Orlando doctor accused of waiting minutes to act as friend’s 7-year-old son drowned

Detectives say video and follow-up interviews changed how they viewed the April death of 7-year-old Khushil Bandi.

ORLANDO, Fla. — When 7-year-old Khushil Bandi was pulled unconscious from a community swimming pool in April, Orlando police initially regarded the drowning as an accident. Months of investigation later, detectives reached a different conclusion and charged the physician who had taken him there with aggravated manslaughter of a child.

The change in the case is at the center of the prosecution against Sukanthini “Suki” Subbiah, 48, a Louisiana doctor who was supervising Khushil, his twin sister and her own young son during the outing. Investigators say surveillance footage and later interviews showed a prolonged emergency during which Subbiah failed to personally rescue Khushil even after he had been underwater for an unreasonable amount of time. Her lawyer rejects the criminal interpretation, saying accidents happen and that the facts do not justify manslaughter. Subbiah has pleaded not guilty.

Police did not announce a criminal charge in the immediate aftermath of the April 10 drowning. Emergency responders instead dealt first with a child who had been recovered from the pool and needed urgent medical care. Khushil was taken to a hospital after efforts to revive him at the scene. He later died. The later arrest therefore reflects a second stage of the case: detectives looking back at the minutes before the rescue and asking whether the adult who had responsibility for him had recognized the danger and failed to respond in a legally culpable way.

Investigators reconstructed why the children were at the pool in the first place. Subbiah was visiting her mother in the Orlando area, and her son had become friends with Khushil and his twin sister, who lived nearby. Police said the twins’ mother allowed Subbiah to take the children to the pool for a play date. The sister wore a life vest. Khushil did not. According to investigators, Subbiah said she interpreted the absence of a flotation device as an indication that he knew how to swim. Nothing in the public reporting indicates that the outing began with concern that the boy would be unable to handle the water.

Subbiah’s first description of the emergency gave detectives one version of how quickly she reacted. She told investigators that she saw Khushil underwater for roughly 45 seconds or so before trying to get help, according to the arrest report. She said she asked the other children to retrieve him and later sought assistance from another adult. She also told police that her mother could not assist because she could not swim. After Khushil was brought out, Subbiah performed CPR and called 911, actions that were included in investigators’ account of what happened.

The surveillance system gave police a separate record. Detectives said the footage showed the children entering the pool around 6:19 p.m. and Khushil beginning to struggle within about a minute. Investigators described him turning in the water and splashing vigorously before he went beneath the surface. They placed his submersion at about 6:21 p.m. The footage then allowed detectives to measure the delay in a way that recollections alone could not. Rather than a brief period underwater before help was sought, police concluded that Khushil remained submerged for several minutes.

The recording also changed investigators’ assessment of Subbiah’s actions. Police said she was positioned where she could observe the pool and, at points, appeared to be looking in the direction where Khushil had gone underwater. Other activity continued around her, including her son asking her for goggles. By the time questions from the children drew greater attention to Khushil’s condition, several minutes had passed. Investigators say Subbiah finally entered the pool around 6:26 p.m. but did not proceed far enough into the water to retrieve him herself.

What happened next became especially important to detectives. Police allege that Subbiah directed the other 7-year-olds to try to reach Khushil. When they were unable to do so, another adult on the pool deck was asked for help. That man entered the water and recovered the boy. According to the police timeline, Khushil had been underwater for more than seven minutes by the time he was removed. Investigators later described relying on children of the same age as the victim to attempt the rescue as part of the conduct they believed showed a serious disregard for his safety.

Detectives then returned to Subbiah for further questioning. She gave an estimate of about two minutes for how long Khushil might have been underwater and reportedly acknowledged that such a period would be an unrealistic length of time for a child to hold his breath. She said she froze when confronted with the situation. Police did not accept that explanation as sufficient to remove criminal responsibility. They emphasized that she was both the supervising adult and a physician who would understand the danger created when a person remains submerged and unable to breathe.

Those findings changed the case from a fatal accident investigation into an allegation of culpable negligence. Under Florida law, aggravated manslaughter of a child applies when a person causes the death of someone younger than 18 through culpable negligence. The statute classifies the offense as a first-degree felony. Whether Subbiah’s conduct meets that standard is not decided by an arrest affidavit. It is the question prosecutors must establish through the court process, while the defense may dispute the state’s interpretation of her conduct, awareness, abilities and responsibility during the emergency.

The police theory does not depend on an allegation that Subbiah pushed Khushil into the pool, intended for him to drown or deliberately prevented someone from helping him. Instead, investigators argue that her alleged failure to take effective action became criminal because she had responsibility for the child, was close enough to respond and let critical minutes pass. They also contend that the shallow-to-moderate depth described in the report gave her an opportunity to enter farther and retrieve him rather than turning first to children for help.

Defense attorney Rajan Joshi has challenged that interpretation from the outset of the arrest. He said Subbiah cooperated with investigators and voluntarily surrendered. He has described the death as a genuine tragedy while maintaining that tragedy and criminal culpability are not the same thing. Joshi also invoked Subbiah’s history as a physician, saying she had devoted her career to helping people. His public comments did not concede the state’s interpretation of the surveillance footage, and he said she intends to contest the prosecution in court.

The months between the drowning and the arrest also help explain why the case now turns so heavily on reconstruction. Police interviewed the adults and children connected to the outing, examined Subbiah’s statements and compared them with the camera footage. The result was an allegation based less on a single disputed action than on a series of moments investigators say added up to grossly inadequate intervention. The defense, by contrast, is expected to argue that a chaotic emergency should not be transformed into a felony merely because investigators can later examine every second with the benefit of recorded video.

Khushil’s death remains the undisputed tragedy underlying those competing legal positions. The criminal case must determine a narrower question: whether Subbiah’s response crossed the line from an unsuccessful reaction to an emergency into culpable negligence under Florida law. She has entered a not-guilty plea, and the available reporting reviewed through Nov. 17 did not establish a later adjudication of the charge. Until the case is resolved, the police conclusions remain allegations rather than findings of guilt.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.