Ex-girlfriend kills Illinois man after she summoned to retrieve vehicle

Phillip Armstrong’s child was 10 when he was killed and 13 when the woman convicted of his murder returned to court for sentencing.

EDWARDSVILLE, Ill. — Three years after Phillip Armstrong was shot dead while retrieving a vehicle from his former girlfriend’s home, his daughter stood before a Madison County judge and described how losing her father had altered the course of her childhood. Minutes later, Circuit Judge Amy Maher sentenced Tara A. Anderson to 55 years in prison for Armstrong’s murder.

The Oct. 6 hearing marked the final major stage of a case that began when Armstrong, 39, was found dead in a Granite City roadway on Sept. 24, 2023. His daughter was 10 at the time. By sentencing, she was 13 and told the court that milestones in her life had become reminders that her father would not be there to share them. Armstrong’s identical twin brother, Patrick Armstrong, also submitted a victim-impact statement. Their accounts placed the focus of the hearing on the long-term effects of the killing after months of trial arguments had centered on Anderson’s intent and her claim that she had fired only a warning shot.

That claim did not persuade the jury. Anderson had testified that she meant to scare Armstrong away rather than hit him. Prosecutors presented a different account, arguing that the evidence showed the shooting followed threats and an escalating confrontation. Armstrong had come to Anderson’s home because she asked him to retrieve a vehicle, according to evidence presented at trial. He was attempting to load it onto a trailer when Anderson confronted him, went back inside the residence, returned with a .45-caliber handgun and fired toward him. The shot passed through a wooden privacy fence and struck Armstrong from roughly 100 feet away.

For Armstrong’s family, the legal debate over intent unfolded against a loss that began the night police were called to the 1400 block of Madison Avenue. Officers found Armstrong dead in the roadway. Early reports identified the shooting as an isolated domestic incident and described Anderson and Armstrong as having been in a dating relationship. A fundraiser organized days later for Armstrong’s daughter said the family planned to support the girl and preserve memories of her father. At that point, the criminal case had barely begun. Anderson had been arrested, and prosecutors had filed murder counts and firearm-related charges while investigators continued assembling evidence.

Police accounts later provided a clearer picture of what investigators said happened around the time of the shooting. One witness told authorities he was with Armstrong when Anderson came outside and began yelling at him. That witness said Anderson then moved back toward the house and he heard one gunshot. Another witness told police that Anderson came from the home with a firearm and made a statement that she intended to kill Armstrong. Investigators recovered a .45-caliber shell casing from Anderson’s porch. They also found a .45-caliber handgun in the basement, and police said Anderson’s fingerprint was found on the magazine.

Nearly three years later, those pieces of evidence helped shape the murder trial held before Maher in May. Assistant State’s Attorneys Morgan Hudson and Lauren Maricle told jurors that Anderson had expressed a desire to kill Armstrong before the shooting. Prosecutors said a witness heard her make another threat only minutes before the gun was fired. Anderson’s attorney, David Fahrenkamp, argued that the fatal result did not establish that Anderson intended to kill Armstrong. The defense characterized the shot as an attempt to frighten him. Anderson herself testified that she had fired a warning shot. Jurors deliberated a little more than three hours before convicting her of first-degree murder.

The verdict transformed the legal question facing Armstrong’s family. Before May, the state still had to prove Anderson guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. After the conviction, the issue became how long she would be imprisoned. The sentencing range was severe because the murder conviction carried a lengthy term on its own and use of a firearm added substantial time. Maher ultimately imposed 30 years for the murder and another 25 years tied to the firearm, for a combined 55-year sentence. Local reporting said Anderson must serve the sentence in full.

Prosecutors asked Maher to impose more than 55 years and argued that the killing should not be viewed in isolation from Anderson’s history. Hudson told the judge that Anderson had two felony drug convictions among a broader record that included misdemeanor and traffic cases, battery charges and protection orders. She also said Anderson had fired a gun at Armstrong on an earlier occasion and had once fired at a different former boyfriend. The state used that history to argue that the September 2023 shooting reflected a pattern of turning to a firearm in volatile relationships rather than a single inexplicable mistake.

The defense urged a different view of Anderson’s life and asked for 45 years. Fahrenkamp told the judge that such a term already meant Anderson could be in her 80s by the time she left prison. He described a troubled upbringing and said Anderson had experienced post-traumatic stress disorder and other difficulties. Those arguments did not challenge the jury’s authority to return the murder verdict; instead, they asked Maher to consider personal circumstances when deciding punishment. Fahrenkamp had also sought a new trial, but Maher rejected that motion before imposing the sentence.

Anderson addressed the court herself before learning her punishment. She apologized and said she had never intended for the killing to happen. That statement echoed the position her defense had taken at trial, but it came after the jury had already rejected the argument that the shooting was merely an unintended consequence of a warning shot. Prosecutors had emphasized that Armstrong was where Anderson expected him to be because she had asked him to come retrieve the vehicle. They also pointed to the direction of the shot and the threats described by witnesses as evidence that the shooting was intentional.

The 55-year sentence cannot answer every question Armstrong’s daughter will face as she grows older, but it does establish the criminal consequence for the act that killed her father. At sentencing, her statement moved the case beyond the physical evidence and courtroom arguments. She told the judge that her father’s absence would be felt at milestones still years away. Her uncle described his twin as kind and loving. Those statements gave the court a record not only of how Armstrong died, but of the relationships that ended with his death.

Madison County State’s Attorney Tom Haine said after sentencing that no punishment could undo the family’s loss. He said the sentence nevertheless held Anderson accountable for a killing a jury had determined was murder. The Granite City Police Department led the investigation, with other agencies assisting during the case. Anderson’s prison term now extends for decades beyond the conclusion of the trial, while Armstrong’s family moves forward without the man whose death brought them into the criminal justice system in 2023.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.