PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A man who was convicted of a violent crime against an elderly woman more than four decades ago is now poised to receive another opportunity for rehabilitation, despite a troubled history marked by substance abuse. David Sibinich, now 65, faces ongoing challenges but has garnered the attention of the Massachusetts Parole Board, which has suggested a potential path forward.
Sibinich’s criminal past began on December 15, 1980, when police discovered him in the home of 80-year-old Esther Berenholc. The elderly woman was found bound and beaten, her injuries indicative of a brutal attack. She reported to officers that Sibinich had attempted to suffocate her with a pillow before restraining her. The scene showed signs of violence, with both blood and pillow stuffing strewn across the room. In a troubling twist, police found a diamond ring belonging to Berenholc in Sibinich’s pocket, though he claimed she had given it to him.
Berenholc died of natural causes less than two months after the incident. Following a trial in March 1982, Sibinich was convicted of multiple charges, including armed robbery and assault with intent to murder, leading to a life sentence with the possibility of parole.
Sibinich first came up for parole in 1996 but was denied. He faced several hearings in the years that followed, resulting in his release in 2007. However, this freedom was short-lived, as he returned to prison for violations related to his parole in 2012. He was again granted parole in 2020, only to face further setbacks, landing back in custody in 2024.
More recently, on August 6, 2025, Sibinich attended a parole review hearing where board members noted his lack of violent behavior since his incarceration. However, they acknowledged his ongoing struggle with substance use, identifying it as a crucial issue that must be addressed. The board emphasized the importance of Sibinich committing to sobriety, a sentiment voiced during the hearing.
Berkshire County Assistant District Attorney Joseph Pieropan opposed Sibinich’s release, reflecting the concerns of many regarding his past. Nonetheless, the parole board expressed confidence in the re-entry plan presented by Sibinich, highlighting its focus on essential areas that require attention as he prepares to reintegrate into society.
In a unanimous decision, the board granted Sibinich parole, set to take effect on January 21. Following the approval, Sibinich is expected to participate in a Long-Term Residential Program, with Soldier On being a preferred option, contingent upon clearance from the district attorney’s office. This latest chapter in his life underscores the complexities of parole, as he navigates the challenges of recovery and the expectations of a society that remains cautious.