HARRISBURG, PA – A former magistrate judge has been convicted of attempted murder after shooting her boyfriend in a case that has captivated local residents with its shocking details. Sonya M. McKnight, 58, was found guilty by a Lancaster County jury on charges stemming from a February 2024 incident where she shot her then-boyfriend, Michael McCoy, 55, while he slept, resulting in permanent blindness in one of his eyes.
The verdict came after two days of testimony during which jurors learned about a tumultuous relationship between McKnight and McCoy, including a previous incident with her estranged husband, which authorities deemed self-defense. The shooting that led to McKnight’s conviction occurred at McCoy’s home on Saddle Ridge Drive in Dauphin County.
Evidence presented in court revealed that McKnight shot McCoy in the head while he lay asleep. The bullet penetrated his head, ultimately leading to his visual impairment. Despite the severity of his injuries, McCoy survived.
Due to a conflict of interest, the Cumberland County District Attorney’s Office was assigned the case. The local DA’s office initially requested the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office to handle the prosecution, but they, too, cited a conflict of interest due to McKnight’s former position in the judicial system.
Witnesses described a tense period preceding the shooting. McCoy, who had ended the relationship on February 4, had asked McKnight to vacate his home. Despite removing her access to the house, McKnight reportedly returned multiple times. The situation escalated after McCoy suspected McKnight was following him the night before the shooting.
Police reports indicate that on the night of February 9, after a dinner out, McCoy returned home to find McKnight sleeping on his couch. He expressed intentions to ask her mother for help in getting her to leave.
Around 1 a.m., McCoy awoke in extreme pain, unable to see, and began screaming. McKnight contacted emergency services but allegedly claimed ignorance about the incident. Forensic evidence, however, pointed to McKnight as the shooter, with residue and a registered firearm linking her to the crime.
Remarkably, this incident with McCoy was not the first violent confrontation involving McKnight. In 2019, she shot her estranged husband; however, she was not prosecuted as her actions were ruled self-defense.
McKnight’s legal troubles began affecting her career prior to the shooting. In 2023, she was suspended without pay due to various misconduct allegations. Complications included directing her staff to dismiss a financial claim against her.
McCoy, having spent time in the hospital, was released on February 11, 2024. As McKnight faces potentially decades in prison, the case underscores the importance of judicial accountability and personal responsibility in the community.