Fugitive emerges from woods with two knives near sheriff’s mom

Comer McWaters’ death in Alabama custody closes off a prosecution that followed an unusual interstate arrest by a Mississippi sheriff.

MONTGOMERY, Ala. — The man charged with murdering a Georgia woman whose disappearance led investigators from Columbus to rural Alabama and eventually Mississippi died in custody before his case could reach trial, authorities said. Comer McWaters, 68, died Nov. 14 at Baptist South Hospital in Montgomery after being transferred there from jail, according to Macon County Coroner Hal Bentley. McWaters had been accused of killing 49-year-old Eden Sexton, who vanished from Columbus in February.

McWaters’ death changes the legal course of a case that had only recently reached the charging stage. He had been extradited to Alabama after his Sept. 21 capture in Perry County, Mississippi, where Sheriff Jacob Garner encountered him near the home of Garner’s mother after deputies had searched unsuccessfully for him in nearby woods. McWaters was formally charged with murder after his return to Alabama. Because he died before trial, the allegation against him was never tested before a jury, and no court determined that he was guilty of Sexton’s death.

Officials have released only limited information about McWaters’ final days. Macon County Sheriff Andre Brunson said McWaters was being detained in Montgomery so investigators with the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency’s State Bureau of Investigation could interview him. Brunson said McWaters was taken from jail to the hospital and underwent two surgeries. Authorities did not immediately disclose the condition that led to his hospitalization. Bentley said the body was sent to the Alabama Department of Forensic Science, where a medical examiner was expected to determine the official cause and manner of death.

The unanswered questions surrounding McWaters’ death now sit beside the unresolved questions in Sexton’s homicide investigation. Alabama authorities have not publicly explained how Sexton died, what motive they believe may have existed or the exact nature of her relationship with McWaters. They also have not released a detailed summary of the evidence that persuaded investigators to seek a murder warrant. Friends and relatives have publicly described possible forensic evidence and earlier interactions between Sexton and McWaters, but state investigators have not confirmed every detail contained in those accounts.

Sexton was last seen months before McWaters became a publicly identified murder suspect. The Columbus Police Department said she was last known to be in the 4000 block of Victory Drive at about 11 a.m. Feb. 22. Her disappearance was reported Feb. 27, and police asked the public to help locate her. The department said she was 49, stood about 5 feet 5 inches tall and weighed about 220 pounds, with blond hair and brown eyes. The investigation was initially treated publicly as a search for a missing person.

By June, the investigation had crossed the state line. Columbus police asked Alabama’s State Bureau of Investigation to assist after McWaters, of the Little Texas community in Macon County, was identified as a person of interest. Alabama agents opened their own missing-person investigation. Officials later said those agents developed evidence that resulted in a murder warrant for McWaters. The transition from a missing-person investigation to a murder case was significant, but authorities did not accompany the announcement with a detailed account of what evidence established that Sexton was dead or tied McWaters to her death.

McWaters, meanwhile, surfaced in Mississippi under circumstances unrelated to the public chronology of the homicide investigation. On Sept. 21, the Perry County Sheriff’s Office received a report that a man from Alabama had recently been living in the Buck Creek community and was believed to be using another name to avoid arrest. Deputies did not initially know, according to local accounts, that the man was wanted on an Alabama murder warrant. When a deputy went to the area to contact him, authorities said McWaters ran into the woods and disappeared.

The next development came not during a planned tactical operation but during Garner’s visit with his mother. The sheriff was in the same rural community when he saw McWaters emerge from the wooded area and move toward the private driveway near his mother’s home. Garner recognized him from the earlier search. Authorities said McWaters had two large knives and resisted when the sheriff attempted to take him into custody. A physical struggle followed, and Garner disarmed and arrested him. The accounts released by authorities did not report gunfire during the confrontation.

Mississippi authorities initially had their own charges to address. McWaters was accused there of trespassing, disorderly conduct, assault on an officer, resisting arrest and giving false identifying information to police. Once officers positively identified him and checked his information, they learned of the Alabama homicide warrant. He was held in Perry County while extradition was arranged. The arrest provided the first public connection between the unusual Mississippi encounter and the months-long investigation into Sexton’s disappearance in Georgia and Alabama.

Public statements from Sexton’s family and friends later added detail that investigators have not fully adopted in official announcements. Family members said evidence linked Sexton to McWaters’ property and vehicle. Other accounts said she had been staying at a motel near the time she disappeared and had been seen leaving with an older man. McWaters also was reported to have said Sexton got out of his vehicle following an argument. Because those details have not all been independently confirmed by Alabama investigators, they do not establish on their own what occurred after Sexton was last seen.

What Alabama officials have confirmed is narrower. Investigators considered McWaters a person of interest, developed evidence during the State Bureau of Investigation inquiry and obtained a warrant accusing him of murder. What they have not publicly shown is the complete evidentiary path from Sexton’s disappearance to that charge. There has been no publicly released narrative describing the location or circumstances of her death, no announced motive and no complete forensic inventory. Those omissions would ordinarily be addressed over time through court filings, hearings and potentially a trial.

McWaters’ death means that process will not occur against him. Prosecutors will not present a criminal case to a jury seeking a verdict on the murder accusation, and McWaters will not have an opportunity to challenge the evidence through a trial defense. His death therefore leaves the public record with probable cause sufficient for an arrest warrant and formal charge, but without an adjudication. Authorities have not announced another suspect, and available reports do not establish that anyone else has been charged in connection with Sexton’s death.

That distinction is especially important in describing the case after McWaters’ death. An arrest warrant and murder charge represented the conclusions investigators and prosecutors had reached at that stage of the inquiry, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Had the case continued, court proceedings could have exposed more of the underlying evidence and allowed defense attorneys to challenge it. McWaters’ death prevents that adversarial process from occurring, leaving official investigative claims in the public record without the final judgment a criminal trial normally provides.

For investigators, two separate matters now remain capable of generating additional findings. The Alabama Department of Forensic Science is expected to determine how McWaters died after his hospitalization while in custody. Separately, investigators could still release additional information about Sexton’s disappearance and death, even though the prosecution of McWaters cannot proceed. Officials had described the homicide inquiry as ongoing before his death, and there has been no public announcement that every investigative question has been resolved.

The unusual arrest that first drew broad attention to the case remains only one part of a longer story. A resident’s tip about an alias brought deputies to McWaters’ location, his flight sent officers into the woods, and a chance encounter near the sheriff’s mother’s home ended the search. But the later death of the accused man shifts the focus from capture to unresolved evidence. Sexton’s family is left without the verdict that a criminal trial might have produced, while authorities still have not publicly answered central questions about how she died or what happened after she disappeared Feb. 22.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.