Vermont man accused of beating wife to death with flashlight during daughter’s sleepover

Lila Darjee Khadka’s death has renewed scrutiny of earlier cases involving her husband that prosecutors said were difficult to pursue.

BURLINGTON, Vt. — More than a month after Lila Darjee Khadka died from injuries suffered inside her Burlington home, newly reported details about earlier domestic-violence allegations are reshaping the public record surrounding the murder case against her husband. Bal Khadka, 44, has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder and three counts of cruelty to a child.

The newer history does not determine whether Bal Khadka committed the crime now charged. It does, however, show that police and prosecutors had encountered allegations involving the couple before the fatal Oct. 10 incident. A Nov. 18 Seven Days investigation reported that Lila Khadka had previously accused her husband of physical violence and threats and that former Burlington police officer Erin Bartle had worked on domestic-violence matters involving the family. Bartle told the publication she had remained worried about Lila after some earlier cases ended without the most serious allegations being prosecuted to a verdict.

That history illustrates one of the central difficulties prosecutors say they face in domestic-violence cases: the person who reports abuse may later decide not to participate in a criminal case. The reasons can be complicated and can include fear, housing, money, children and continuing emotional ties to a partner. Sarah George, the Chittenden County state’s attorney, has said prosecutors cannot always prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt without testimony from the person who experienced the alleged violence, especially when no other witness saw what happened.

Court records cited after Lila Khadka’s death show that Bal Khadka previously faced an aggravated domestic assault charge tied to a 2020 incident. George said that prosecution was dismissed after Lila Khadka indicated she did not want to testify and wanted the case dropped. George emphasized that the decision should not be treated as Lila’s fault. The prosecutor described the choice facing people in abusive relationships as one shaped by risks and pressures that outsiders may not see. Other reporting has described additional allegations over the years, including accusations that Bal Khadka had hurt, threatened or harassed his wife.

Bartle’s role adds another layer to that history. She later left full-time police work and, beginning in 2025, became a part-time domestic-violence investigator in George’s office. Her job is intended to strengthen cases by gathering evidence that may exist beyond a victim’s testimony. That can include recorded calls, medical information, additional witnesses or other corroboration overlooked during a short initial police response. Prosecutors say the approach can reduce the degree to which an entire case rests on whether a victim is willing or able to take the witness stand.

The case now pending against Bal Khadka presents a very different evidence picture from a private allegation with no other witness. Shortly before 6 a.m. Oct. 10, Burlington police received multiple 911 calls about a fight and the need for an ambulance at the family’s South Champlain Street apartment. Three children were inside: the Khadkas’ daughters, ages 10 and 3, and a 10-year-old friend who had stayed overnight. Court records say two children witnessed parts of the alleged assault, while one of the children recorded audio on a cellphone.

Police arriving outside the building found a distraught 10-year-old who said she and another child had escaped through a first-floor window. According to the charging affidavit, she reported that her father was hitting her mother and that police needed to help. Inside, officers found Lila Khadka unresponsive on a bed with serious head injuries. Authorities said Bal Khadka was elsewhere in the apartment with a young child. Investigators later reported finding a large flashlight that they allege was used in the attack.

The cellphone recording described in court papers is one of the most consequential pieces of evidence identified publicly so far. Investigators say it captures sounds from before and during the alleged assault as well as the arrival of emergency responders. The filing says a child can be heard saying what sounds like, “Dad no,” followed by screaming. Two children separately told police they saw Bal Khadka repeatedly strike Lila Khadka with a large flashlight, according to the court records.

Lila Khadka was taken to the University of Vermont Medical Center in critical condition. She died there the following evening, Oct. 11. Police had initially arrested her husband on an attempted second-degree murder charge. After her death, detectives submitted another probable-cause affidavit and the case was changed to second-degree murder. Bal Khadka later appeared in Chittenden Superior Court, where a public defender entered not guilty pleas for him to the murder charge and three child-cruelty counts.

The court ordered him held without bail. Prosecutors have said the children’s presence is important both because they are witnesses and because the state alleges they were exposed to serious violence in the home. George called the effect on the children an aggravating concern. The minors have not been publicly identified, and George said after the arraignment that the Khadka children were safe with family members.

The earlier cases remain relevant background, but they are not proof of the current murder allegation. Court records show Bal Khadka had prior convictions including violating an abuse-prevention order, violating conditions of release and drunken driving. A prior conviction can be part of a defendant’s history without establishing guilt on a later charge. Likewise, allegations that were dismissed or never proven in court must remain described as allegations rather than established acts.

Seven Days reported that Bartle was present in court when Bal Khadka pleaded not guilty and that she continued to think about her earlier work with Lila. Her comments focused less on claiming that one missed prosecution caused the death and more on the limits of what the criminal-justice system can accomplish when evidence is scarce and victims face competing pressures. George and victim advocates interviewed by the publication said building cases with evidence independent of a victim’s testimony is an important goal but cannot guarantee a person’s safety.

The present prosecution may offer far more independent evidence than some of the earlier cases. In addition to the children’s statements, investigators have cited 911 calls, a cellphone recording, the condition in which officers found Lila Khadka, medical treatment following the incident and a flashlight recovered from the home. The defense has not had a trial at which to challenge that evidence, question witnesses or present an alternative account. Bal Khadka retains the presumption of innocence.

The case therefore stands at the intersection of two separate questions. One is narrow and legal: whether prosecutors can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Bal Khadka committed second-degree murder and child cruelty. The other is broader: what earlier contacts with police and prosecutors reveal about the obstacles involved in responding to repeated reports of abuse. The second question provides context, but it cannot substitute for proof on the first.

Lila Khadka’s death has also left Burlington officials confronting a history that extends beyond the pending murder charge. The earlier allegations, dismissed cases and efforts to build stronger domestic-violence investigations now form part of the public discussion surrounding her death. Bal Khadka’s current charges remain unresolved, and the earlier accusations do not establish his guilt in the homicide case.

Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.