8-year-old New York girl burns alive searching for mom during house fire set by her mom’s ex

A forgotten 2005 report helped derail New York’s prosecution of Timothy Kuhn before federal authorities brought a separate arson charge.

ROCHESTER, N.Y. — Timothy Kuhn was days away from facing a jury over a fatal 2004 house fire when an old piece of the investigation resurfaced: a former jail cellmate said he had given Rochester police potentially important information about Kuhn roughly 20 years earlier, a disclosure that ultimately helped bring the state case to an abrupt end.

That dismissal could have been the final courtroom chapter in the death of 8-year-old Savannah Streber. Instead, federal prosecutors have now charged Kuhn, 66, of Pensacola, Florida, with arson of property used in interstate commerce resulting in death. A federal grand jury alleges that Kuhn maliciously set fire to the rental property at 17 Yates St. on Feb. 28, 2004, causing a death. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York announced the one-count indictment Oct. 19. The offense carries a maximum punishment of life in prison. Kuhn has not been convicted of the federal charge and is presumed innocent.

The path from the state dismissal to the federal indictment highlights an unusual feature of the long-running case: the decisive event in 2025 was not a jury’s assessment of testimony about the fire, but a constitutional ruling tied to how the original investigation had been documented. The state charges against Kuhn were dismissed Oct. 7, 2025, as jury selection was expected to begin. Monroe County District Attorney Brian Green said a newly disclosed fact triggered Kuhn’s speedy-trial rights under the U.S. Constitution. State Supreme Court Justice Stephen Miller dismissed the indictment, ending charges of second-degree murder and first-degree arson before jurors could decide them.

The information that changed the case concerned a former cellmate of Kuhn. According to WXXI’s account of the court proceedings, the man testified that he told Rochester police in 2005 that Kuhn had confessed to killing Savannah. Police Capt. Greg Bello later said the information was “insufficiently documented or acted upon.” That failure mattered because a criminal defendant’s right to a timely prosecution can turn partly on when authorities had evidence and what they did with it. The revelation shifted the legal history of the case backward by years, undermining the prosecution’s ability to proceed on the timetable that had led to Kuhn’s later indictment.

Green said after the dismissal that prosecutors were required to honor constitutional protections even though the outcome was painful for Savannah’s relatives. He also made clear that the judge’s action was not a ruling that the prosecution’s evidence was insufficient to support its accusations. The distinction is important: Kuhn was not acquitted by a jury after a trial, and the state case did not end with a factual finding that he did or did not set the fire. Instead, the indictment was dismissed on a legal issue arising from the passage of time and the handling of investigative information.

Rochester police responded to the episode by pointing to changes made since the early years of the investigation. The department said it had adopted new record-keeping technologies and adjusted procedures intended to ensure that investigative material is submitted electronically and remains trackable. Police also said cold-case work would continue. The department’s explanation placed the failure in the context of older investigative practices, but it could not restore the state prosecution. For Savannah’s family, the result came after they had already waited nearly two decades for an arrest and then watched the case move close to a trial.

The underlying investigation began with a fire just after midnight at the Yates Street home where Savannah lived. Her mother, Lisa Routier, was working. Savannah was inside with her younger sister, a babysitter and the babysitter’s son. Investigators later said the blaze began on the back porch and was deliberately set. The babysitter’s son detected the fire, prompting the people inside to escape. The babysitter realized after getting outside that Savannah was missing and tried to re-enter the home, but officials said conditions had become too dangerous. Firefighters later found Savannah in her mother’s bedroom. Police said they believed she had gone there looking for her mother.

Authorities focused on Kuhn early in the investigation. Police said he had previously been romantically involved with Routier and that a no-contact order of protection was in effect. Investigators later said they believed Routier was the intended target of the alleged arson. But suspicion did not immediately lead to a criminal case. Police said they lacked enough evidence at the time to make an arrest, and the investigation remained unresolved for years. The allegations against Kuhn, including assertions about his purpose in allegedly setting the fire, have never been established by a trial verdict.

Investigators eventually returned to the cold case, and new information helped produce an arrest in late 2023. Kuhn was taken into custody in Florida and returned to Rochester, where he was arraigned in January 2024. He pleaded not guilty to the state charges. At the time, Rochester Police Chief David Smith told Savannah’s family that the arrest could not bring her back but expressed hope that seeing someone face a court would offer some solace. Savannah’s older sister, Kelly Streber, said the family had continued fighting for the case and had never forgotten her. Those statements came during a period when the long-dormant investigation seemed finally headed toward trial.

The discovery of the 2005 information changed that trajectory. A speedy-trial protection is not merely an administrative deadline; it is a constitutional safeguard intended to prevent the government from leaving a person under unresolved criminal accusation for an excessive period. The specific application of those protections depends on the law and facts of a case. In Kuhn’s prosecution, state authorities acknowledged that the old disclosure altered the analysis enough for Miller to dismiss the indictment. That made the police department’s handling of a decades-old report one of the most consequential developments in the entire state case.

The federal government’s entry creates a legally separate prosecution. The new indictment does not simply restore the dismissed New York charges. Instead, it invokes a federal arson statute covering property used in interstate commerce and alleges that the offense resulted in death. Federal prosecutors identify the Yates Street home as a rental property, a characteristic relevant to the jurisdictional basis of the charge. The government must prove the elements of that federal offense beyond a reasonable doubt. The Justice Department has not publicly established through a conviction that Kuhn set the fire, and the indictment remains an accusation.

Kuhn was arraigned on the federal charge Oct. 19 in the Northern District of Florida and ordered detained, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Prosecutors said he would be returned to the Western District of New York. The investigation supporting the federal case involved Rochester police and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, and Assistant U.S. Attorney Melissa M. Marangola is prosecuting it. The Western District of New York’s public calendar now lists Kuhn’s case for a status conference at 2 p.m. Nov. 23 before Magistrate Judge Mark W. Pedersen in Rochester.

The latest moves in the federal case do not undo the record-keeping failure or the constitutional ruling that ended the state prosecution. It places a different criminal accusation before a different court more than 22 years after Savannah’s death. What evidence will ultimately be admitted, what challenges Kuhn’s defense may raise and whether the case will reach a trial remain unresolved. For now, the case stands at a point few expected after the 2025 dismissal: Kuhn is again a defendant in a prosecution tied to the Yates Street fire, while the allegation at its center remains unproven.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.