Digital evidence and forensic findings connected an Indianapolis man to a homicide that began as an early-morning vehicle-fire call.
MUNCIE, Ind. — When Delaware County deputies reached a burning car in a rural field before dawn on Dec. 14, 2025, they did not yet know the name of the person inside or how the vehicle had arrived there. Ten months later, Randal Moon Jr. was sentenced to 86 years in prison after a jury concluded that the Indianapolis man was criminally responsible for his role in the killing of Michael D. Greer.
The path from the scorched rental car to Moon’s conviction depended on evidence collected well beyond the fire scene. Investigators used forensic findings, interviews, surveillance recordings, cellphone information and records of the defendants’ movements to reconstruct what prosecutors described as a chain of events stretching from an Indianapolis residence to southern Delaware County and later back to Greer’s Shelbyville home. Moon admitted he drove to the rural area and took two co-defendants back to Indianapolis, but he told jurors he did not know Greer was hidden in the other vehicle or that it was going to be burned. The jury found him guilty on all five counts it considered.
The first physical clue was the vehicle itself. Deputies had been dispatched about 3:45 a.m. after someone reported a car fire near County Road 500 South west of Indiana 3. Once authorities were able to inspect the burned vehicle, they found a person’s remains in the trunk. The identity was not immediately established publicly. Final DNA testing by the Indiana State Police later confirmed that the victim was Greer, 58, of Shelbyville. Sheriff Jeff Stanley said in January that investigators had worked with the county coroner and prosecutor’s office while conducting interviews and examining evidence. By then, five people had been arrested in connection with the death.
The autopsy told investigators something the fire scene alone could not: Greer had been alive when the vehicle was ignited. Authorities said soot was found in his lungs and trachea, indicating he was breathing as the fire burned. Investigators also determined that he had been beaten and shot before he reached the rural field. Rather than treating the vehicle as the location where the entire crime occurred, detectives traced the case backward. Their investigation pointed to a residence in Indianapolis, where prosecutors said Greer was assaulted before being transported out of the city. Reporting on the case said investigators recovered a deleted recording showing a beating at the residence on the evening before the fire.
Digital records then helped investigators place Moon within that timeline. At a March bond hearing, Delaware County sheriff’s deputies testified that surveillance recordings showed Moon interacting with co-defendants Amy Singhas and Ameariss Aponte at convenience stores in Indianapolis and Daleville during the early hours of Dec. 14. Moon was traveling in a pickup truck while Singhas and Aponte were in the vehicle that would later burn, according to testimony summarized in the judge’s order. Investigators also reviewed communications between Singhas and Moon that they interpreted as referring to a body that needed to be disposed of. Judge Judi L. Calhoun cited evidence presented by investigators when she refused to set bond for Moon.
The trial months later put the prosecution’s reconstruction before jurors. Cellphone location data placed Moon at the Indianapolis home when prosecutors said Greer was being beaten. The state did not claim that a video of the beating visibly showed Moon participating in the assault. Instead, prosecutors used location data and other conduct to argue that his presence and later actions were part of a larger course of participation. That distinction became important because Moon took the witness stand and denied knowing the critical facts that would make his trip to Delaware County criminal. He acknowledged traveling behind the other vehicle but said he did not know Greer was in its trunk.
There was no similar dispute about what Moon did after reaching Delaware County. Moon acknowledged that he was at the rural location and later drove Singhas and Aponte back to Indianapolis after the rental car was set on fire. His defense argued that this did not prove he understood what was happening beforehand. Prosecutors said the circumstances made that explanation implausible. Deputy Prosecutor Maricel Driscoll characterized Moon to jurors as far more than an incidental driver and argued that the evidence showed his involvement from the beginning through the aftermath. The state sought to connect the trip to a pattern of conduct rather than ask jurors to judge the drive in isolation.
Other evidence focused on Greer’s property and Moon’s actions after the homicide. Trial reporting said Moon photographed Greer’s credit card on the morning of Dec. 14 and later tried to use the card at a Menards store. Prosecutors also presented evidence that Moon accompanied Singhas and Aponte to Greer’s Shelbyville residence two days after Greer died. Cellphone evidence became relevant again when prosecutors challenged Moon’s claim that he did not initially know the fire had killed anyone. They said records showed he had viewed and photographed news coverage of the homicide. Each piece addressed a different part of the prosecution’s theory: what Moon knew, where he went and what he did after Greer’s death.
The jury received the case after a trial that began Sept. 14. After deliberating for several hours on Sept. 18, jurors convicted Moon of murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Some court reporting described the murder-related verdict under Indiana’s aiding, inducing or causing liability, reflecting the prosecution’s position that a person can bear criminal responsibility for helping carry out an offense even when the evidence does not establish that he personally committed every physical act. The verdict meant jurors rejected Moon’s central claim that he had accompanied the others without knowing the nature of the crime.
Calhoun sentenced Moon on Oct. 13. The resulting 86-year term made him the first of the five defendants in Greer’s case to reach both a conviction and sentencing. Delaware County Prosecuting Attorney Eric Hoffman credited Chief Deputy Prosecutor Zach Craig, Driscoll, investigators and sheriff’s personnel after the verdict and said justice had been served. The sentence followed a prosecution in which physical evidence from the car supplied only the starting point. The state’s case broadened as detectives tied together activity in Indianapolis, the trip to Delaware County and conduct during the days after Greer’s death.
The four other defendants — Singhas, Aponte, Megan Sloan and Tallis McCoy — were charged separately in connection with Greer’s death. Investigators alleged Singhas drove Greer toward Delaware County in the rental car and that Aponte later drove the vehicle off the road near the site where it burned. Earlier reports said Singhas and Aponte made statements acknowledging parts of the trip. Sloan and McCoy were arrested later in the investigation. Those claims remain allegations in any unresolved cases, and Moon’s guilty verdict does not establish the guilt of another defendant. Each person whose case remains unresolved retains the presumption of innocence.
The evidence developed against Moon has not publicly answered every question surrounding Greer’s killing. Authorities have not established a verified motive in the public reporting reviewed for this article. Greer’s family previously said he had been in a relationship with Singhas, but that relationship does not by itself explain what led to his death. What the investigation did establish at Moon’s trial was a chronology strong enough to persuade jurors that he knowingly participated in the crimes for which he was charged. His own admissions placed him at important points in that chronology, while prosecutors relied on digital and circumstantial evidence to argue that he knew far more than he acknowledged.
Moon is now serving an 86-year prison sentence while the broader case continues through the Delaware County court system. The latest reliable reports before Nov. 20 listed additional proceedings for the remaining defendants, although some previously reported court dates have passed without a verified public outcome available in the material reviewed here. A Dec. 14 jury trial had been listed for McCoy. Until the remaining cases are resolved, Moon’s conviction stands as the first completed test in court of the evidence produced by the investigation that began at the burning rental car.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.