Indianapolis man allegedly stabbed mom and stepdad with garden tools before waiting for cops in underwear

David White faces three felony counts as court records offer a fuller account of the hours and concerns preceding his parents’ deaths.

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — The criminal case against David White has advanced from an emergency response at his family’s home to formal felony charges, with prosecutors accusing the 38-year-old Indianapolis man of murdering his mother and stepfather and trying to attack a neighbor who intervened.

White is charged with two counts of murder in the deaths of Cynthia Pottle, 75, and Robert Pottle Jr., 80, as well as attempted battery by means of a deadly weapon. He was ordered held without bond after appearing in Marion County court, and local court reporting identified Dec. 17 as his next scheduled court date. The charges mark an important change from the earliest reports of the Oct. 11 killings, when White had been arrested on preliminary allegations while prosecutors reviewed the investigation. The state must still prove its case in court, and the filing of charges does not establish guilt.

The prosecution’s case is built in part around what police say happened outside the Pottles’ Lakeshire Lane home shortly before officers arrived. According to accounts of the probable-cause documents, a neighbor heard an unusual noise and went outside, where he saw Robert Pottle being attacked. The witness told investigators he moved toward White, who retreated into the house. Cynthia Pottle then appeared and the witness placed an emergency call. White allegedly returned carrying a shovel and a kitchen knife. Police say the neighbor took the shovel away during the confrontation, but White continued the attack with the knife and later went back inside. Prosecutors’ attempted-battery charge is tied to allegations arising from that intervention.

When police reached the property just after 12:20 p.m., they confronted two separate scenes. Robert Pottle was outside with critical injuries. Emergency crews transported him to a hospital, but he died later. Cynthia Pottle was found inside the residence and pronounced dead there. Investigators documented several objects they believed could be relevant evidence. Reports on the court filings say a knife and shovel were found near Robert Pottle, while a smaller garden shovel and garden shears with apparent blood were located inside near Cynthia Pottle. An open jug of bleach was also reported near the outdoor scene. The significance of those items remains a matter for the criminal case, and their presence alone does not establish every detail alleged by prosecutors.

White’s arrest itself was comparatively uneventful after the violence described by witnesses. Police found him in a bathroom inside the residence, according to court reporting. He was wet and had removed most of his clothing, leaving him in his underwear. Officers took him into custody without another reported confrontation. That detail drew attention in initial coverage, but the later charging records placed greater emphasis on witness testimony, recovered objects and the history investigators gathered from relatives. When detectives sought an interview, authorities said White did not answer substantive questions about the deaths. Instead, he asserted that Cynthia and Robert Pottle had been holding him against his will, an allegation investigators recorded but did not publicly corroborate.

The formal case also includes information about the Pottle family’s growing concern before Oct. 11. White’s half-sister told detectives that relatives had become worried about changes in his behavior and increasing aggression toward his parents, according to reports based on the court documents. Investigators were told he had stopped taking medication and had not completed a mental health evaluation ordered through a Hamilton County court. The records also describe beliefs attributed to White, including a claim that a newly installed heating and air-conditioning system was being used to poison him. Authorities have not said those beliefs were true, and they should not be treated as established explanations for the deaths.

The distinction matters because a criminal prosecution and questions about mental health follow different evidentiary paths. Police may document a person’s behavior, family observations and prior crisis contacts as part of an investigation, but those reports do not by themselves establish a psychiatric diagnosis or resolve whether a defendant is legally competent or criminally responsible. No public finding cited in the available reporting has resolved such questions in White’s case. Prosecutors are proceeding with murder allegations, while any competency or mental-state issue that becomes legally relevant would have to be addressed through the appropriate court procedures. The state’s accusations therefore remain focused on conduct the government says can be proved through witnesses, physical evidence and records.

Police had encountered the family before the killings. IMPD spokesperson Tommy Thompson said the department’s Mobile Crisis Assistance Team previously went to the Lakeshire Lane home in connection with concerns about White. That team combines law enforcement response with behavioral health expertise. The department did not initially provide a complete account of what occurred during every earlier visit, whether White accepted services or what follow-up occurred afterward. The existence of those calls became more significant after investigators learned that Cynthia Pottle had been trying to obtain additional help because she believed the living arrangement was becoming unsafe.

A text message recovered during the homicide investigation gave police a narrow glimpse into the final period before officers were called. According to court records cited by local reports, Cynthia Pottle contacted her husband around noon and asked him to return home because she was concerned about White. The emergency call reporting violence came soon afterward. Investigators also learned from relatives that Cynthia had been looking into a formal intervention related to White’s mental condition because of the family’s fears. The records do not establish that she anticipated a fatal attack, but the message and relatives’ statements show that concern inside the household had reached an urgent level before the deaths.

The legal filing also clarifies the identities and relationships that were still emerging when police first arrived. Cynthia Pottle was White’s mother. Robert Pottle Jr. was his stepfather. Early law-enforcement statements referred generally to two victims believed to be White’s parents while authorities completed notifications and gathered evidence. The Marion County investigation later produced the more detailed account that formed the basis of the formal charges. Police and prosecutors have not publicly announced a conventional motive, and the court documents described in news reports do not establish a single proven reason for the alleged attacks.

Community reaction initially centered on the deaths themselves. Residents described the Pottles as longtime neighbors and expressed shock that a violent confrontation had occurred on the normally quiet street. City-County Councilor Leroy Robinson offered condolences to their family, friends and neighbors, noting that the impact extended into the surrounding community. Police said they believed the event was isolated rather than part of a continuing threat. The neighbor’s reported effort to intervene also became an important element of the case, not only because of the risk he faced but because his firsthand account helped detectives reconstruct events that occurred before police reached the house.

White remained in the Marion County Jail without bond as of the latest reporting reviewed for this story. His scheduled Dec. 17 court appearance is the next publicly reported milestone. The prosecution will have to support the two murder counts and attempted-battery allegation through the judicial process, and White will have an opportunity to contest the state’s evidence and allegations. Until that process produces a judgment, the descriptions of the Oct. 11 events contained in charging records remain accusations rather than findings of guilt.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.