Court records describe several pieces of evidence investigators say connect Jaymon Trey Gilreath to Noah Slinkard’s Oct. 8 shooting.
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — A man sitting beside Noah Slinkard told police he saw the shooting. Three other witnesses described what the accused man allegedly said beforehand. Investigators recovered a handgun, reviewed camera footage and documented a 911 call they attribute to the defendant. Together, those accounts form the early evidentiary framework of the murder case against Jaymon Trey Gilreath.
Gilreath, 23, has pleaded not guilty to murder in the Oct. 8 death of Slinkard, 24. The evidence described in a probable-cause affidavit and police reports was sufficient for authorities to arrest and charge him, but it has not yet been tested before a jury. The public record available so far presents several forms of evidence that investigators say converge on the same event: what a porch witness said he saw, what Gilreath’s companions recalled hearing, what Gilreath allegedly told emergency dispatchers and detectives, what police found along his route and what nearby cameras reportedly recorded.
The most direct account described by police came from the man who had been sitting with Slinkard outside a residence in the 1000 block of North Illinois Street. According to police, the witness said Gilreath approached on foot, pulled a handgun from his waist and shot Slinkard before leaving. Officers responding to reports of gunfire found Slinkard near the residence’s front doorway or porch with a gunshot wound to the head. Emergency crews took him to IU Health Bloomington Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 9:49 p.m. The Monroe County Coroner’s Office later released Slinkard’s identity.
A second strand of the case concerns what investigators say Gilreath communicated after the shooting. According to the probable-cause account reported by Indiana Public Media and other local outlets, Gilreath called 911 while officers were still responding and told dispatchers he had just shot someone. Police were already receiving information from callers who said the suspected shooter had left the residence and was walking east on West 13th Street. Officers located Gilreath at 8:23 p.m., about eight minutes after police said the initial shooting calls came in, and took him into custody without incident.
Investigators then developed physical evidence along the path police said Gilreath had taken. Officers found a 9 mm handgun in a holster near a park bench in the 1300 block of West 13th Street, beside Crestmont Park. Police said they believed the firearm had been used in the shooting. Later reporting on the affidavit said Gilreath told officers where he had thrown or left the gun. The publicly available accounts reviewed for this story do not describe final ballistics results, fingerprint testing, DNA testing or other forensic findings, meaning the full laboratory evidence, if any, has not been established in the public reporting.
The case also includes recordings that investigators say captured parts of the event. The probable-cause affidavit, as described in local reporting, says cameras in the area showed Gilreath shooting Slinkard and then leaving. That assertion could become significant because video can provide evidence independent of a witness’s memory or a defendant’s later account. However, the recordings themselves were not included in the reports reviewed for this article. Without the full footage, it is not possible to independently assess its quality, duration, angle or whether the defense may dispute what prosecutors say can be seen.
Investigators say three people who had been traveling with Gilreath supplied evidence about events immediately before the shooting. According to the affidavit, Gilreath was riding in a vehicle when he saw Slinkard on the porch and wanted to get out. He allegedly told the group he was going to fight Slinkard. The three witnesses also told police Gilreath made a statement to the effect that they should leave if they heard a gunshot. The witnesses said they heard a shot shortly afterward. Their accounts add a pre-shooting component to the prosecution narrative rather than describing only what happened after officers arrived.
Gilreath’s reported police interview provides a different category of evidence because it contains both admissions and claimed gaps in memory. He told investigators that he had a child with a woman with whom he had been in a relationship and believed she might be involved with Slinkard, according to the court filing. Gilreath reportedly said he had a “gut feeling” she was cheating after plans they had made fell through and she did not respond to calls or messages. He later saw her vehicle and then saw Slinkard outside, according to the affidavit.
But Gilreath reportedly told detectives he did not specifically remember the shooting itself. According to the filing, his next memory was leaving the residence and realizing he had his gun in his hand with the safety off, at which point he understood that he had shot Slinkard. That claimed memory gap does not resolve the case one way or the other. Prosecutors may rely on other evidence to establish what they believe occurred, while a defense attorney may scrutinize the circumstances and admissibility of Gilreath’s interview, the exact wording of his statements and how investigators interpreted them.
The collection of different evidence types matters because criminal trials rarely turn on a single police summary. Witnesses can be questioned about their ability to observe an event, consistency and prior statements. Recordings can be examined frame by frame. Firearms and other physical evidence can be tested and their chain of custody challenged. Statements to police can raise questions about warnings, voluntariness and context. None of those potential disputes has been resolved merely because a probable-cause affidavit describes evidence in a way that supported filing a charge.
Gilreath appeared at a preliminary hearing Oct. 12 and entered a not-guilty plea, according to Indiana Public Media. During that proceeding, he asked about being released to stay with his mother and children and mentioned that he had no prior felonies. Court Commissioner Bret Raper told him he was not eligible for bond in the murder case. Gilreath also asked about his right to remain silent as the court advised him of his rights, and a public defender was involved in the proceeding. The plea means the state still carries the burden of proving its allegation beyond a reasonable doubt.
The available record also leaves important questions unanswered. Public reporting has not established a full forensic analysis of the recovered handgun, released the surveillance recordings or provided a complete transcript of Gilreath’s police interview and 911 call. Nor does the reporting establish that Slinkard actually had a romantic relationship with the woman Gilreath believed he was seeing. That belief is described as part of the alleged motive investigators identified, not as an independently established fact about Slinkard’s personal life.
Reports published in October said Gilreath was scheduled for a bond review Oct. 27 and a pretrial conference Nov. 18. A search of reliable publicly indexed reporting through Nov. 20 did not locate a confirmed account of the outcome of those later proceedings or a final disposition of the case. The latest independently confirmed plea in the reviewed material remains not guilty, and the murder allegation remains pending rather than proved.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.