Texas man strangles ex-girlfriend after beating her with carjack because she reported him for stalking

A warrant for Karl Stanley’s arrest was obtained about two hours before prosecutors say he entered Paola Becvar’s home and killed her.

McKINNEY, Texas — About two hours before Paola Becvar was killed inside her Celina home, a detective had obtained a warrant to arrest her former boyfriend, Karl Andrew Stanley, for stalking, according to testimony that became a key part of the capital murder case against him.

The warrant marked the final step in a series of police contacts that prosecutors said began when Becvar reported harassment and stalking in early November 2024. Before the month ended, police had issued Stanley a criminal trespass warning, arrested him for violating it and pursued a separate stalking case. On Nov. 25, before officers could arrest him on the newly obtained warrant, prosecutors said Stanley broke into Becvar’s home armed with a car jack and killed her. Nearly two years later, a Collin County jury convicted Stanley of capital murder, and Judge Richard Davis sentenced him to life in prison without parole.

Detective Frank Alegre testified that Becvar had been reporting Stanley’s behavior to the Celina Police Department since early that November. Prosecutors said police responded by formally warning Stanley to stay away from her home. The warning created a documented boundary between the former couple and gave officers grounds to act if Stanley returned. Authorities said he nevertheless violated the trespass warning and was arrested in the days immediately before the killing. He was later released, leaving the separate stalking investigation still moving through the law-enforcement process.

By Nov. 25, Alegre had obtained the stalking arrest warrant. The district attorney’s office said that happened about two hours before Becvar was attacked. That fact did not mean officers had already taken Stanley into custody; the warrant authorized his arrest, but the killing occurred before it could be carried out. Prosecutors later used the timing to establish the sequence behind their retaliation theory: Becvar had reported Stanley, police had escalated their response, and Stanley then went to her home. The state argued that her efforts to involve police were the reason he targeted her.

The criminal case then shifted from an investigation of stalking to a homicide scene. A carpenter working inside Becvar’s home in the Mustang Lakes subdivision saw Stanley enter carrying a car jack, according to evidence presented at trial. The worker said Stanley began attacking Becvar with it. He intervened and managed to take the tool away from Stanley. Prosecutors said Stanley continued pursuing Becvar through the residence after losing the car jack and ultimately strangled her. The worker called Celina police, providing officers with an eyewitness account before they reached the property.

Responding officers encountered a scene that closely matched the caller’s report. Stanley was still inside the house, only a short distance from Becvar’s body, the district attorney’s office said. Officers took him into custody. Becvar, 51, died at the residence. Early reports from Celina police described the response as beginning with a burglary call on Seattle Slew Drive. At that stage, police publicly said Stanley and Becvar knew one another but released limited information about a motive while investigators worked through the recent stalking and trespassing history.

Detectives then gathered evidence that prosecutors later presented to the jury. Joseph Shires obtained search warrants for Becvar’s home, Stanley’s DNA and Stanley’s vehicle. Investigators recovered the car jack outside the house, consistent with the carpenter’s account that he had taken it away during the attack. DNA analysis confirmed Becvar’s blood on Stanley’s hands, prosecutors said. The physical evidence helped corroborate the witness testimony and the observations of officers who arrived while Stanley was still at the property.

A search of Stanley’s vehicle added another element to the state’s theory of the case. Investigators found a document labeled “grudge list,” according to the district attorney’s office, and Becvar’s name appeared first. Prosecutors presented the document with the stalking reports and other evidence to argue that the killing was not an unexplained encounter but retaliation directed at a woman who had been trying to stop unwanted conduct through police intervention. The prosecution did not need to rely on the document alone; the state combined it with the prior reports, trespass enforcement, pending stalking warrant, eyewitness testimony and forensic evidence.

Stanley pleaded not guilty to capital murder, putting the prosecution to its burden of proving the charge. At trial, jurors heard about Becvar’s reports to police, the criminal trespass warning, Stanley’s recent arrest, the stalking warrant obtained shortly before the killing and the events witnessed inside the house. They also heard about the car jack, the DNA findings and the material recovered from Stanley’s vehicle. After the evidence and arguments were completed, the jury deliberated for less than an hour before returning a guilty verdict.

The verdict determined the punishment. The Collin County District Attorney’s Office said Stanley’s capital murder conviction required life imprisonment without the possibility of parole under Texas law. Judge Richard Davis imposed that sentence. District Attorney Greg Willis said after the case that Stanley had killed Becvar because she reported his stalking to police. The prosecutor emphasized both the home invasion and the lasting effect on Becvar’s family, contrasting Stanley’s imprisonment with the loss her relatives would continue to face.

The case also shows how rapidly the documented sequence developed. What began with reports of harassment in early November progressed to a trespass warning, an arrest for violating that warning and a stalking warrant before the month was over. The existence of those interventions did not prevent the fatal attack. At trial, however, the records and testimony surrounding them supplied prosecutors with a detailed chronology of the relationship between Becvar’s reports, Stanley’s police contacts and the killing. That chronology became one of the clearest ways for the state to explain why it believed Stanley went to the house.

Becvar’s identity and life extended far beyond that timeline. Funeral information published after her death said she was born in Trujillo, Peru, in 1973 and lived in Celina. She was survived by her daughter, parents, siblings and other relatives. Friends described her after the verdict as a person of faith and warmth whose life should not be reduced to the way she died. Those accounts offered a different record from the police chronology: one centered on Becvar as a mother, daughter, sister and friend rather than as the victim identified in a capital murder prosecution.

Stanley’s conviction and mandatory sentence now close the trial and sentencing stage of the case stemming from the Nov. 25, 2024, killing. He is to remain imprisoned for life without parole. The stalking warrant that had been waiting to be served that afternoon became part of a later murder prosecution instead, preserved in testimony as one of the final events in the weeks-long sequence before Becvar’s death.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.