She told investigators Dudley discussed shooting his stepfather before a confrontation that he later described as an accidental discharge.
NEW PLYMOUTH, Idaho — Before Michael Dudley and his girlfriend drove to the home of his mother and stepfather on Sept. 18, Dudley talked about shooting his stepfather in the foot “to make him jump and work,” the girlfriend later told investigators. Hours later, 47-year-old Howard Schofield IV was dead, and Dudley was in custody facing a first-degree murder case in which he says the fatal shot was never intentional.
The girlfriend’s statement sits at the center of a sharp contrast in the evidence described in a probable cause affidavit. On one side is Dudley’s account of a physical confrontation in which he says Schofield attacked him, grabbed at a gun carried in his sweatshirt pocket and caused it to fire. On the other is evidence that Dudley had spoken about using the gun before arriving. The girlfriend said she did not think Dudley would follow through on the earlier remark, and she did not witness the shot itself. Investigators and prosecutors nevertheless included the statement as they built a case charging Dudley with first-degree murder and burglary.
The girlfriend did hear part of the struggle. According to the affidavit, she told law enforcement she heard Dudley tell Schofield not to hit him and heard him order Schofield to get off him. Those statements are consistent with at least part of Dudley’s description of a physical fight, but they do not establish what either man was doing at the instant the firearm discharged. The girlfriend said she did not see the shooting. Her account therefore gives investigators information about what was said before the visit and what she heard during the confrontation, while leaving the critical moment itself outside her direct observation.
Dudley told police that Schofield had become angry after accusing him of stealing property from the New Plymouth home. He said the argument turned physical and that Schofield began hitting him before ending up on top of him. Dudley had a firearm in the front pocket of his sweatshirt, according to his statement. He said Schofield grabbed it during the struggle and the weapon went off. Dudley told investigators he did not pull the trigger and never intended to shoot Schofield. He said he was trying to defend himself, an assertion that remains part of his account rather than a finding by a court.
The encounter did not begin as a dispute over a gun. Court records described by East Idaho News say it grew out of a disagreement over work Schofield had been paid to perform on a trailer occupied by Dudley and his girlfriend. They had paid him $2,250 for remodeling, according to the affidavit. The girlfriend told investigators that their trailer did not have a functioning bathroom or shower and that the work had not been done. Frustration over the unfinished project led Dudley to seek what he described as compensation from property at the home where Schofield lived with Dudley’s mother.
According to Dudley’s account, he first contacted his mother and told her he would need compensation because the promised work had not been completed. He said the plan was to take items from the home and that his mother agreed. Once Dudley and his girlfriend arrived, he began collecting property, including a television and some of Schofield’s tools, the affidavit says. Schofield objected and accused his stepson of stealing. The disagreement over who had a right to the property then escalated into the argument and physical fight described to investigators.
Prosecutors’ burglary allegation gives those events significance beyond the ownership dispute itself. Idaho law defines burglary as entering a house or certain other places with the intent to commit theft or another felony. Whether prosecutors can prove the required intent is a question for the case. Dudley’s reported assertion that his mother agreed to the plan is part of the factual record that may bear on the circumstances of his entry and his claimed reason for taking the items. The filing of a burglary charge reflects the prosecution’s allegation; it does not establish that burglary occurred.
The burglary count also helps explain the severity of the accompanying homicide charge. Idaho law includes burglary among the underlying felonies that can elevate a murder committed during the felony or attempted felony to first-degree murder. That means the prosecution’s legal theory can differ from the more familiar form of a murder allegation based on a planned intent to kill. Dudley’s statement that he did not intend to fire the gun therefore does not, on its own, eliminate the possibility of a first-degree murder prosecution. The state still must prove the required elements, and Dudley can contest both the burglary allegation and the homicide theory.
The girlfriend’s pre-visit statement may also be considered alongside Dudley’s own reaction when investigators asked about the idea. The affidavit says Dudley acknowledged that discussing shooting Schofield in the foot had been a “stupid idea.” The available reports do not say that the girlfriend described the remark as a detailed plan, nor do they establish that Dudley attempted to carry it out as stated. Her account is significant because it places discussion of firearm use before the confrontation, but the evidence described publicly still leaves a factual gap between that discussion and Dudley’s claim that the actual discharge occurred during a struggle.
Police were summoned at about 7:30 p.m. to the residence on Southwest Fourth Avenue near Adams Road. Deputies from the Payette County Sheriff’s Office responded with Payette and Fruitland police and county paramedics. First responders tried to save Schofield, but authorities said he died at the scene. Dudley was arrested there. Officials initially said nobody else was known to have been injured and there was no ongoing danger to the public. State forensic personnel, the county prosecutor and the coroner’s office assisted with the investigation.
Dudley later appeared in Payette County court, where his bond was set at $1 million. Prosecutors cited concerns that included flight risk and possible witness tampering, according to KIVI. One issue raised was the importance of Dudley’s mother as a potential witness because she was married to Schofield and was also the person Dudley said had approved taking property from the residence. Those arguments related to pretrial detention and did not determine the ultimate truth of the homicide allegations.
Dudley should not be described as convicted on the basis of the available reporting. The unresolved case remains centered on evidence from before, during and immediately after the confrontation: an earlier remark about a gun, an argument over property, a girlfriend who heard but did not see the fatal struggle, and Dudley’s assertion that the shot that killed his stepfather was never meant to be fired.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.