New York man stored ex-girlfriend’s severed head in carry on suitcase with a flower

Prosecutors say Alberta Dale had ended her relationship with Damon Foy before he killed her in Ulster County in 2024.

KINGSTON, N.Y. — Long before Damon Foy admitted murdering Alberta Dale, authorities had already been called into the former couple’s troubled relationship, according to court records describing domestic violence allegations, a stay-away protection order and a warning Dale reportedly made about what could happen if she disappeared.

Those earlier events now form a critical part of the context surrounding Foy’s Oct. 7 guilty plea to second-degree murder. The Ulster County District Attorney’s Office said Foy, 50, killed Dale, 44, between March 31 and April 1, 2024, shortly after she ended their relationship. Prosecutors said he dismembered her and was trying to dispose of her remains when law enforcement intervened. The plea before Ulster County Court Judge Bryan E. Rounds means the case will proceed to sentencing Dec. 16 rather than to a murder trial.

Court filings reviewed by Law&Crime described a history of alleged domestic violence involving the couple. One earlier incident involved a gun, according to that reporting, and a stay-away order of protection was active around the time Dale was killed. Officials speaking after Foy’s 2024 indictment also said he was out on bail in a previous domestic violence matter when Dale died. The records further said Dale had told a crime victims unit that if she went missing, Foy would be responsible for killing her. That warning has taken on added weight because her disappearance was what first brought deputies to Foy’s home.

The criminal case did not begin with the discovery of remains. It began with concern from Dale’s family in Pennsylvania. On April 1, relatives contacted authorities because they could not account for her and asked for a welfare check. The request was passed to the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office, which went to Foy’s residence. Dale was not located, but investigators soon launched a formal missing-person case. Her vehicle was at the property, according to court records and subsequent reporting, adding to questions about where she had gone.

The following day, a member of the public found property belonging to Dale along a roadside in the town of Wawarsing and turned it over to police. The discovery sharpened concerns that she had been harmed. Deputies and detectives returned to Foy’s residence, gathered information and obtained warrants to search the home and other locations. The district attorney’s office later said the searches produced evidence showing that Dale had been the victim of foul play and led to Foy’s arrest.

Authorities have given slightly different dates for the discovery of Dale’s remains. The district attorney’s 2026 plea announcement says her remains were ultimately located April 2, 2024. During a public briefing shortly after Foy’s arrest, however, the Sheriff’s Office said a multiagency team executed a search warrant at his apartment April 3 and found remains there that were identified as Dale’s. Officials also said additional remains were later recovered in the town of Marlboro. The difference does not change the broader sequence: a welfare check became a missing-person investigation, roadside property heightened suspicions, and searches produced evidence of homicide.

Law&Crime’s review of court filings supplied additional details about the apartment search. Investigators found a suitcase in a closet and, after obtaining authority to open it, discovered some of Dale’s remains. The filings also described blood evidence and fragments in the residence. The account is disturbing, but the principal evidentiary point is that the search linked the apartment directly to Dale’s death and to efforts to conceal or dispose of her body. Investigators then continued searching outside the residence as they worked to recover additional remains and reconstruct what had happened.

According to the same records, Foy eventually told investigators that he had killed Dale. In a subsequent interview he spoke at length about grievances arising from their relationship and its breakup, including his anger about being required to leave a home. He accused Dale of having “play[ed] me like a fool” and “like a sucker.” Those were Foy’s descriptions of his feelings, not findings by investigators about Dale’s conduct. Prosecutors have instead emphasized that Dale had recently ended the relationship and that the case occurred against a documented background of domestic violence concerns.

The distinction matters because official statements after the plea have placed the case within the broader problem of abuse by intimate partners. District Attorney Emmanuel C. Nneji said the killing showed what he called the “total selfish disregard for the life and dignity of another person” at the center of domestic violence. He also argued that legal protections must do more than exist on paper, saying victims should be physically, psychologically and emotionally safe from people who target them. His statement repeated themes he raised when Foy was first prosecuted in 2024.

Foy initially faced an eight-count indictment. In addition to second-degree murder, the charges included aggravated criminal contempt, concealment of a human corpse, first-degree criminal contempt, third-degree criminal mischief, third-degree assault, criminal obstruction of breathing or blood circulation and fourth-degree criminal possession of a weapon. Those counts reflected both the homicide allegations and the broader history investigators said they uncovered. Foy’s guilty plea to murder removes the need for the district attorney’s office to prove the homicide charge to a jury.

Chief Assistant District Attorney Elizabeth Culmone-Mills, who has worked on the case since its beginning, said prosecutors devoted significant resources to the investigation over the following two and a half years. She credited Dale’s family for its strength and trust while thanking the Sheriff’s Office, State Police and other investigators. The New York State Police Forensic Investigation Unit, Bureau of Criminal Investigation personnel, Major Crimes Unit and Ulster County Medical Examiner’s Office all assisted, according to the district attorney.

Law&Crime reported that the plea agreement calls for Foy to receive 23 years to life in state prison and that Dale’s family supported the arrangement. Culmone-Mills said prosecutors would not have made the recommendation without the family’s backing. The district attorney’s official plea announcement confirmed the Dec. 16 sentencing date but did not include the proposed prison term in its release. Rounds will preside over the sentencing in Ulster County Court.

With guilt established by Foy’s plea, the unresolved stage of the criminal case is now punishment. The proceeding will no longer turn on whether prosecutors can persuade jurors that Foy killed Dale. Instead, the December hearing will formally address the sentence for a murder that authorities say followed the collapse of an intimate relationship already marked by legal intervention, allegations of violence and a protection order intended to keep the two apart.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.