Ex-boyfriend breaks into Minnesota woman’s home and kills her and her new man

One of Randy Zimmerman’s first-degree murder convictions was built on a documented pattern of abuse involving former partner Tabitha Trescott.

NEW ULM, Minn. — The double-murder case that ended with two consecutive life sentences for Randy Thomas Zimmerman was not prosecuted only as a deadly break-in. For the killing of his former girlfriend, Tabitha Trescott, prosecutors used a first-degree murder law that specifically addressed a past pattern of domestic abuse.

That legal path placed the history between Zimmerman and Trescott at the center of the case. Court records cited by KEYC show that Zimmerman had misdemeanor domestic assault convictions involving Trescott in December 2023 and December 2024. The station also reported that he faced felony stalking charges tied to a July 2025 incident in which Trescott was the alleged victim. When Zimmerman pleaded guilty in August 2026, he admitted intentionally killing Trescott and accepted a first-degree murder conviction based on a past pattern of domestic abuse. The second life sentence came from a different theory: first-degree murder committed while burglarizing the home of Justin Reinarts, Trescott’s partner.

The two legal theories mattered because they allowed the prosecution to account separately for the circumstances surrounding each victim. According to the plea documents, Zimmerman admitted entering Reinarts’ home without consent while armed with a dangerous weapon and intentionally killing him. For Trescott’s death, the plea focused on the prior romantic relationship and the documented abuse history. Both counts carried mandatory life sentences with the possibility of later release under state law. The judge still had an important choice at sentencing: whether the terms would run concurrently, allowing them to overlap, or consecutively, requiring one sentence to follow the other.

Trescott’s relatives made clear before the Oct. 5 sentencing that the structure of the punishment mattered to them. Her mother, Terri Smith, told KEYC after the guilty plea that she was relieved her grandson might be spared from testifying, but she objected to the plea agreement because it left open the possibility of eventual release. She said the family wanted the sentences imposed consecutively. The court ultimately did that. Zimmerman, 46, was ordered to serve two consecutive life terms, with credit for 345 days already spent in custody. The sentence moved the case from a pending prosecution into its punishment phase without a jury trial.

The killings took place in the early hours of Nov. 2, 2025, in Hanska, a small Brown County city about 30 miles west of Mankato. Authorities said Trescott’s 13-year-old son awoke to an argument inside the home. The criminal complaint said he heard Zimmerman yelling and then heard a gunshot. When the boy opened his door, he encountered Zimmerman in the hallway with a long gun, according to investigators. The complaint said Zimmerman pointed the weapon toward the child, told him to return to his room and later left the house. The boy called 911, reporting that his mother’s former boyfriend had broken in and shot her.

Deputies responding to the home found Trescott, 32, and Reinarts, 50, dead. Investigators recovered spent shotgun shells from the upstairs area where the two were killed. Early charging documents described the deaths in graphic medical terms, but the essential fact established later by the guilty pleas was more direct: Zimmerman intentionally killed both people after entering the residence. The plea eliminated any dispute over his responsibility for the two deaths, while leaving prosecutors to dismiss other counts that had accumulated as the case moved from the initial complaint to a grand jury indictment.

That indictment had significantly increased Zimmerman’s legal exposure. He was first charged with second-degree murder after his arrest. On Nov. 26, 2025, KEYC reported that a Brown County grand jury had returned nine felony counts, including first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree felony murder, first-degree murder involving a pattern of domestic abuse, second-degree intentional murder, first-degree burglary and second-degree assault. The premeditated counts carried the possibility of life imprisonment without release. Under the eventual plea agreement, prosecutors agreed to seek dismissal of the remaining charges while Zimmerman pleaded guilty to two first-degree counts that still required life sentences.

The case also extended beyond Minnesota on the day of the killings. After leaving Hanska, Zimmerman traveled into Iowa. Authorities there said law enforcement officers tried to stop his vehicle and that he accelerated away, at times reaching very high speeds. During the pursuit, officials said Zimmerman fired a shotgun backward from the vehicle toward a deputy. The deputy was not struck. Officers from multiple Iowa agencies joined the chase, which ended after law enforcement forced Zimmerman’s vehicle into a ditch and pursued him on foot. He was arrested in Louisa County roughly 12 hours after the 911 call from Hanska.

Those events formed part of the broader account of the manhunt, but the Brown County murder case ultimately turned on the conduct to which Zimmerman admitted in court. Prosecutors did not need to prove the complaint’s every allegation once the plea was accepted. That distinction is important in a case with multiple documents created at different stages: allegations in a complaint describe what prosecutors say evidence will show, while a guilty plea establishes the factual basis for a conviction. Here, Zimmerman’s admissions covered the unlawful armed entry, the intentional killing of Reinarts and the intentional killing of Trescott in the context of a qualifying domestic-abuse history.

The domestic-violence dimension also shaped how Trescott’s family spoke about the case after the sentence. Smith said she hoped her daughter would be remembered for her warmth and compassion rather than only for the circumstances of her death. She also used public interviews to urge attention to abusive relationships and the danger that can persist after a breakup. Violence Free Minnesota, a statewide coalition, later included Trescott among its confirmed victims of intimate partner homicide for 2025. The group’s memorial said she left behind two young sons and described her as a charismatic person with a great deal of energy.

Reinarts’ family emphasized a different part of the loss. Local reports described him as a volunteer firefighter and a longtime resident of Brown County. Jody Rhoades, the mother of his two children, told KEYC after sentencing that the family planned to lean on the Hanska and New Ulm communities as they healed. Relatives described Reinarts as generous and devoted to his family and fire service. That community role made the case especially visible in a town of only a few hundred people, where the killings, the search for Zimmerman and the later court proceedings were felt far beyond the immediate families.

Minnesota’s sentencing framework explains why the difference between concurrent and consecutive life terms became the principal unresolved issue after the plea. State law requires life imprisonment for first-degree murder and allows supervised release consideration after a minimum term for certain categories of life sentences. It does not make release automatic. A separate state board process governs whether an eligible person is actually released. By ordering Zimmerman’s two life terms to run consecutively, the Brown County court chose the harsher of the two structures available under the plea, while stopping short of the life-without-release punishment that could have followed a conviction on certain dismissed premeditated counts.

Zimmerman was sentenced Oct. 5, 2026, and KEYC reported that his life terms would be served in the Minnesota correctional system. The court also allowed a 30-day period to complete restitution for the victims’ families. No final restitution figure was found in the later public reports reviewed for this account. What is settled is the central judgment: Zimmerman is serving consecutive life sentences for two first-degree murder convictions, one rooted in burglary and the other in a past pattern of domestic abuse. That second conviction ensures the years preceding Trescott’s death are part of the formal legal record, not merely an afterthought to the violence that ended her life.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.