Investigators say Sandra Antolick’s communications suggest she knew her mother had died hours before the time she later reported.
VALPARAISO, Ind. — A series of overnight and morning phone calls has become a key part of the criminal case against an Indiana woman accused of neglecting her 93-year-old mother until complications from severe pressure wounds caused her death.
Investigators allege that Sandra Antolick, 62, gave authorities an account of her mother JoAnne Antolick’s final hours that did not match evidence recovered from her phone or information supplied by a co-worker. Sandra said her mother had been alive into the late morning, became unresponsive after vomiting and died around 11:30 a.m., according to reports citing court documents. Police say Sandra’s phone activity began much earlier and that a co-worker reported being told of JoAnne’s death by about 8:30 a.m. The disputed timeline is one element of a broader case alleging that Sandra failed to obtain medical treatment despite being responsible for her mother’s care.
The phone evidence reached back to about 3 a.m., when Sandra allegedly made several calls. One was to a co-worker who was asleep and did not answer, according to the probable cause affidavit as reported by Law&Crime. The co-worker returned the call at about 8:30 that morning. Investigators say Sandra then told the co-worker that her mother was dead and made statements indicating she believed she was in serious trouble. The same witness told police that Sandra wanted other people to say JoAnne had died around 11 or 11:30 a.m. Those statements are allegations attributed to the witness and investigators; the available reports do not include testimony tested under cross-examination.
Sandra’s own reported version was different. She allegedly told police her mother had been vomiting but could still eat, drink and communicate before becoming unresponsive late in the morning. Sandra said she was shocked after the death and did not immediately contact emergency services. Instead, authorities say, she called a funeral home. The funeral home told her to call 911. Police ultimately arrived at the Valparaiso residence at about 1:40 p.m., according to reports, though the published sources differ over whether that response occurred Sept. 15 or Sept. 16, 2025. Local reporting citing charging documents places JoAnne’s death on Sept. 15; Law&Crime’s account of the affidavit gives Sept. 16 for the police response.
What officers found shifted the inquiry from a routine death call toward an investigation of possible neglect. JoAnne was in a living-room recliner, where Sandra said her mother had been sleeping because she could no longer walk. Police described a strong odor from spoiled food, trash and mildew. Clutter covered much of the living room, and investigators said bedrooms and the second floor could not be accessed normally. There was no running water in the house. The refrigerator did not work and contained spoiled food. Sandra reportedly slept on the living-room floor near her mother because other parts of the home were blocked by accumulated belongings and debris.
The autopsy then provided evidence that authorities say made the lack of medical intervention especially significant. JoAnne had extensive pressure wounds, also known as bedsores or pressure ulcers, on multiple parts of her body. Some extended to the bone, according to the court records described in both reports. A forensic pathologist said the injuries would have caused substantial pain. The listed cause of death was complications from extensive ulcerative wounds that resulted in infection. The medical findings gave investigators a basis to examine not only what happened on the morning JoAnne died but also what care she had received during the preceding weeks, months and years.
Sandra told police that she had been her mother’s sole caregiver for several years. She also allegedly said JoAnne had not seen a doctor for five or six years. Although her mother was unable to walk, Sandra portrayed her as eating and drinking and having few other complaints, according to the local report. She said she changed dressings on wounds and claimed the pressure sores had appeared only about a week before the death. Investigators disputed that estimate. Police said the severity, size and bleeding associated with the wounds indicated they had been present longer than Sandra described and that the care being provided had not been adequate to address them.
JoAnne’s limited mobility appears throughout the investigative account. Sandra said her mother had fallen and injured an arm and was difficult to move. She compared the injured arm to a bird with a damaged wing, according to the affidavit. That inability to move independently is significant because the prosecution alleges JoAnne was dependent on Sandra to recognize worsening conditions and obtain outside treatment. Authorities have not accused Sandra merely of failing to cure wounds herself. Their case, as publicly described, is that she did not seek professional care despite circumstances that investigators contend should have made the need for medical help apparent.
Police also cited Sandra’s employment history. Investigators said she had spent more than 25 years working as a radiological technician at a local hospital. They argued in the affidavit that her professional experience would have given her knowledge that her mother’s condition required attention. The reports reviewed do not identify Sandra’s workplace, describe her exact duties or suggest that any hospital participated in JoAnne’s care. Her medical employment is presented in the charging narrative as evidence bearing on what Sandra allegedly understood, not as an allegation against the institution where she worked.
The living arrangements had changed shortly before JoAnne’s death. One local account says mother and daughter had used a small studio apartment next to the house because the residence itself lacked water and were later evicted. Law&Crime reported that they had been living in the house for about a month after an eviction from an apartment described as too cluttered. By the time officers arrived, investigators said the home itself was heavily obstructed. The details matter because prosecutors are relying on the physical environment alongside the medical evidence and communications to describe the conditions in which JoAnne spent her final period of life.
More than a year passed between the death and Sandra’s arrest in October 2026. Publicly available reports do not provide a complete explanation for that interval. The case described in the charging records, however, involved an autopsy, review of wound severity, multiple interviews, Sandra’s statements, a co-worker’s account and analysis of phone activity. When charges were filed, local reporting said Sandra faced Level 3 and Level 5 felony counts of neglect of a dependent as well as a Class C misdemeanor count of resisting arrest. Law&Crime reported that she was being held on an $11,000 bond.
The contested chronology could ultimately matter because it speaks to both Sandra’s credibility and investigators’ effort to determine what she knew and when she knew it. A discrepancy in time does not by itself prove criminal neglect, and the prosecution must establish the elements of the charged offenses in court. Likewise, the co-worker’s statements remain part of the state’s account unless admitted and evaluated in the judicial process. The public reports reviewed do not contain a substantive response from Sandra or a defense attorney addressing the phone evidence, the medical findings or the allegation that she failed to seek treatment.
Whether the disputed phone calls become important at trial will depend on how prosecutors use them alongside the medical findings and Sandra Antolick’s statements to investigators. The reviewed reports do not show that a court has resolved when JoAnne Antolick died or accepted either account of her final hours. No subsequent case outcome was located, leaving those conflicts to be tested through the criminal proceedings rather than settled by the allegations in the affidavit.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.