North Carolina woman charged with murder after 1-year-old niece dies from blunt force trauma

Arabella Johnson’s mother is speaking publicly after authorities charged a relative who had been caring for the 21-month-old girl.

HAMPTONVILLE, N.C. — Six months after 21-month-old Arabella River Elisabeth Johnson died from injuries authorities ruled a homicide, her mother is describing the child she expected to watch grow up while a great-aunt faces murder and felony child-abuse charges in connection with the death.

Cheyanna Elisabeth Pardue’s account places the criminal case inside a family story that was largely absent when investigators first announced the homicide finding. Pardue said she was incarcerated when Arabella was fatally injured and remained behind bars until 17 days after her daughter’s death. Stephanie Kay Johnson, 37, Arabella’s great-aunt, was arrested in October after authorities alleged she inflicted the fatal injury while caring for the toddler. Johnson has not been convicted, and the charges against her remain allegations that must be proved in court.

For Pardue, the loss is measured not only by the investigation but by the future she no longer expects to share with her daughter. She told WXII in an Oct. 29 interview, “I know that I’ll never get to watch her grow up.” Pardue said she had previously been told she might not be able to have children and regarded Arabella as an especially meaningful arrival in her life. Her public comments came after months in which the family had mourned while investigators worked without publicly identifying a suspect.

Arabella was born July 28, 2024, in Surry County and lived in Hamptonville. Her obituary described her as a calm, quiet child with a memorable smile. Pardue later recalled small moments of her daughter’s brief life, including the delight Arabella showed when she first tasted a strawberry. Those details offer a different frame for a case that official reports necessarily describe through medical findings, warrants and criminal charges: before she became the subject of a homicide investigation, Arabella was a young child whose relatives expected years of ordinary family milestones.

The emergency that ended those expectations began April 30. Deputies and medical personnel responded to the 5900 block of Bob’s Lake Road in Hamptonville after receiving what was initially described as a medical emergency involving a 21-month-old child. Arabella was taken to a hospital for treatment. While she was receiving care, the Yadkin County Sheriff’s Office said detectives identified evidence of earlier trauma that appeared non-accidental. The publicly released accounts do not provide a full description of the injuries or specify exactly when investigators believe each injury was inflicted.

Arabella died May 1 at Atrium Health Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center in Winston-Salem. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner later determined that blunt force trauma caused her death and classified the manner of death as homicide. That medical conclusion established that authorities believed the death resulted from another person’s actions rather than an accident or natural cause, but it did not by itself identify who was criminally responsible. Investigators continued working after the medical examiner’s findings, with no arrest publicly announced for more than five months.

During that period, the Yadkin County Sheriff’s Office worked with the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. The Yadkin County Department of Social Services also began an investigation after concerns about non-accidental trauma emerged. Public reports have not disclosed the full contents or outcome of the child-welfare inquiry. They also do not explain whether Johnson’s caregiving role arose through an informal family arrangement or another process. Those unknowns are important because Pardue’s later comments make clear that she was unavailable to provide care herself when her daughter suffered the fatal injuries.

The criminal case moved into public view Oct. 8, when deputies arrested Johnson after obtaining warrants. Authorities charged her with murder and with intentionally inflicting child abuse resulting in serious bodily injury. The second charge focuses specifically on Johnson’s alleged role as a caregiver. North Carolina law allows a person who is providing care or supervision to a child younger than 16 to be prosecuted for felony child abuse if prosecutors prove the person intentionally inflicted serious bodily injury or committed an intentional assault resulting in such an injury.

The arrest warrant alleges that Johnson was caring for Arabella as her great-aunt when the injury was inflicted. It also accuses Johnson of killing the child with malice aforethought, terminology tied to the state’s murder allegation. Public reporting available as of Nov. 19 does not provide a detailed prosecution narrative explaining how investigators believe the fatal episode unfolded. It does not identify a publicly established motive, disclose the complete autopsy findings or set out every item of evidence detectives gathered between April and October. Those matters may emerge through court filings or later proceedings.

The relationship between the accused woman and the child has made the case particularly painful for Pardue. She told WXII she could not understand how her daughter could have been harmed by a person who was supposed to be caring for her. At the same time, Pardue has spoken about her own circumstances without suggesting facts beyond what authorities have established. She said she wants to find a way to help other incarcerated mothers locate safe places for their children so that other families do not experience the loss she is living with.

That aspiration reflects one consequence of the case without resolving questions that remain for investigators and the courts. The available record does not establish who selected each caregiver, what information was available when the arrangement was made, whether any prior warning signs existed or whether child-welfare authorities had been involved with the family before the April emergency. It would be speculative to assign responsibility for those unanswered issues. The confirmed public record is narrower: Arabella was in the care of a great-aunt whom authorities later accused of inflicting fatal injuries, and Pardue was incarcerated at the time.

Family members had been speaking about Arabella before Johnson’s arrest. In May, as the sheriff’s office announced the homicide ruling, the toddler’s grandfather described her to WXII as happy and full of love. The family was planning a memorial service. Arabella’s obituary also preserved a picture of a child remembered for her smile rather than for the circumstances of her death. Those remembrances now sit alongside a criminal proceeding that will require prosecutors to move beyond the medical examiner’s conclusion and prove that Johnson was the person legally responsible for the injuries.

Johnson was arrested without incident and was reported held in the Yadkin County Jail without bond following her arrest. Sheriff Nick Smitherman said his department’s thoughts remained with Arabella’s relatives as investigators announced the charges. The North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation assisted local authorities through the investigation. No reliable source reviewed for this report provides a final disposition of either criminal count, and no conviction should be inferred from Johnson’s arrest, her detention or the homicide determination.

Pardue has said she plans to attend each of Johnson’s court appearances. The next hearing reported in the case is scheduled for December. Until then, the prosecution leaves two parallel public records: one built from autopsy findings, warrants and allegations, and another built from a mother’s memories of the daughter she expected to raise. The court process will determine whether the state can prove its case against Johnson; it cannot restore the childhood Pardue says she had imagined for Arabella.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.