Prosecutors say Amy Hogan was killed inside the home she shared with her son, but they have not identified a motive.
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — Joseph Petrella has pleaded not guilty to allegations that he stabbed his mother to death inside their Penfield residence, leaving prosecutors to pursue a murder case in which they say some of the most basic questions about the confrontation — including why it happened — may never be answered.
Petrella, 39, faces second-degree murder, second-degree burglary and petit larceny charges stemming from an investigation that began Sept. 13. His mother, Amy Hogan, 60, was found dead in the residence on Ewald Drive. Prosecutors allege she was stabbed and cut several times during a confrontation sometime between the night of Sept. 12 and the next day. Petrella entered his not-guilty plea during an Oct. 7 appearance in Monroe County Court. He remained held without bail, and his next reported court date was set for Dec. 4.
Assistant District Attorney Ellie Laloudakis has publicly emphasized what investigators do not know. She said authorities may never have a complete account of how Hogan’s final hours unfolded, what led to the confrontation or what motive may have driven the alleged attack. That uncertainty does not prevent prosecutors from bringing charges, but it defines the boundaries of the public record. Officials have disclosed their theory about who killed Hogan and how she died, yet they have not supplied a verified explanation for why the confrontation began. Petrella’s attorney declined to comment after the October arraignment, leaving his not-guilty plea as his principal public response to the accusations.
The criminal case did not start with a call about Hogan. Monroe County sheriff’s deputies were dispatched to Ewald Drive at about 3 p.m. Sept. 13 because a nearby resident reported a burglary. A supporting deposition cited in local reporting said the resident’s vehicle had been ransacked and items were missing. After examining security video, the residents believed Petrella might have been responsible. Deputies began speaking with him as part of that separate investigation. The sheriff’s office said Petrella permitted them to enter his residence, a decision that placed a deputy inside the home where Hogan would soon be found.
Chief Deputy Michael Fowler said the deputy noticed conditions that appeared out of the ordinary and became concerned. Petrella was detained while deputies continued the investigation. What followed turned the burglary inquiry into a major-crimes investigation: deputies found Hogan dead inside the residence. They secured the scene and called in the sheriff’s Major Crimes Unit. Evidence technicians processed the home, investigators conducted a search under a warrant, and a crime victim’s advocate was sent to assist the family. The sheriff’s office later said evidence developed during the investigation identified Petrella as the suspect in his mother’s death.
The most specific allegations about Hogan’s death appear in a felony complaint described by local news organizations. The complaint alleges that Petrella stabbed and cut Hogan multiple times with a sharp object during a confrontation. Deputies found her body in a bathtub, wrapped in a plastic shower curtain. Frozen items had been placed around the body, according to the complaint, and the investigator who prepared it characterized their placement as an apparent effort at concealment. Those details are part of the prosecution’s account and have not been tested at trial. No public source reviewed for this report identifies a particular weapon recovered by investigators or explains what evidence prosecutors intend to use to establish the alleged confrontation.
The three charges reflect two interconnected but legally distinct parts of the investigation. The murder count concerns Hogan’s death. The burglary and petit larceny counts grew from the neighborhood investigation that initially brought deputies to Ewald Drive. The sheriff’s office announced all three charges after Petrella’s arrest and said he was arraigned in a local centralized arraignment court before being remanded to the Monroe County Jail without bail. By the time he appeared in Monroe County Court in October, the case had moved beyond the initial arrest stage, but the allegations remained unresolved. A plea of not guilty requires the prosecution to prove its case rather than treating the charging documents as established fact.
That distinction is especially important because some portions of the prosecution’s narrative are more developed than others. Authorities have described where Hogan was found and have alleged a violent confrontation, but they have not publicly established what the two were discussing, when the conflict began or why it escalated. Laloudakis said that uncertainty is not unusual in cases involving violence within families, where the people best positioned to explain the private events leading to a death may not be available or may dispute what happened. In this case, Hogan cannot give her account, and Petrella’s defense has not publicly offered a competing version of events.
The court proceedings have also brought Hogan’s family into public view. Laloudakis said after the October arraignment that Hogan had three daughters in addition to Petrella and that members of her family were devastated by the loss. Hogan’s mother attended the court proceeding, according to local reporting. The prosecutor described Hogan in terms relayed by relatives, emphasizing the effect her death had on the people closest to her. Those comments marked a shift from the factual language of the sheriff’s initial arrest announcement, which identified Hogan, listed the charges and summarized the investigative response without detailing much about her personal life.
Hogan’s obituary supplies that personal history. Born in Rochester in 1966, she was remembered as someone who constantly created things for her family and friends. Her interests included painting, crocheting, pottery, soap making, sewing, papier-mâché, gardening and cooking. The obituary says she frequently shared meals and treats, decorated for holidays and birthdays and kept numerous projects underway. It also describes a love of books and a garden filled with flowers, vegetables and small fairy doors. Those memories contrast with the narrow way homicide cases often reduce a person’s public identity to the circumstances of death.
Her family wrote most extensively about her role as a grandmother. Hogan had two grandchildren and, according to the obituary, filled their time together with food, art, games, nature, television and impromptu dance parties. The family said she cherished friendships as well, spending time at concerts, card games and gatherings. She was survived by her mother, two brothers, four children and her grandchildren. Funeral and burial arrangements took place in September, while the criminal case against her son was still in its earliest stages. The obituary did not attempt to explain the pending prosecution and instead focused on the relationships and interests through which relatives wanted Hogan remembered.
The sheriff’s office has said investigators acted quickly after finding Hogan, securing the residence and gathering evidence under the direction of its Major Crimes Unit. But the evidence itself has not been presented publicly in the manner it would be at a trial, where prosecutors would need to establish each element of the charges and the defense could challenge their proof. No conviction has occurred. Petrella’s plea means the central allegations — including that he intentionally caused his mother’s death — remain accusations despite the detail contained in the complaint and public statements from law enforcement.
No trial date had been announced as of Nov. 18, and the prosecution had not supplied a public motive for Hogan’s death. The case therefore moves forward with a detailed allegation about what happened inside the Ewald Drive residence but no complete explanation of why. Petrella’s next reported court appearance was set for Dec. 4.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.