Longtime boyfriend accused of shooting elderly Florida woman after she refuses to sell house after breakup

Investigators say the man who reported the shooting had been arguing with his longtime girlfriend over their breakup and money tied to her home.

TAMPA, Fla. — A 911 call shortly before 11:30 a.m. on Oct. 3 brought Tampa police to a business parking lot on East Fowler Avenue, where officers found a 74-year-old woman dead in the passenger seat of a pickup and arrested the man accused of shooting her.

The driver, 74-year-old Alan Barber, was taken into custody without incident and later charged with second-degree murder in the death of Barbara Susdorf, according to police and a probable-cause affidavit reported by Law&Crime. The roadside scene gave officers the immediate facts of a homicide investigation: a dead passenger, a firearm and a white Chevrolet pickup that police impounded as evidence. The alleged reason for the confrontation emerged later, through Barber’s statements to investigators about a relationship of more than 25 years that he said was ending amid a bitter dispute over a house and $300,000.

Law&Crime reported that Barber himself called 911 and said he had shot his girlfriend while driving in the 4100 block of East Fowler Avenue. Tampa police confirmed that Barber stopped the vehicle in a local business parking lot after the shooting. Officers secured the area, recovered the gun believed to have been used and preserved the pickup for investigators. Susdorf was found in the front passenger seat and pronounced dead. Police did not describe any continuing threat to the public in their announcement of Barber’s arrest.

The first official account released by Tampa police was narrower than the narrative later attributed to Barber. Police said only that Barber and the woman had known each other for more than two decades, had been together in the pickup and became involved in a disagreement that began at a restaurant. Barber was driving and the woman was riding as a passenger when the argument intensified. Investigators said he fatally shot her before stopping the truck. The department did not initially publish Susdorf’s name or explain what the argument was about.

The probable-cause affidavit filled in that missing relationship history. According to the document as reported by Law&Crime, Barber told investigators after receiving his Miranda rights that he and Susdorf had been together for more than 25 years. They lived in a house that was in Susdorf’s name, he allegedly said, and they had recently been arguing while repeatedly discussing a breakup. Barber characterized the separation as something both wanted, according to the affidavit, but the couple had not agreed on what would happen financially if they parted.

Barber told investigators he believed he was entitled to $300,000 because of money he claimed to have put toward the house. Susdorf, according to his account in the affidavit, would not agree to sell the property and would not pay him the amount he wanted. Publicly available reports do not independently verify his $300,000 figure or explain the legal basis, if any, for the claim. The material reviewed for this report also does not establish whether his payments represented ownership contributions, mortgage costs, repairs, living expenses or something else.

The disagreement followed the couple into lunch on the day Susdorf was killed. The affidavit says they argued at the restaurant over a dollar for a tip. On its own, that dispute was minor, but investigators allege the argument continued after they returned to Barber’s truck and quickly became focused again on the unresolved property issue. Barber kept pressing Susdorf to sell the house and pay him $300,000, according to the affidavit. She refused, and investigators said the exchange became increasingly hostile as Barber drove.

Authorities allege a gun then entered the confrontation. The affidavit says Barber gave Susdorf a holster containing his firearm during the argument. The sequence described by investigators indicates that she at one point had the weapon, after which Barber allegedly took it from her, removed it from the holster and pointed it toward her. Barber had also made a threat to shoot her during the dispute, according to the affidavit. Investigators said he later described himself as having “snapped.” Susdorf was then shot and killed inside the truck.

Police have not presented those allegations as a judicial finding. The account is part of the evidence authorities say supports the criminal charge, and Barber is presumed innocent unless proved guilty in court. His statements are also only one source for the couple’s dispute. Susdorf could not provide her own account, and the reports reviewed for this story do not include an independent witness to the conversation inside the pickup or documentation resolving Barber’s claim about the money he said he had contributed to the house.

The physical evidence described by police is more straightforward. Officers recovered the firearm, secured the pickup and took Barber into custody at the scene. The department said the truck was impounded as evidence. The probable-cause account reported that a passenger-side window had been damaged, while Tampa police publicly said Susdorf was fatally shot during the escalating argument. Investigators’ handling of the vehicle and firearm indicates that both were treated as evidence in the homicide case.

Acting Tampa Police Chief Brett Owen addressed the case when the department announced the charge two days later. “Violence is not the answer to conflict, and there is never a disagreement that should end with the tragic loss of a life,” he said. Owen said Barber would now face the justice system for what police allege occurred. The department also assigned a victim advocate to work with Susdorf’s family and loved ones as they dealt with the aftermath of her death.

The different levels of detail in the case reflect the purposes of the records involved. A police news release typically gives the public a brief account of an arrest and the department’s investigative findings. A probable-cause affidavit can contain more specific allegations, including statements attributed to a defendant, because authorities use it to explain why they believe a charge is justified. Neither document, by itself, determines guilt. That question belongs to the criminal court process, where evidence may be challenged and competing accounts may emerge.

The evidence publicly described so far leaves the financial dispute particularly unsettled. Barber’s assertion that he put $300,000 into Susdorf’s house is an allegation attributed to him, not a verified accounting. Reports do not say whether the pair had a written agreement governing the property, whether Barber appeared on any mortgage or other financial document, or whether a civil claim concerning the home had ever been filed. What investigators do allege is that the dispute over money and the couple’s breakup formed the backdrop to the argument that ended in Susdorf’s death.

Barber was transported to the Orient Road Jail after his Oct. 3 arrest. Law&Crime reported after the arrest that he was being held without bond. The sources reviewed for this article did not identify a later adjudication or other final resolution of the murder case as of Nov. 17. The prosecution therefore remains centered on allegations that began with a 911 call and a stopped pickup on Fowler Avenue and expanded into a case about what police say happened during the final argument of a decades-long relationship.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.