referred to him as a “goodie two shoes,” according to reports based on the filing. Law enforcement also attributed to Cusey complaints that the instructor assigned him work. Those statements offer prosecutors evidence they may cite when arguing intent, although a court would determine their admissibility and weight.

The complaint attributes other comments to Cusey about school and employment. He allegedly told investigators that he never wanted to attend college or hold a job and suggested prison could be a way to avoid those expectations. Such remarks may help explain what police said he told them after his arrest, but they do not by themselves establish a legal motive or prove the elements of attempted murder. The state must still establish beyond a reasonable doubt any charge that proceeds to trial, including the allegation that Cusey acted with premeditation rather than forming an intent during the confrontation itself.

Minnesota prosecutors filed three assault counts in addition to attempted murder. The first-degree assault charge alleges great bodily harm. One second-degree assault count alleges use of a dangerous weapon causing substantial bodily harm, while another alleges assault with a dangerous weapon. The separate counts allow prosecutors to address different alleged aspects of the same episode. According to the charging document as reported by MN Crime, the attempted first-degree murder count carries a maximum term of 20 years. Other counts also carry possible prison sentences, though any eventual punishment would depend on the outcome of the case and applicable sentencing rules.

The post-arrest interview contained additional allegations that are not necessary to describe the mechanics of the attack but form part of the record authorities presented. Investigators said Cusey described the attack as exciting and made comments indicating amusement at the instructor’s distress. He also allegedly discussed previous violent fantasies involving family members and a possible school shooting if he had access to a firearm. Those statements are disturbing, but the reports reviewed do not indicate that the fantasies produced additional charged acts in this case. They remain attributed statements in an investigation, not independent findings that other crimes occurred.

That distinction matters because the criminal case is narrower than the totality of what Cusey allegedly told investigators. The filed counts focus on the Sept. 29 attack, the instructor’s injuries, the knife and the prosecution’s claim of an intent to kill. A defendant can make alarming statements without every statement becoming a separate criminal charge. Likewise, prosecutors’ inclusion of an allegation in a probable cause narrative does not mean a jury has accepted it. The eventual court process must address evidence under legal rules that are different from the probable-cause standard used at the charging stage.

Reports published soon after the incident differed over Cusey’s age. Law&Crime and the Minnesota Star Tribune identified him as 20, while CBS Minnesota, Valley News Live and Bring Me The News reported that he was 21. A contemporaneous booking record also listed him as 21. This account uses 21 because that age is supported by multiple later and court-based reports. The discrepancy illustrates why details from initial crime reporting can change as court and custody records become available, even when the core allegations remain consistent.

The case also moved through more than one detention facility. Law&Crime reported in early October that Cusey was being held at the Wilkin County Jail under a high bond set in the case. A current Douglas County inmate roster lists him as having been booked there Oct. 14 under Stevens County authority. The roster lists four offenses corresponding to the attempted-murder and assault case and describes him as an “unsent boarder,” a custody designation rather than a judgment on the charges. The record does not show a conviction.

What ultimately happens in the case will depend on later court proceedings, possible motions, evidentiary rulings and any plea or trial outcome that is publicly recorded. The sources reviewed for this article do not establish a final resolution. As of Nov. 18, Cusey remained listed in Douglas County custody, and the allegation that he planned the attack by purchasing the knife beforehand remained part of the state’s charging case rather than a proven fact.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.