An employee quietly documented a second alleged choking after first warning a colleague that he was hurting the resident, police say.
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — A shaken group-home employee who asked to speak with police away from her workplace gave investigators an account that would become central to a manslaughter case: She said she saw a coworker choke 26-year-old Jason Similien unconscious twice and recorded audio during the second incident.
More than three years later, authorities arrested that coworker, Jimmy Bertram Alexis, 43, in connection with Similien’s June 30, 2023, death at Genuine Love and Care Group Home in Fort Lauderdale. Alexis is charged with aggravated manslaughter of a disabled adult. Police say the witness account was supported by a phone recording from inside the home and by statements Alexis later made during a controlled call arranged by investigators. Alexis has denied the allegations and told police that he restrained Similien but did not choke him. No criminal guilt has been established.
The witness did not initially give her full account in front of others at the facility, according to police records described by Local 10. Officers said she appeared visibly shaken when they spoke with staff after Similien was found unresponsive. Investigators later encountered her waiting outside, where she indicated that she wanted to talk away from the group home. She then told officers that she had watched Alexis choke Similien until he lost consciousness on two occasions during the overnight shift. Her decision to separate herself from the workplace before speaking gave detectives a substantially different account from the explanation Alexis had provided.
The employee said she objected during the first encounter and told Alexis to stop because he was hurting Similien. When she later saw what she described as another choking incident, she used her phone to make an audio recording, investigators said. Police reported that Similien could be heard moaning on that recording. The full audio has not been publicly released in the reporting reviewed for this article, so its complete contents and context are not independently available. But investigators cited the recording in the arrest documentation as evidence supporting the witness’s description of what happened during the early morning hours.
Police then used the witness in another investigative step. Authorities asked her to make a controlled phone call to Alexis, meaning investigators were monitoring or directing a conversation designed to gather evidence. According to the arrest form, Alexis discussed what he intended to tell police and advised the woman to give a similar version in her own words. Investigators also said he warned her against mentioning the facility’s logbook because officers could seek it, told her not to discuss the mat on which Similien had been lying and cautioned her against providing details that could generate more police questions. Those statements remain allegations from the investigative record.
The chronology described by the witness began before the cookie request that later drew attention to the case. She said Similien was active around the home at about 1 a.m. and was told by Alexis to return to bed. When he did not comply, the witness alleged that Alexis put an arm around Similien’s neck as the resident sat on a blue foam mat. Similien then lost consciousness, she said. Police records indicate that Similien later regained consciousness, making the first alleged episode important to investigators because it suggested more than one physical confrontation occurred during the same shift.
At about 3 a.m., the witness said, Similien was awake again and went to a snack closet in search of a cookie. Investigators said she described Alexis as frustrated by Similien’s activity. She alleged that he again put Similien in a hold around the neck until the resident became unconscious. Law&Crime, citing the arrest affidavit, reported that Similien did not regain consciousness after that alleged encounter. Alexis later told investigators a different sequence, saying Similien went back to bed on his own about 5 a.m. and fell asleep before being found unresponsive when Alexis tried to wake him at 6:45 a.m.
The competing accounts are important because Alexis did not deny using physical restraint. According to investigators, he said Similien moved around the home and made noises that could disturb other residents. He told police he had used a technique he called “vertical immobilization” four or five times during the night. His early explanation was that he had to “restrain him, not choke him.” That distinction is now at the center of the case: Police allege the physical contact included repeated choking that caused Similien to lose consciousness, while Alexis has disputed that description and denied the allegations through his defense.
Similien’s medical and behavioral history also became part of the investigation. Facility representatives told police he had autism and experienced anxiety and psychosis. Staff said he was prone to self-injury and sometimes banged his head against surfaces. That information offered investigators another possible explanation to consider when assessing injuries and the circumstances of his death, but police ultimately pursued the case as a homicide investigation. Similien was transported from the home to a hospital and pronounced dead at 7:42 a.m. on June 30, 2023. In November of that year, the medical examiner classified his death as a homicide.
Despite the homicide ruling, more than three years passed before Alexis was taken into custody. Fort Lauderdale police said investigators worked with the Broward State Attorney’s Office as the case developed. In October 2026, the department’s Fugitive Unit arrested Alexis on a warrant. His defense attorney questioned the timing during his first court appearances, arguing that it was unusual for authorities to bring the case years after the death. The delay does not itself establish either guilt or innocence, and public reports reviewed for this article do not identify a final adjudication of the charge.
Similien’s family has pursued its own account of what happened through civil litigation. Adam Finkel, an attorney representing the family, described Similien as a sweet and caring young man and said the family believes the residential program failed to protect him. Finkel has also alleged that other employees had previously raised concerns about Alexis and that those warnings did not result in his firing. The facility and related defendants have been sued separately from the criminal prosecution. NBC 6 reported after the arrest that it had contacted representatives of the facility and their attorneys but had not received a response.
The witness’s role makes this case unusual in a practical sense: Investigators say she not only described what she saw but preserved audio during the alleged second encounter and then participated in a monitored conversation with the suspect. Even so, those materials have not been publicly tested through a trial. Prosecutors must establish that the evidence supports the charged offense, while Alexis can challenge the witness’s recollection, the interpretation and context of the recordings, the medical evidence and other parts of the state’s case.
What happens next will determine how much of the evidence described by police is tested in open court. The coworker’s account, her audio recording and the controlled call are central to the state’s case, but none amounts to a finding of guilt. Alexis is out on bond, has denied wrongdoing and had not been reported convicted or acquitted as of Nov. 18.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.