Reyes made it outside after her boyfriend blocked the door, but prosecutors said the 24-year-old returned to collect her possessions.
VILLA PARK, Ill. — Before the fatal violence inside a suburban Chicago apartment, Jessica Reyes had already gotten away. Prosecutors said the 24-year-old climbed down from a third-floor balcony because her boyfriend, Anthony Jimenez, was blocking the door. More than two years later, Jimenez has been sentenced to 55 years in prison for killing her after she returned to get her belongings.
That brief period outside the apartment is one of the defining facts in the case that ended with Jimenez’s Oct. 15 sentencing. Authorities said Reyes and Jimenez had been arguing on the morning of July 17, 2024, and that she resorted to the balcony because he would not allow her to use the door. Jimenez later followed her into the parking lot. They spoke, the confrontation appeared to settle, and Reyes went upstairs again so she could collect her property. She never left the apartment alive.
The argument had begun at about 8 a.m. at Jimenez’s residence in the 1600 block of South Michigan Avenue, according to the DuPage County State’s Attorney’s Office. Early court filings later reported by local news organizations said Reyes went to her car after climbing out and that Jimenez followed her. Those filings also said she eventually returned for items that included her phone. Prosecutors’ later sentencing account summarized the sequence more simply: the argument calmed outside, and the couple went back into the apartment so Reyes could gather her belongings.
Inside, the dispute resumed. Prosecutors said that while Reyes was collecting her things, Jimenez pulled a knife from his pocket and stabbed her in the side of the head. Reyes fought back. The attack continued, with injuries to her neck, face, arms, chest and hands, according to authorities. The state’s attorney’s office said Jimenez stopped when his mother entered the room. The official account released after sentencing did not provide a broader explanation for the violence beyond the domestic confrontation between the couple.
Contemporary court records supplied more information about what investigators believed was said before the attack. Those records stated that Jimenez had accused Reyes of being unfaithful and that, after she returned to the apartment, she told him she thought they should take a three-month break from the relationship. The records said she was getting items from a closet when the attack began. Those descriptions came from early filings in a criminal case and were allegations at that stage. Jimenez ultimately pleaded guilty to first-degree murder rather than contesting the charge at trial.
The emergency response began at about 10:50 a.m. Prosecutors said Jimenez told a dispatcher during the 911 call that he had stabbed his girlfriend in the neck. Earlier court reporting indicated that his mother had initially called 911 before Jimenez took the phone and spoke with the dispatcher. When Villa Park officers reached the apartment, they encountered Jimenez at the door with apparent blood on his hands and chest and placed him in custody. Officers then entered the home and found Reyes in a rear bedroom.
Police provided aid until paramedics arrived. Reyes was taken to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead at approximately 11:26 a.m. The state’s attorney’s office said the fatal sequence began with the argument at about 8 a.m., meaning the escape, return and killing all occurred during a period of less than four hours. The timing is important because it shows that the violence did not follow a long separation between the couple. Authorities said the confrontation eased only briefly before the two went back upstairs.
Jimenez was arrested and initially charged with two counts of first-degree murder. On July 19, 2024, Judge Joshua Dieden ordered him held before trial after prosecutors asked the court to deny release. Dieden wrote that the circumstances described by the state showed a level of danger that could not be adequately controlled through conditions of release. Jimenez remained in the DuPage County Jail while the case proceeded. At that point, he was legally presumed innocent and the state still would have been required to prove its case if the prosecution had gone to trial.
That changed on May 8, 2026. Jimenez, then 28, voluntarily pleaded guilty to one count of first-degree murder, according to prosecutors. The plea established his criminal responsibility for Reyes’ death and moved the case into its sentencing phase. Five months later, DuPage County Judge Mia McPherson sentenced him to 55 years in the Illinois Department of Corrections. Prosecutors said he must serve 100% of that term before becoming eligible for parole, making the sentence substantially different from one in which a prisoner may receive earlier release through ordinary sentence credits.
The sentencing announcement also brought renewed attention to the person at the center of the case. Reyes’ relatives described her on a fundraising page as selfless, resilient and playful. They said she had spent six years serving in the military and had become a veteran before her death. Their description emphasized how she helped others and the relationships she left behind. The criminal case necessarily focused on the hours leading to her killing, but the family’s account presented a broader picture of a 24-year-old whose life had included years of military service.
State’s Attorney Robert Berlin issued his sentencing statement during Domestic Violence Awareness Month. He said people should not have to live in fear of a spouse, partner or other family member and called Reyes’ death a stark example of the potential consequences of domestic violence. He also expressed sympathy to her family and friends. Berlin’s office thanked the prosecutors who handled the case and emphasized that the sentence followed Jimenez’s guilty plea rather than a trial verdict.
The unusual manner in which Reyes first escaped is not merely a dramatic detail in the record. Prosecutors said the normal way out of the apartment had been denied to her because Jimenez was blocking the door. Her decision to climb from the third floor established that she had physically separated herself from the apartment before the killing. Authorities then documented why she went back: the confrontation appeared to have calmed, and she returned to retrieve her property. Nothing in the sentencing announcement suggested that she expected the encounter to become fatal after she re-entered the residence.
By the time McPherson imposed the sentence, Jimenez had spent more than two years in custody. The court’s order now places him under a 55-year prison term that prosecutors say must be served in full. No trial remains scheduled because of his guilty plea. For Reyes’ family, the sentencing resolves the principal criminal case, while the record of what happened on July 17, 2024, remains centered on a woman who got out of the apartment once, returned for her possessions and was killed before she could leave again.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.