The emergency recording captures Jonathan Gatto blaming a possible space heater before investigators concluded the bedroom fire was deliberately set.
HARRISBURG, Pa. — A newly released 911 recording has added another piece of public evidence to the case against Jonathan Gatto, the Harrisburg man accused of killing his pediatrician wife, Dr. Julia Pederson, before setting a fire inside their home. During the six-minute Oct. 10 call, Gatto reported that his wife was trapped in a bedroom fire while he and the couple’s 7-year-old daughter were outside.
The significance of the recording comes from what investigators learned after the call ended. Gatto initially suggested to the dispatcher that a space heater might have been involved in the fire. A Pennsylvania State Police fire marshal later determined that the blaze had been intentionally set, and an autopsy found Pederson had already died from multiple traumatic injuries before the fire began. Prosecutors now allege that Gatto strangled the 41-year-old doctor and used the fire as part of the crime, allegations that led to first-degree murder, arson and evidence-tampering charges.
On the recording, Gatto sounds urgent as alarms ring in the background. He tells the dispatcher the fire is in his wife’s room and says he cannot get inside. He also reports that he burned his hand and that his daughter is outside with him. At one point he says, “Hurry up.” The dispatcher repeatedly instructs him to remain outside rather than re-enter the burning home. The audio does not establish by itself what happened before the emergency call. Its importance to the case comes from the contrast between what Gatto reported in real time and the conclusions police, the fire marshal and the coroner reached afterward.
Firefighters arrived at the home in the 2900 block of Green Street shortly after the call, at about 7:05 a.m. They encountered light smoke and a relatively small fire in a lower-level bedroom, according to court records and local reports. Pederson was found unresponsive. First responders attempted CPR and took her to Penn State Health Holy Spirit Medical Center, where she was pronounced dead. Testing cited in investigative documents indicated that she had died before the blaze. The autopsy, completed several days later, ruled her death a homicide. Authorities said the fire itself was not the cause of death.
Gatto’s explanation to detectives after the fire covered the hours before the 911 call. He said Pederson had been ill and had not taken their daughter to ballet the day before. Later that night, he told police, he heard a sound that resembled someone falling down stairs but saw no one when he checked. He said Pederson gave a brief response and went back into her bedroom. Gatto told investigators he set an alarm so he could offer her ibuprofen at about 2 a.m. and that she appeared startled when he entered. He said he returned to bed, later woke to smoke alarms and immediately took the child outside.
Authorities allege that sequence concealed a homicide. Gatto was arrested Oct. 14, four days after the fire, after investigators said the forensic findings and scene examination established probable cause. The Harrisburg Bureau of Police lists six charges: murder, abuse of a corpse, tampering with or fabricating physical evidence, endangering the welfare of a child, arson involving danger of death or bodily injury, and aggravated arson involving a person inside the property. A judge denied bail, and Gatto remains at Dauphin County Prison. He is presumed innocent unless proved guilty.
The couple’s daughter is an important part of the case but has been kept largely outside public reporting because she is a child. Police say she was asleep elsewhere in the home during the alleged killing and was taken outside when the smoke detectors sounded. District Attorney Fran Chardo said authorities monitored Gatto after investigators determined the fire was arson but before they had developed enough evidence to arrest him. Chardo said officials did not believe the child was in immediate danger during that interval. He later said family members were expected to play a role in her care while the criminal case proceeds.
The investigation has also produced evidence concerning Pederson’s unexplained medical symptoms during the weeks before her death. According to a search-warrant application, Pederson told her mother in September that she felt unusually groggy and weak and suspected she might have been drugged. A friend and co-worker described drinks being brought to Pederson at work by Gatto and the couple’s daughter and told investigators that some symptoms appeared to worsen after she consumed them. On Oct. 9, a co-worker said Pederson became so lethargic that she lay on the floor at work and planned to obtain bloodwork the next morning.
Those reports do not amount to a public finding that Pederson had been poisoned or drugged. Investigators sought food and drink containers, biological material, surveillance footage and other possible evidence while examining the allegation, but authorities have not publicly announced laboratory results establishing that a substance caused Pederson’s earlier symptoms. No additional drugging-related charge appears among the six charges publicly listed by Harrisburg police. The distinction separates a line of inquiry described in a search warrant from the homicide and arson allegations prosecutors have already brought to court.
Pederson and Gatto were also preparing to separate, according to Gatto’s police interview. He told detectives their marriage was “not good” and said they were trying to decide how to explain the separation to their daughter. Investigators have included the condition of the marriage in their account of the case, but authorities have not publicly established a definitive motive for the killing. The criminal prosecution is based on the alleged acts and the evidence gathered around Pederson’s death, not merely on the fact that the couple was separating.
Pederson was a pediatrician with UPMC Children’s Community Pediatrics and had a lengthy academic and medical background. Her family said she graduated from Harvard University, received her medical degree from Stanford University and completed her pediatric residency at Northwestern University’s Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago. UPMC described her as a valued physician who dedicated her career to caring for children and helping families. Her sister’s memorial account emphasized ordinary parts of her life as well, including reading, visiting nature preserves and learning crochet, and a fundraiser was established to help with funeral costs and her daughter’s future.
The 911 audio became public in November after being played in court and entered into the public record, giving the public a direct record of what Gatto told emergency dispatchers while the fire response was unfolding. It does not resolve the case, but it adds to a collection of evidence that includes fire-scene findings, medical examination results, police interviews and search-warrant material. Prosecutors will have to prove the charges in court, while Gatto will have the opportunity to challenge the state’s evidence and account of the events.
The 911 recording is now one part of a much larger evidentiary record that prosecutors and the defense may examine as the case advances. Its account of a possible accidental fire stands against the fire marshal’s conclusion that the blaze was intentionally set and the medical finding that Pederson died before it began. Gatto remains jailed without bail, and the competing accounts of what happened inside the home have yet to be tested at trial.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.