Forensic testing, competency evaluations and witness issues stretched the case from a 2018 killing to a 2026 jury trial.
SALT LAKE CITY, Utah — Nearly eight years after Candace Samples was killed behind a Salt Lake City discount store, Kidus Chane Yohannes has been sentenced to life without parole in a case that moved from a 2018 crime scene through delayed DNA testing, a 2021 prosecution and a 2026 jury trial.
The long timeline is central to the case that ended with Yohannes’ Sept. 29 sentencing. Investigators collected evidence soon after the Nov. 7, 2018, stabbing, including shoes they believed had blood on them, but prosecutors have said forensic analysis took time. Yohannes was charged years later, and the court case encountered additional delays involving biological evidence, competency evaluations and witness availability. A jury finally convicted him of aggravated murder in August before Third District Judge Kristine Johnson imposed life without the possibility of parole.
The investigation began after Salt Lake City police received a report that two people had been stabbed near 477 N. 300 West. Officers found a scene behind a Dollar Tree that has since closed. Samples, 20, and Jeffrey Plante were taken for emergency medical treatment. Samples died after arriving at the hospital. Plante survived. Police began interviewing witnesses and reconstructing a confrontation that had started nearby with a dispute over a cellphone.
According to prosecutors, investigators learned that Samples had taken Yohannes’ phone while at the Marmalade Branch Library. The dispute later continued in a dumpster enclosure behind the store, where Samples, Yohannes and others were present. Prosecutors said Yohannes produced a knife and said he would use it if the phone was not returned. A witness who observed what was happening left the immediate area and went to a nearby 7-Eleven to seek help.
Plante responded to that call for help and ran toward the enclosure. Prosecutors said he was attacked after entering it and suffered multiple stab wounds. Another person inside the enclosure climbed over a wall to escape, obtained a large board and returned. That witness then saw Yohannes attacking Samples, according to the district attorney’s account. The enclosure gates were opened, and Yohannes left. What investigators had initially approached as an active stabbing scene soon became a homicide investigation after Samples died.
Police located Yohannes and questioned him. Prosecutors said he denied involvement in the stabbings and denied knowledge of or interaction with the victims. Investigators nevertheless retained evidence they believed could connect him to the attack. Surveillance footage from the 7-Eleven showed Yohannes and Samples entering and leaving the business together before the violence, authorities said. Police also took his shoes, which appeared to have blood on them. The physical evidence later became particularly important as the case remained unresolved.
By 2021, forensic work had produced a significant development. Police said testing of blood associated with Yohannes’ clothing or footwear linked the biological material to Samples. The Salt Lake Tribune reported at the time that state crime laboratory findings had been returned after a lengthy wait, and Salt Lake City police arrested Yohannes more than two and a half years after Samples’ death. The district attorney filed first-degree aggravated murder and attempted-murder charges in July 2021, moving the investigation formally into a prosecution.
An arrest did not mean an immediate trial. Prosecutors later cited continuing DNA work, competency evaluations and problems involving witness availability among the reasons the case took additional years to reach a jury. Those delays meant Samples’ family remained involved in the criminal process well beyond the initial investigation. Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill later credited them for their patience and said the biological evidence went through multiple levels of testing before prosecutors were prepared to present the case at trial.
The trial opened Aug. 4, 2026, and concluded Aug. 7. Jurors heard evidence about the cellphone dispute, the confrontation behind the store, the attack on Plante, the killing of Samples and the physical evidence gathered by police. They found Yohannes guilty of first-degree aggravated murder. In the count involving Plante, jurors made a finding of imperfect self-defense that led to a conviction for attempted manslaughter rather than the attempted-murder charge originally filed by prosecutors.
That distinction mattered when Yohannes returned to court for sentencing. Johnson ordered him to spend life in prison without the possibility of parole for Samples’ murder. She imposed a separate zero-to-five-year prison term for attempted manslaughter in Plante’s stabbing. The sentencing order made the aggravated-murder punishment permanent: Yohannes cannot seek release through parole on that conviction. He was 39 when sentenced, according to prosecutors and local news reports.
The hearing also shifted the focus from evidence and procedural delays to the people who had lived with the consequences of the crime. Samples’ loved ones described the experience of raising her and spoke about both the happiness she brought them and the struggles she faced. They prepared a video about her life that the court permitted to be shown. Their remarks placed Samples at the center of a proceeding that for years had largely been described through police evidence, laboratory testing and court schedules.
Plante also addressed the court. Local reporting said he discussed how his life had changed after he survived the stabbing and described efforts to help others through his work. His appearance underscored a part of the case separate from Samples’ death: another person had entered the enclosure in an effort to intervene and was seriously wounded. That attack ultimately produced the second conviction and additional prison sentence imposed alongside the aggravated-murder term.
Gill described the conclusion in limited terms rather than presenting the sentence as a way to undo what happened. After sentencing, he said prosecutors hoped Samples’ relatives had received some measure of justice, while noting that a complete form of justice would mean Samples was still alive. His comments followed similar remarks after the verdict, when he emphasized the family’s patience and the work required to test and retest the biological evidence before trial.
From the night of the killing to the final sentence, the case passed through several distinct stages: an immediate police investigation in 2018, delayed forensic results, charges filed in 2021, years of pretrial proceedings, an August 2026 trial and the September sentencing. The evidence collected at the beginning remained relevant at the end, particularly the DNA match prosecutors used to connect Yohannes to Samples after he had denied involvement.
Yohannes is now serving the life-without-parole sentence for aggravated murder along with the additional sentence for attempted manslaughter. Public reporting reviewed through Nov. 18 did not identify a later court action that altered Johnson’s sentence. The case that remained unresolved for years has therefore moved beyond trial and sentencing, leaving the convictions and prison terms as the controlling court outcome.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.