Custody clash at middle school ceremony ends with fiance killing Florida woman’s ex-boyfriend

Roderick Kelvin Watson Jr. testified that he feared Joseph James Juarez Coles before jurors convicted him of premeditated murder.

OCALA, Fla. — Roderick Kelvin Watson Jr. took the witness stand and told jurors why he believed shooting Joseph James Juarez Coles was necessary: He thought he was in danger. The jury ultimately rejected that explanation and convicted Watson of premeditated first-degree murder.

The Oct. 8 verdict brought a life sentence from Circuit Judge Barbara Kissner-Kwatkosky and resolved the central dispute in a case that had remained largely unchanged since the night of the May 22, 2024, shooting. Watson acknowledged firing at Coles outside North Marion Middle School in Citra. The question was whether Florida’s rules governing self-defense protected his actions. Prosecutors said no, pointing to eyewitnesses who described Coles as unarmed and moving away. Watson’s lawyers argued that their client reasonably believed he faced a serious threat.

On the stand, Watson said he fired because he wanted to survive the encounter. He testified that he had heard Coles was a boxer and said he did not know whether Coles or another man nearby might have a weapon. The defense used those concerns to argue that jurors had to consider what Watson reasonably believed at the time, not simply what investigators learned afterward. Coles was not armed, according to evidence presented at trial.

The prosecution focused instead on Watson’s decisions before the gunfire. Assistant State Attorney Toby Hunt argued that Watson was sitting in a vehicle before entering a disagreement between Coles and the mother of Coles’ children. Prosecutors said Watson armed himself and approached the dispute despite being told not to become involved. Hunt’s argument was that those choices mattered because a person claiming self-defense cannot create or unnecessarily escalate a deadly confrontation and then rely on the danger he helped produce.

Witness testimony gave jurors another version of the crucial seconds. The State Attorney’s Office said Coles turned to walk away after Watson intervened. Witnesses said Watson fired multiple times, and some accounts gathered by investigators described Coles trying to get away. After Coles fell, authorities said Watson repeatedly struck him and then kicked him before leaving his immediate side. Those actions became evidence for prosecutors seeking to show that Watson’s conduct went beyond an attempt to stop a perceived threat.

The confrontation had grown out of a disagreement over the children after a student awards ceremony at North Marion Middle School. Coles and his former partner were discussing where the children would go after the event. She told investigators that Coles grabbed her arm during the dispute. Watson, who was engaged to her, then became involved. The defense treated that account as important context for his claim that he stepped in to protect people. Prosecutors did not dispute that an argument had occurred but argued that the evidence did not justify what followed.

The physical scene also became part of the case against Watson. Sheriff’s investigators recovered six spent 9 mm cartridge cases in the parking lot, according to reporting based on the arrest affidavit. A handgun was found in Watson’s vehicle, with its slide locked back, a condition investigators said was consistent with the ammunition in the magazine having been fired or the slide having been manually pulled back. Coles suffered multiple gunshot wounds and was taken to a hospital, where he died.

Watson’s conduct after the gunfire presented jurors with facts the defense said supported its position. He did not flee the campus. Deputies found him nearby, and reports from the initial investigation said he identified himself as the shooter and told law enforcement where the gun was. He surrendered without resistance. His attorneys argued that remaining at the scene was inconsistent with the conduct of someone who believed he had deliberately committed a murder and needed to escape.

Prosecutors responded that cooperation afterward did not answer the question of whether the shooting itself was justified. Investigators said from the first days of the case that witness accounts and evidence at the scene contradicted Watson’s self-defense claim. After he was taken into custody, Watson declined to give investigators a further statement after being advised of his rights, according to the State Attorney’s Office. More than two years later, however, he chose to testify before the jury and give his account directly.

The legal case had become more serious in the weeks after the shooting. Watson was initially arrested on a charge of second-degree murder with a firearm. In June 2024, a Marion County grand jury indicted him on a first-degree murder charge. That meant the state would have to convince jurors that the killing was premeditated, rather than simply proving an unlawful killing committed with a depraved state of mind. By trial, the prosecution’s theory centered on Watson’s decision to obtain the gun, enter the dispute and continue the confrontation as Coles moved away.

Defense attorney Julia Williamson told jurors that Watson’s actions had to be evaluated as those of a man who believed a threat was real. She described him as someone who was trying to protect others and highlighted evidence that he stayed to meet deputies rather than running. The defense also sought to place the shooting in the context of prior conflict involving Coles, the children’s mother and Watson. The prosecution countered that whatever tension existed before the shooting did not make an unarmed Coles a deadly threat at the moment Watson fired.

Jurors began deliberating at 3:23 p.m. on Oct. 8 after final arguments and instructions. By 4:57 p.m., they had informed court personnel they had reached a decision, according to trial reporting. The verdict was read shortly after 5 p.m.: guilty of premeditated first-degree murder. The relatively short deliberation ended a trial in which Watson’s own testimony had placed his state of mind squarely before the panel.

The case carried added weight because of where the confrontation happened. Students and relatives had gathered at North Marion Middle School to mark academic achievements. Sheriff Billy Woods said after the killing that the setting made the violence especially troubling because children had come to the school to be recognized for their work. State Attorney Bill Gladson returned to that point after the conviction, saying school grounds should be associated with learning and celebration rather than deadly violence. Authorities said no students were physically injured.

Coles was 32 and a father of four, according to family statements and published obituary information. His relatives publicly expressed their grief in the days after the killing and called for justice. Those statements stood apart from the legal question the jury eventually had to decide: not whether the shooting happened or who fired, but whether Watson’s fear made his actions lawful.

What ultimately decided the case was not whether Watson fired the shots, but whether jurors believed his explanation for doing so. After hearing him describe his fear and weighing that account against witness testimony and the physical evidence, the jury sided with prosecutors. His life sentence reflects that rejection of the defense theory at the heart of the trial.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.