Strange woman allegedly targeted sisters then fatally stabbed 7-year-old girl

Shavon Gayden remains charged with first-degree murder as a judge examines whether she is presently fit to stand trial.

CHICAGO, Ill. — The criminal case against a woman accused of killing 7-year-old Eddimar Paola Hernández Chacón has moved into a new phase after a Cook County judge ordered Shavon Gayden detained and directed that she undergo an evaluation to determine whether she is competent to stand trial.

The evaluation does not decide whether Gayden, 48, committed the killing prosecutors have charged her with, nor does it resolve any potential mental health defense. Instead, it addresses whether she currently understands the proceedings and can assist her attorney. That issue arose after Gayden’s initial hearings were postponed while she was hospitalized and after her public defender raised concerns about her psychiatric condition. Behind that legal question is the Oct. 3 death of Eddimar, who prosecutors say was walking with her 17-year-old sister in Chicago’s Chatham neighborhood when Gayden suddenly attacked them.

At Gayden’s detention hearing, prosecutors described an encounter they said was captured in part by surveillance cameras and seen by several witnesses. Eddimar and her sister were on South Cottage Grove Avenue shortly before noon when Gayden allegedly moved toward them while holding a knife. The older sister avoided the first lunge, prosecutors said. Gayden then allegedly grabbed the younger child, forced her down and stabbed her four times in the back. The account remains an allegation that prosecutors must prove in court. Gayden has been charged with first-degree murder and has not been convicted.

The legal proceedings were delayed almost immediately. Witnesses chased Gayden after the attack and restrained her before officers arrived, according to police and prosecutors. She was injured during that confrontation and hospitalized, preventing her from attending the first scheduled detention hearing. A second hearing was also delayed. Those postponements meant prosecutors began presenting portions of their account while Gayden was still receiving medical care. When she later appeared, the court confronted both the state’s request to keep her detained and defense concerns about her ability to participate meaningfully in the case.

Assistant Public Defender Brett Balmer told reporters and the court that Gayden was in a severe psychiatric crisis. The defense described years of mental health problems and periods of homelessness, and Gayden’s relatives said they had struggled to secure lasting treatment for her. Balmer did not argue that Gayden should be released while the murder case is pending. Instead, the defense emphasized a need for psychiatric care and asked the court to order an evaluation. The judge granted an examination after Gayden’s behavior during the hearing added to questions about her mental state.

That distinction is important in the criminal process. Competency to stand trial concerns a defendant’s present ability to understand what is happening in court and work with counsel. It is separate from questions about a defendant’s mental condition at the time of an alleged offense. A finding that someone is not presently competent would not amount to an acquittal, while a finding of competency would not determine whether the person is guilty. Public reporting reviewed for this story does not establish the result of Gayden’s ordered evaluation or a later final resolution of the murder charge.

Prosecutors have also used Gayden’s conduct shortly before the attack to build the sequence of events. They said she had entered a nearby cellphone business to pay a bill, became impatient and threatened a worker during a dispute. She left the store and soon encountered Eddimar and her sister. Authorities have not said the girls were involved in the business dispute, and investigators have not announced a motive linking that confrontation to the killing. Police initially described the sidewalk attack as unprovoked, and reporting from multiple outlets said Gayden was not known to the child.

Investigators say their evidence includes video, witness statements and knives recovered after the encounter. Prosecutors said surveillance footage showed Gayden approaching the sisters and described witnesses who saw the confrontation. A knife believed to be connected to the killing was recovered near the scene, while two additional knives were found in a bag Gayden had been carrying, according to the state’s account. Those details remain part of the prosecution’s case and have not been tested at trial. The defense will be entitled to challenge the admissibility, interpretation and weight of that evidence if the case proceeds to trial.

The detention hearing also brought Gayden’s criminal history into the court’s assessment of whether she could safely be released. Prosecutors cited earlier arrests involving allegations of knives in 2016 and 2019. Those cases were dismissed after the complaining witnesses did not continue with the prosecutions. Later proceedings produced convictions. Records reported by Chicago news organizations show Gayden pleaded guilty in 2024 to aggravated battery of a CTA employee and received two years of probation. She later pleaded guilty to misdemeanor assault and battery after a separate incident involving an emergency shelter worker and received court supervision.

A warrant tied to the probation case had also been issued before Eddimar’s death after Gayden failed to appear for a hearing, according to the court records reviewed by local news outlets. Prosecutors referenced that history when arguing for detention. Judge John Hock ultimately ordered Gayden held while the murder prosecution continues. The detention decision addresses whether she should remain in custody before trial; it is not a finding that she is guilty of killing Eddimar. The charge must still be resolved through the criminal process.

Outside the courtroom, the focus for Eddimar’s family has remained on the child they lost. Relatives and members of the community gathered near the Cottage Grove Avenue scene after her death, and a memorial Mass was held at Our Lady of Guadalupe Church. Her family described her as a happy child who liked drawing and spending time with her siblings. Staff from Tanner Elementary, where she was a student, joined mourners. Her mother publicly asked that her daughter’s death be met with justice, while relatives faced funeral arrangements and the sudden loss of a 7-year-old whose final walk had begun as an ordinary trip with her sister.

The bystanders who intervened also became part of the case’s factual record. Police said people nearby rushed toward the child and followed Gayden as she left. Gayden was eventually knocked down and held until officers arrived. Although the confrontation left her injured and contributed to the delay in her first court appearance, police credited civilians with preventing her departure. Investigators then began collecting video and physical evidence along the commercial stretch of Cottage Grove Avenue. Eddimar was transported to Comer Children’s Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.

What remains unresolved publicly is why the child was attacked. No reliable account reviewed for this article establishes a prior relationship between Gayden and Eddimar, and authorities have not announced a motive. The prosecution has described the killing as part of a sudden sequence that began after Gayden left the nearby business, but that chronology does not by itself explain intent or cause. Questions about Gayden’s psychiatric condition may become significant as the case proceeds, but they do not justify unsupported conclusions about why the alleged attack occurred.

As of the latest verified reporting reviewed for this article, Gayden had been ordered to remain in custody and to undergo a competency evaluation. Publicly available coverage located in this search did not establish a later final disposition of that evaluation or of the murder case. She remains accused of first-degree murder, and the presumption of innocence applies unless the charge is proven in court.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.