A probable cause account provides new detail about what Ellis County deputies encountered after a pre-dawn 911 hang-up call.
WAXAHACHIE, Texas — A confusing 911 call, evidence recovered inside a home and an alleged statement to deputies form the core of the publicly reported probable cause case against a Texas mother accused of fatally shooting her two sons in Waxahachie.
Colleen Nichole Lemmon, 42, faces two counts of capital murder in the Oct. 1 deaths of Christopher Scott Pitre, 21, and his 15-year-old brother. The Ellis County Sheriff’s Office initially announced the arrest by saying investigators had recovered corroborating evidence that gave them probable cause to identify Lemmon as responsible for the shootings. Later reports citing the arrest documentation added details about the emergency call, the scene encountered by deputies and words authorities say Lemmon spoke after they arrived. None of those allegations has been established at trial.
The case began not with a detailed report of a shooting but with a communication problem. The Sheriff’s Office said its emergency center received a call about an unknown emergency shortly after 4 a.m. NBC 5 later reported, based on a probable cause narrative, that dispatchers first received a 911 hang-up. They were able to reconnect with a female caller, who allegedly said all units were needed. Dispatchers were unable to get a clear explanation of the emergency before the call ended again, according to that account.
That uncertainty shaped the initial response. Deputies went to the 900 block of Big Sky Drive without a publicly reported description of an armed suspect, wounded person or domestic dispute. When they reached the residence, the scene immediately became more serious. Reporting on the probable cause narrative said deputies saw Lemmon with blood on her hands and heard her calling for additional units. The Sheriff’s Office later confirmed that Lemmon was inside the home when deputies arrived and that she had injuries that were not considered life-threatening.
Inside the residence, deputies found two male victims who had been shot. Christopher Scott Pitre, 21, was pronounced dead at the scene. His younger brother, 15, was alive when first responders reached him and was taken to a hospital in critical condition. Authorities later announced that the teenager had died. The Sheriff’s Office initially withheld the juvenile’s name. NBC 5 subsequently reported that the family publicly identified him as Brian Pitre. The deaths left investigators with two homicide victims inside the same home.
The arrest documentation, as reported by FOX 4 and other outlets, describes additional evidence that authorities believed connected Lemmon to the shootings. Deputies found a gun near her, according to those reports. When officers questioned her about the blood, Lemmon allegedly said, “I shot both my kids.” Investigators also described injuries to Lemmon that appeared to be self-inflicted. Because those details come from a probable cause record, they represent the government’s account of why there was a legal basis for the arrest rather than a judicial finding that the allegations are true.
The Sheriff’s Office publicly summarized its investigative conclusion in more general terms. Detectives developed probable cause through corroborating evidence recovered during the investigation, the agency said. Officials did not publicly release a full inventory of every item collected from the residence or explain which specific pieces of physical evidence they consider most significant. The available reporting does not establish whether laboratory testing had been completed at the time of the arrest or what forensic results, if any, prosecutors may ultimately seek to introduce in court.
Lemmon was taken into custody after deputies responded to the house but first received treatment at a local hospital for her injuries. After her release, authorities booked her into the Wayne McCollum Detention Center on two capital murder counts. Initial reports said bond was awaiting a determination. Updated jail information cited by People and other news organizations later showed a $2.5 million bond. The public record described in those reports did not show a conviction, and the charges remain allegations unless established through a guilty plea or court verdict.
The probable cause account answers some questions about why investigators arrested Lemmon so quickly but does not answer one of the largest questions surrounding the case. Authorities have not publicly announced a motive. The Sheriff’s Office did not describe an argument, threat or other event immediately preceding the shootings. It also did not release a public explanation of the relationship inside the home beyond identifying Lemmon as the victims’ mother. As a result, the available record is more detailed about what deputies say they encountered afterward than about what allegedly occurred before the 911 call.
That difference between evidence of responsibility and evidence of motive is a defining feature of the public information released so far. Investigators say they found enough corroborating evidence to accuse Lemmon of shooting both sons, and the probable cause narrative includes a statement attributed to her. But no publicly verified account reviewed for this story explains why authorities believe the violence began. A motive is not something journalists can fill in from the circumstances, and speculation about family conflict, mental state or other possible causes would go beyond the evidence released by investigators.
The 15-year-old victim’s initial condition also shows that the two deaths were confirmed at different stages of the investigation. Christopher was pronounced dead at the residence. His younger brother was rushed to a hospital while investigators were still dealing with the scene and Lemmon’s injuries. Only later did authorities announce that the teenager had died. That development changed what had begun as one confirmed death and one critically injured victim into a case involving the deaths of both brothers and two capital murder counts against their mother.
The brothers’ father, Scott Pitre, later spoke to NBC 5 about the loss. He said the younger boy had recently turned 15 and that the family had celebrated his birthday at a lake only days before the shooting. He said he wanted justice for both sons. His account did not provide a motive for the killings, but it offered a view of the victims apart from the police narrative and court allegations that dominated the first reports about the case.
Ellis County Sheriff Brad Norman also addressed the victims’ relatives after the teenager’s death was confirmed. Norman said his “deepest sympathies” were with their father, family and loved ones. The statement did not discuss the strength of the evidence in detail or predict the outcome of the prosecution. Instead, the agency’s public case description remained focused on the timeline of the response, the discovery of the two wounded brothers, the evidence investigators said supported probable cause and Lemmon’s subsequent booking.
For prosecutors, the next phase centers on whether the evidence described in the probable cause record can withstand scrutiny in court. Lemmon remained charged with two counts of capital murder in the most recent reliable reporting, with bond listed at $2.5 million. No final disposition had been reported as of Nov. 16, and the alleged statements and physical evidence cited by investigators have not yet been tested at trial.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.