Michael Freund’s trial centered on whether a porch confrontation justified deadly force or amounted to the first-degree murder of Dexter Perkins.
WHEATON, Ill. — For three days, jurors heard two sharply different explanations for why Michael Freund opened fire on Dexter Perkins outside a suburban Chicago bar: Freund said he acted in self-defense, while prosecutors said his own decisions turned an ordinary disagreement into murder.
A DuPage County jury resolved that dispute Oct. 9 by finding Freund guilty of first-degree murder after less than an hour of deliberations. Perkins, 37, was killed Dec. 22, 2023, outside Rosie O’Reilly’s in unincorporated Wheaton after an encounter involving drinks, pizza and an argument over the bill. The unusual origin of the disagreement drew attention to the case, but the central issue at trial was not who was entitled to the leftover food. Jurors instead had to decide whether the circumstances legally justified Freund’s use of deadly force.
Defense attorney Dave Carlson argued that they did. He acknowledged the killing as a tragedy but challenged the prosecution’s description of the events outside the bar. The defense maintained that the physical confrontation involving Perkins and one of Freund’s co-workers posed a serious threat and that Freund responded to what he believed was unfolding in front of him. Carlson also disputed that Freund possessed the intent required to support the state’s first-degree murder theory.
The defense’s approach placed heavy emphasis on the final moments before the shooting. Prosecutors asked the jury to look further back. They argued that Freund’s conduct before the gunfire was essential to understanding whether the shooting was truly an unavoidable act of protection. The state highlighted one decision in particular: Freund left the dispute, walked to his pickup truck, obtained a handgun and returned to the bar with it before the confrontation outside reached its fatal conclusion.
The encounter began at about 7:20 a.m. when Freund and two co-workers arrived at Rosie O’Reilly’s after completing a work shift. Perkins was already inside. Authorities said the men did not know one another before that morning. They began talking and drinking together rather than remaining separate. Trial reporting described surveillance video showing the group at the bar, and prosecutors said Perkins bought a round of shots for the three men. They also shared pizza.
A second pizza changed the tone of the encounter. Prosecutors said Perkins gave Freund and one co-worker a slice each and kept the rest. The remaining pizza was apparently intended to leave with Perkins. That led to disagreement over the food and who would pay for it. Evidence described at trial indicated the bartender offered to remove the pizza from Freund’s bill. Even with that potential resolution available, the tension continued.
Freund then went to his truck and obtained a 9 mm Glock handgun, according to prosecutors. Trial reporting said the state also presented evidence that he offered a second firearm to a co-worker, who declined it. The prosecution treated those actions as important because they occurred before the final physical encounter on the porch. Rather than portraying the shooting as arising without warning, prosecutors presented jurors with a timeline in which Freund had already armed himself while the dispute was continuing.
Outside the bar, Perkins and one of Freund’s co-workers came into physical contact. Prosecutors described it as a brief scuffle. Cellphone video introduced or discussed during the trial reportedly showed the two men in close contact, including moments characterized by the state as resembling a bear hug or dancing. Carlson objected to the prosecution’s benign description. The defense argued the confrontation looked more serious and that Freund reasonably perceived danger to the other man.
The distinction mattered because Illinois law did not allow jurors to decide the case simply by determining whether a confrontation occurred. They had to evaluate the evidence under the legal instructions given by the court and decide whether Freund’s use of deadly force met the requirements for lawful self-defense. The prosecution argued that it did not, particularly in light of Perkins being unarmed and Freund’s actions before the shooting.
Prosecutors said Freund first drew the handgun and fired two shots into the air. The confrontation between Perkins and the other man continued. Evidence described during the trial indicated that Perkins went to the ground and later stood. When he moved toward the other man again, Freund fired at him from the opposite side of a wooden railing, according to the state. Perkins was struck multiple times and died at the scene.
The state argued those facts showed force far beyond what was legally justified. Assistant State’s Attorney Lee Roupas urged jurors to reject the self-defense theory and presented Freund’s actions as murder. The defense countered that the prosecution was minimizing the danger Freund believed his co-worker faced. Jurors therefore had competing interpretations not only of the shooting itself but also of the same video evidence and physical interactions immediately preceding it.
What occurred after the gunfire added another part to the prosecution’s chronology but did not replace the central self-defense dispute. Authorities said Freund took the Glock back to his pickup truck and left it in the center console. DuPage County sheriff’s deputies arrived at about 8:40 a.m. after a report of shots fired and found Perkins dead. Freund remained at the bar and was arrested without incident. Investigators later recovered the handgun from the truck.
The following day, prosecutors charged Freund with first-degree murder and persuaded a judge to keep him in custody while the case was pending. At that point, all accusations against Freund remained unproven. The court process continued for nearly three years before the competing versions of events were presented to a jury. The October 2026 verdict marked the point at which prosecutors met their burden of proving the murder charge beyond a reasonable doubt.
The jury’s speed did not determine the strength of the verdict, but it provided a striking conclusion to the three-day proceeding. Jurors deliberated for less than an hour before finding Freund guilty. By doing so, they rejected the claim that the fatal shooting was lawful self-defense. The verdict also showed that the defense’s narrower focus on the final confrontation did not overcome the broader chronology prosecutors presented.
After the conviction, DuPage County State’s Attorney Bob Berlin emphasized the loss suffered by Perkins’ relatives rather than the unusual food dispute that had preceded the killing. Perkins was the father of two daughters. Berlin said the verdict could not restore him to his family but expressed hope that the conviction would bring some measure of accountability and comfort.
The trial demonstrated why descriptions of the case as a killing simply “over pizza” capture only part of what jurors considered. The disagreement over the food may have helped start the conflict, but the legal case turned on the actions that followed: Freund’s trip to his vehicle, his return with a firearm, the physical encounter outside, the shots into the air and the later fatal gunfire. Each stage gave the prosecution and defense different facts to emphasize when explaining whether the final use of force was justified.
What the jury settled was the central dispute that had defined the trial: Freund’s claim that the shooting was justified did not persuade the panel. His first-degree murder conviction therefore stands as the court’s confirmed determination of guilt, while the available reporting does not establish what sentence, if any, was imposed after the post-trial hearing scheduled for Nov. 9.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.