Separated Florida man killed his 7-year-old and 5-year-old children before their mother came for custody exchange cops say

Remy and Aria Dingwall had missed school before their mother went looking for them and found them with their father.

COCOA, Fla. — Olivia Piccolo was supposed to have her children on Oct. 7, but the routine custody transition never happened. After 7-year-old Remy Dingwall and 5-year-old Aria Dingwall missed school and their father could not be reached, she went to his Cocoa home and found all three dead, according to police and reports based on the 911 call.

The circumstances that brought Piccolo to the residence are central to the police account of the case. Cocoa investigators say the children’s father, 37-year-old Joseph Kyle Dingwall, killed Remy and Aria and then died by suicide. The three were found inside the Sorrento Drive home shortly before 1 p.m. Police have said the deaths were caused by gunfire, but they have not released a motive or a detailed explanation of what happened inside the house before Piccolo arrived.

The children’s school absence added to Piccolo’s concerns that morning. Florida Today reported that she went to check on them after they were marked absent. Cocoa Police Chief Evander Collier IV also said Piccolo had tried to reach Dingwall and that Oct. 7 was her day to have the children. Those details meant the lack of contact was not simply an unanswered call: the children were expected elsewhere, and their mother was waiting for a transfer of custody that did not occur.

When Piccolo reached Dingwall’s home, the front door was partially ajar, Collier said. She went inside and found Dingwall and both children unresponsive. Her 911 call, later released by authorities and described by Florida Today, captured her reporting what she had found and telling dispatchers there was a gun at the scene. Reports place the emergency call at about 12:43 p.m. Police officers converged on the home and secured it, beginning an investigation that initially centered on three unexplained deaths.

The first public statements were cautious. Officers said preliminary evidence suggested a murder-suicide and told residents they did not believe there was an active danger to the surrounding neighborhood. Detectives interviewed witnesses while crime-scene technicians processed the residence. By the next day’s briefing, police had identified Dingwall, Remy and Aria and said investigators believed the father was responsible for killing the two children before taking his own life. The department’s conclusion remained an investigative finding rather than a court judgment because there is no surviving suspect to prosecute.

Only after the discovery did another piece of the previous night come into focus. Neighbor Marcos Garcia said he had heard two gunshots at about 12:20 a.m. from the direction of the house. A surveillance camera across the street captured a man outside around the same time. Video aired by local television stations showed the figure moving around the property, at one point carrying or using a light. Police said they believed the man in the recording was Dingwall. No emergency call reporting the overnight gunshots was made at the time, Collier said.

The overnight evidence does not answer every question. Authorities have not said whether the sounds reported by Garcia account for all of the gunfire involved in the three deaths, or precisely when Remy, Aria and Dingwall died. Nor have police released a minute-by-minute reconstruction connecting the surveillance recording to the physical evidence found inside. The video and witness account instead provide investigators with a reference point many hours before Piccolo arrived, narrowing part of a timeline whose most consequential events occurred without a known surviving eyewitness.

Police records added another layer but not a clear explanation. Collier said officers had been dispatched to the address about 11 times since 2021 for matters ranging from medical calls to suspicious activity. One dispatch report used “suicide” as a call classification. The chief said he could not confirm whether that earlier entry concerned Dingwall or someone else. Police did not release details showing that those prior responses involved threats toward the children, and no public information has established that officers had previously been told Dingwall intended to harm Remy or Aria.

For that reason, the earlier police history cannot be treated as a known chain of warnings leading to the deaths. It establishes that the department had been called to the property before, but officials have not disclosed enough about those contacts to characterize them more broadly. The investigation also has not produced a publicly stated motive. Collier did not announce a custody dispute, financial conflict, mental-health diagnosis or other explanation as the cause of the killings, and no such explanation can be inferred merely from the fact that Piccolo and Dingwall shared custody.

The custody arrangement is relevant because it explains why Piccolo went to the home and why she expected the children that day. Police have not said the killings occurred during an argument over the exchange or in Piccolo’s presence. The information released by investigators instead places the mother at the end of the known sequence: she could not reach Dingwall, learned or knew that the children had not attended school, went to the house on her custody day and encountered a partially open door. What had happened before her arrival remains the focus of the evidence gathered afterward.

Family members described a recent period that gave them no obvious explanation. Dingwall’s grandmother, Cheryl Trimmer, told Florida Today that he had taken the children out during the preceding weekend and said the family had gone to a movie Friday night. She remembered him as someone who loved his children and said she felt numb after the deaths. Her comments underscored the gap between relatives’ recent interactions and the conclusion police reached, rather than providing investigators with a motive.

Friends supporting Piccolo have tried to keep attention on the children themselves. Fundraisers created after their deaths described Remy and Aria as unusually close siblings. Remy was remembered as a kind, intelligent boy who enjoyed video games, music and time with friends. Aria was described as compassionate and courageous, with a love of animals and the color pink. Organizers said the children were at the center of their mother’s life and sought help with funeral costs and the financial disruption created by their deaths.

The mother’s role in discovering the scene also means the first emergency response began with a parent who was arriving to retrieve her children rather than a neighbor reporting violence in progress. Police have not suggested Piccolo was involved in the deaths. Their account identifies her as the person who found the three and called for help. The distinction matters because some early reports described the case broadly as a family tragedy before investigators publicly assigned responsibility to Dingwall based on the evidence collected at the home.

For Piccolo, the sequence began not with an emergency alert but with ordinary signs that her children’s day was off course: they had missed school, their father was not answering and they were supposed to be with her. Police have not announced evidence that she knew violence had occurred before she reached the house. The custody handoff therefore remains significant for a different reason — it was the routine family obligation that brought someone to the home, triggered the 911 call and exposed a crime investigators believe had already taken place.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.