Pennsylvania family gathering turned deadly after cousin strangled off duty cop at cabin say police

Investigators say medical findings and accounts from relatives contradicted the initial description of Michael McGeehan simply falling asleep on a porch.

CUMMINGS TOWNSHIP, Pa. — An autopsy finding that off-duty police Officer Michael McGeehan died from forearm compression of his neck became the pivotal evidence in a homicide investigation that led authorities to charge 25-year-old Paden Edward Frey nearly three months after McGeehan was found dead at a rural Pennsylvania cabin.

The Lycoming County Coroner’s Office classified McGeehan’s July 11 death as a homicide after a July 13 autopsy identified manual strangulation by forearm compression of the neck as the cause, according to investigators and court records described by several Pennsylvania news organizations. The finding gave police a medical explanation for a death that had initially been announced publicly by McGeehan’s department as an unexpected passing and that witnesses had described in the immediate aftermath as occurring after an effort to get the heavily intoxicated officer to sleep.

The medical evidence did not stand alone. Investigators compared it with accounts from McGeehan’s wife, son and other people who had attended a family gathering at a cabin on Dam Run Road in Cummings Township. Those statements described an extended physical struggle in which McGeehan was held down after people at the cabin became concerned about his behavior. Police allege that Frey pressed a forearm against McGeehan’s neck during that restraint and continued until the 44-year-old officer became unconscious.

Other findings were also associated with the autopsy. Reporting based on the investigative records referenced blunt-force injuries to McGeehan’s head along with acute and chronic alcohol-related findings, hypertensive atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, obesity and a history of sleep apnea. Daily Voice described those health conditions as contributing factors while reporting that forearm compression was identified as the cause of death. The coroner’s homicide classification means authorities concluded that McGeehan’s death resulted from another person’s actions; it does not by itself determine criminal guilt.

Frey, of Cogan Station, was arrested Oct. 7 by Lycoming Regional Police with assistance from the Lycoming County Sheriff’s Office. Police said the arrest occurred without incident at his residence. He is charged with third-degree murder, strangulation, involuntary manslaughter and recklessly endangering another person. He was arraigned before Magisterial District Judge Denise Dieter and sent to Lycoming County Prison without bail. Frey has not been convicted, and the allegations against him remain subject to court proceedings.

The events described by investigators began several hours before first responders arrived. McGeehan, an officer with the Middlesex Township Police Department in Cumberland County, was off duty and attending a family gathering at the Cummings Township cabin. Witnesses told police that he had consumed too much alcohol. At some point, according to the probable-cause affidavit, people at the gathering tried to persuade him to go to bed. One witness said McGeehan was talking about swimming or riding a four-wheeler, prompting others to try to keep him from leaving.

Those efforts became physical. McGeehan’s son told investigators that Frey and another man restrained his father and that Frey placed a forearm across the middle of McGeehan’s neck. The son described McGeehan as continuing to fight and struggling to breathe during a confrontation lasting about 10 minutes or more. McGeehan’s wife gave investigators another view of the struggle. According to the affidavit, she said Frey told her to get away while he was lying on McGeehan and warned that he would “put him to sleep” if McGeehan did not stop.

The phrase became significant because of what investigators say occurred next. Frey told police that he and another person had been fighting with McGeehan in an effort to get him to go to sleep and that they eventually got him to lie down on the porch, where he fell asleep. After the autopsy and further witness interviews, investigators wrote that Frey’s version omitted a crucial fact: that he had applied pressure to McGeehan’s neck until McGeehan lost consciousness. Witnesses also told police that Frey left the officer on the porch and did not provide aid, according to the affidavit.

Lycoming County 911 received a call at about 2:38 a.m. reporting that McGeehan was not breathing. Other reporting on the charging documents said statements made during the call referred to McGeehan having been put to sleep because he was intoxicated and to people having choked him. Police officers and emergency medical workers arrived at about 2:57 a.m. McGeehan was on his back on the front porch and was unresponsive. Attempts to save him were unsuccessful, and he was pronounced dead at the scene.

The autopsy two days later provided investigators with a connection between those accounts and the physical cause of death. Police said the combination of medical findings and witness statements showed that Frey had not fully described the restraint during his initial interview. Investigators eventually sought charges, and regional police announced the arrest on Oct. 7. Their public statement said a joint investigation by the department and the Lycoming County Coroner’s Office concluded that Frey and McGeehan had been involved in a physical altercation and that Frey was alleged to have strangled McGeehan.

The murder charge carries a distinct legal allegation from the lesser involuntary manslaughter count filed in the same case. Under Pennsylvania law, third-degree murder is the category for murder that does not meet the statutory definitions of first-degree intentional killing or second-degree felony murder. Pennsylvania courts describe the offense as requiring malice, which can include conduct undertaken with an extreme disregard for a known risk of death or serious bodily injury. Involuntary manslaughter, by contrast, addresses deaths caused through reckless or grossly negligent conduct under circumstances defined by state law. Which offense, if any, prosecutors ultimately can prove remains for the courts to determine.

The strangulation charge closely tracks the physical conduct alleged in the affidavit. Pennsylvania law defines strangulation as knowingly or intentionally interfering with another person’s breathing or blood circulation by applying pressure to the throat or neck or by blocking the nose and mouth. Prosecutors cite witness descriptions of Frey’s forearm position, the observations that McGeehan was having trouble breathing and the autopsy result. Frey’s defense will have the opportunity to challenge the Commonwealth’s evidence and its interpretation as the case proceeds.

The homicide investigation also changed the public understanding of a loss that had already been deeply felt in Cumberland County. Middlesex Township police said McGeehan had served the department for 12 years and was known as a trusted leader. His obituary described a law-enforcement career that included graduation from HACC’s Municipal Police Academy and service as president of his academy class. He was also remembered for coaching his sons’ sports teams. McGeehan was a husband and father of five boys, and the department later promoted him posthumously to corporal.

The case has not yet reached a trial court determination on the evidence. Frey’s preliminary hearing, originally scheduled for Oct. 21, was later continued to Dec. 23, according to subsequently reported court records. He remains in Lycoming County Prison without bail. The latest public police statement continued to describe the investigation as active, and no trial date had been announced as of Nov. 18.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.