Rejected suitor kills 22-year-old Minnesota woman after she says she wants friendship

Kayli Arseth repeatedly defined the relationship as friendship before Jose Luis Lopez Xique was convicted of murdering her.

RICHFIELD, Minn. — Hours before Kayli Grace Arseth was killed inside her Richfield apartment, the 22-year-old sent a message explaining that she did not have the capacity for a romantic relationship. More than a year later, the man receiving those messages was convicted of her premeditated murder and sentenced to spend the rest of his life in prison without parole.

The final exchanges between Arseth and Jose Luis Lopez Xique became one part of a broader prosecution that included phone-location evidence, surveillance video, a neighbor’s account and items investigators recovered along the route Lopez Xique’s phone traveled after leaving the apartment area. A Hennepin County jury convicted Lopez Xique, 27, on Oct. 9 of first-degree premeditated murder, second-degree intentional murder and aggravated harassment involving a dangerous weapon. A judge sentenced him Oct. 15 to life without the possibility of parole, the mandatory penalty prosecutors said followed the first-degree conviction.

The relationship described in the court record began online. Arseth and Lopez Xique spent time together and communicated often enough on Snapchat to have a “best friend” badge and a daily-message streak, according to the criminal complaint. Friends said Lopez Xique bought things for Arseth during shopping trips. But investigators were also told that the relationship was not romantic or sexual. Messages reviewed after Arseth’s death showed a sharper distinction: Lopez Xique was asking for a romantic relationship and “actual dates,” while Arseth said she viewed him as a friend and did not feel a romantic attraction to him.

That distinction became especially clear on the afternoon of June 16, 2025. According to the filing, Arseth messaged Lopez Xique at 2:55 p.m. and said that although she enjoyed spending time with him, she did not have enough mental capacity for a relationship. She described herself as overwhelmed and stressed while trying to manage other parts of her life. Lopez Xique answered that he was confused and believed she might be looking for something different. Arseth responded that she simply was not ready for a relationship. Lopez Xique then said he could “tone it back” and that the two could continue communicating as they had before.

On its face, the exchange ended with an acknowledgment of Arseth’s boundary. The location evidence described by investigators told a different part of the story. Lopez Xique’s phone was already at her apartment building by 3:38 p.m., according to the complaint. Arseth worked until late that afternoon and returned home. The filing says Lopez Xique sent her another message from the apartment location at 4:06 p.m., telling her to have fun because he knew she had plans with friends. His device remained at the building until 4:49 p.m.

A neighbor supplied investigators with an account of what happened during part of that window. The neighbor reported hearing yelling from Arseth’s apartment shortly after 4:30 p.m. and could distinguish a male voice in the argument. The criminal complaint says the neighbor heard Arseth say, “How could you do this to me?” The neighbor then heard someone leave the apartment about 10 minutes later without seeing who it was. That wording in the filed complaint differs from some published accounts that assigned the statement to Lopez Xique. The court filing places the words with Arseth.

Outside the apartment, another clock was already running. Arseth had made plans for a friend to pick her up around 5 p.m. The friend arrived, called and texted repeatedly and then went to her door when she did not come outside. A neighbor also came into the hallway during the attempts to reach her. After waiting without a response, the friend left but contacted Arseth’s father because the situation seemed unusual. Family and friends continued trying to reach her by phone, text, social media and in person. Arseth then failed to appear at work the next morning.

Her family asked Richfield police to check on her June 17. Officers found her vehicle in the parking lot, and her shared phone location indicated that her phone was still in the apartment. The door was locked. After repeated knocks produced no answer, officers obtained a key from apartment management and entered. Arseth was found dead in the living room from a gunshot wound. The Hennepin County Medical Examiner ruled the death a homicide. Investigators also noted that Arseth’s apartment key was missing from her key ring, according to the complaint.

While friends and family were trying to reach Arseth on June 16, investigators say Lopez Xique’s phone was moving away from the building. It went first to a hardware store. Surveillance there showed a man matching his description getting out of a blue BMW while wearing dark clothing and a surgical mask, the complaint says. He bought beverages and steel shoe covers. At 5:19 p.m., the phone was stationary for several minutes in West Bloomington. Police later searched that area and recovered two bags containing ammunition, clothing, an empty gauze box, disposable gloves, shoes, sunglasses and a hat.

More items were found in nearby trash bins, including wipes, masking tape, rubber gloves and packaging for some of the discarded products. Investigators said surveillance and store records showed Lopez Xique had purchased several of those goods at a large retailer around noon that day. Cameras recorded him consulting a written list while selecting items, according to the complaint. The prosecution’s probable-cause account did not rely on that evidence alone. Police also obtained search warrants for his home and car, where the investigation continued.

At Lopez Xique’s residence, officers recovered a Glock 9 mm firearm, a sight adapter and electronic storage equipment, according to the initial filing. The complaint stated that forensic testing of the gun remained in progress at the time the case was first charged. Police also photographed scratches on his chest and puncture wounds to his forearm. When he was arrested, investigators said he appeared unsurprised and did not ask why officers were taking him into custody. After being advised of his rights, he ultimately requested an attorney rather than answering investigators’ questions, according to the complaint.

The first criminal complaint, filed July 7, 2025, accused Lopez Xique of second-degree intentional murder. The case that eventually went to the jury included a more serious first-degree premeditated murder count as well as the harassment charge. Prosecutors announced Oct. 9, 2026, that jurors had convicted him on every count. Six days later, the first-degree verdict produced the most severe sentencing consequence available in the case: life imprisonment with no possibility of parole.

Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty has described the crime as a “rejection killing,” saying Arseth was targeted after making clear that she did not want the relationship Lopez Xique wanted. At sentencing, Moriarty linked that description to what she called a wider pattern of gender-based violence, while acknowledging that there is no precise count of such killings because they can be categorized with other forms of violence. The prosecutor’s office also focused attention on who Arseth was outside the case, describing her as a young woman who loved art, music, family and friends, was restoring a motorcycle and worked with children with special needs.

The legal case is now past both verdict and sentencing. Lopez Xique is serving a life sentence without parole. For the jury, the communications that began as private messages between two people became part of the evidence used to establish a sequence: Arseth repeatedly said she wanted friendship, Lopez Xique’s phone was placed at her building after those exchanges, a neighbor heard an argument, and investigators traced his movements away from the apartment before police found Arseth dead the next day.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.