Kourtney Aumen’s October plea marks a major turn in a Missouri case that has moved through court since 2020.
WARSAW, Mo. — The criminal case that began when deputies found 4-year-old Jessica Mast dead days before Christmas in 2020 has reached another major turning point, with former neighbor Kourtney Aumen pleading guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault after nearly six years of court proceedings.
The Oct. 5 plea did not close every case tied to Jessica’s death, but it ended the prospect of an October jury trial for Aumen and moved her prosecution directly toward sentencing. She is scheduled to return to court Dec. 21. The path to that hearing stretches back to the early morning of Dec. 20, 2020, when Benton County deputies responded to Jessica’s rural home and began an investigation that eventually drew in two neighbors and both of the child’s parents.
Deputies arrived after a report of a possible domestic disturbance and found Jessica dead inside the house. Authorities said she had suffered severe abuse, including blows and repeated immersion in a cold pond during winter weather. Investigators also found that a 2-year-old boy and Jessica’s mother had been injured. An infant in the household was reported unharmed. The surviving children were later taken from the home as investigators began reconstructing what had happened and identifying the adults they believed bore criminal responsibility.
Within days, the investigation centered on Aumen and Ethan Mast, neighbors of the family. Despite the shared last name, authorities said Ethan Mast was not related to Jessica’s parents. Sheriff Eric Knox said at the time that investigators believed the violence occurred during what he called a “religious-type episode.” Statements attributed to the adults described claims involving a supposed “demon.” Law enforcement treated those statements as part of the explanation offered for the conduct, not as an independent finding about religion or belief.
The investigation then widened. James and Mary Mast, Jessica’s parents, also were arrested and charged in connection with the events surrounding their daughter’s death and injuries to other family members. James Mast told investigators that he and his wife had witnessed violence and had been threatened if they tried to stop it. Authorities nevertheless pursued charges against the parents based on their alleged conduct and failures during the period of abuse. From that point forward, what began as one homicide investigation became four related but legally separate criminal cases.
The first major plea came in February 2022, when Ethan Mast pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and assault. His admission resolved his guilt without a trial but did not settle what would happen to Aumen or Jessica’s parents. The remaining prosecutions continued on separate schedules. That distinction became increasingly important as years passed: a plea in one case could establish one defendant’s responsibility without automatically resolving allegations against another person who had been charged over the same events.
Mary Mast later pleaded guilty to endangering the welfare of a child. James Mast entered a guilty plea in November 2024 to second-degree murder and first-degree assault, including an assault count connected to his young son, according to local reporting. His case did not simply move to an uncontested sentencing, however. He later sought to withdraw his plea. A judge denied an effort to do so, and reporting in 2026 said he continued filing motions challenging the plea. That procedural history leaves his case on a different track from Aumen’s newly entered plea.
Aumen’s own prosecution remained unresolved much longer. Her case was moved from Benton County to Webster County on a change of venue as preparations continued for trial. She faced serious charges arising from Jessica’s death and the injuries described by investigators. Over time, her mental competency to proceed became a recurring issue. Defense lawyers argued in 2026 that she should be in the custody of the Missouri Department of Mental Health and cited difficulties communicating with her as they prepared a defense.
In September, the court found Aumen competent to stand trial again. Defense counsel said in a filing that communication problems remained despite that determination, but the ruling allowed the criminal case to continue. A jury trial was set to begin Oct. 26 and was expected to last several days. With the competency question resolved for purposes of moving forward, the case appeared headed toward the presentation of evidence before jurors more than five years after the original arrests.
The next turn came only days before Aumen’s guilty plea. She sought to waive her right to a jury trial, a step that would have allowed the case to proceed without a jury if the court accepted it. Judge M. Brandon Baker refused the request, citing the seriousness of the charges. That ruling appeared to preserve the planned jury trial. Instead, court records soon reflected a change-of-plea hearing, and Aumen admitted guilt to second-degree murder and first-degree assault on Oct. 5.
The plea changed both the legal posture and the public focus of the case. Prosecutors no longer needed to prove Aumen’s guilt to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt on the charges resolved by the plea. Defense attorneys no longer needed to prepare for the October trial that had been approaching. The unresolved question became punishment. Reports of the plea set Aumen’s sentencing for 1:30 p.m. Dec. 21, giving the case its first specific post-plea milestone after years dominated by pretrial proceedings.
The long court timeline has unfolded alongside enduring attention in the small Benton County community. In early 2021, residents gathered to remember Jessica, and a community effort collected stuffed animals for first responders to carry on calls involving children. Knox said the case had a profound effect on deputies and other emergency workers who responded to the home. Those reactions were separate from the legal process, which required judges and prosecutors to deal with each defendant individually rather than treating community outrage as a substitute for proof.
That separation is especially important because the criminal histories of the four adults are not interchangeable. Ethan Mast’s 2022 plea, Mary Mast’s child-endangerment plea, James Mast’s contested post-plea litigation and Aumen’s October 2026 admission all arose from the same underlying investigation but involved different charges and procedural paths. Some secondary accounts have also differed on details such as ages, the description of earlier charges and the status of other defendants. The most reliable point of reference for Aumen’s present case is the October court development itself: a guilty plea to second-degree murder and first-degree assault.
Jessica’s death remains the event linking those proceedings. Investigators said the 4-year-old endured repeated abuse before deputies were called. Authorities described injuries to other members of her household and said the violence had been justified by some participants through claims about demonic influence. The evidence developed in the investigation led prosecutors to pursue criminal responsibility beyond the individuals accused of directly assaulting Jessica, producing the unusually prolonged set of separate cases still moving through Missouri courts.
For Aumen, however, the next phase is no longer uncertain in the same way it was before Oct. 5. She will not face the jury that had been scheduled to hear her case later that month. Unless the court calendar changes, she will instead appear in Benton County on Dec. 21 for sentencing. The sentence itself has not yet been imposed and should not be presumed before the judge rules.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.