Newburgh, New York, has been rocked by the recent indictment of a 13-year-old boy on murder charges in connection with the death of 11-year-old Matthew DeGroat. The young suspect, appearing at an emotionally charged arraignment, pleaded not guilty in a courtroom filled with tension, as family members on both sides grappled with the weight of the tragedy.
Matthew’s relatives attended the proceedings wearing T-shirts emblazoned with his image, while the accused, handcuffed and shackled, was led into the courtroom. His mother, visibly distraught, expressed her love for him, urging him to remain strong amid the turmoil.
The shooting incident occurred on the morning of October 9, 2024, in Matthew’s home on North Miller Street. Matthew had recently relocated to Newburgh from Middletown after the passing of his father. Community members are struggling to come to terms with the heartbreaking event, which has gained attention beyond local boundaries.
During the arraignment, prosecutors disclosed that the firearm used in the shooting belonged to the suspect. They alleged that the defendant had previously pointed the weapon at another individual and intentionally shot Matthew in the head. Authorities previously indicated that Matthew had faced bullying, with public social media footage capturing a troubling incident involving a peer just days before his death.
As the court hearing unfolded, prosecutors illustrated the troubled background of the 13-year-old, detailing his unstable living conditions, sporadic school attendance, and recent mental health crises, including a suicide attempt. They also mentioned that he had previously been involved in an incident involving gunfire in Newburgh.
The Orange County District Attorney’s Office is seeking a protective order to control access to evidence in the case, aimed at safeguarding underage witnesses and sensitive information. This order would allow the defense attorney to review materials while restricting public and familial access.
Defense attorney Laisa Pertet criticized the prosecution’s handling of the case, suggesting their request for a protective order indicated a desire to obscure what she characterized as a hasty investigation. Pertet highlighted the complexities of the case, noting that multiple children and an adult were present in the home at the time of the shooting.
LaTanya Watkins, representing Matthew’s family, expressed gratitude that the legal process was moving forward. “They are waiting for the day when justice is served for Matthew,” she stated, affirming the family’s commitment to supporting their cause.
Judge Craig Brown denied bail for the teen but permitted the submission of a written bail application from the defense. He also issued protective orders for three of Matthew’s family members, emphasizing the need for emotional control as tensions have led to threats against individuals connected to both families. Security measures were heightened in the courtroom, with families exiting separately to ensure safety.
The accused is scheduled to appear in court again on December 3. In addition to second-degree murder charges, he faces counts of tampering with physical evidence and menacing, as the community and family members continue to seek answers and justice in the wake of this devastating event.