Donna Stone remains convicted in her granddaughter’s death, but jurors rejected a sentence that would permanently bar her from seeking parole.
MADISON, W.Va. — The West Virginia jurors who convicted Donna Stone in the starvation death of her 14-year-old granddaughter made a second decision one day later: The 79-year-old grandmother should have the possibility of parole rather than spend the rest of her life permanently barred from seeking release.
The mercy recommendation followed Stone’s convictions for murder by a parent, guardian or custodian by refusal or failure to provide necessities and child neglect resulting in death. Under the jury’s decision, Stone faces 15 years to life on the murder count and can eventually be considered for parole. She is also subject to punishment on the neglect conviction. The mercy finding did not reduce the jury’s determination that Stone was criminally responsible in Kyneddi Miller’s April 17, 2024, death. It instead narrowed the sentencing question that Boone County Circuit Judge Stacy Nowicki-Eldridge will address when Stone returns to court Dec. 8.
Stone testified during the mercy phase, putting her own explanation before jurors after not taking the stand during the main guilt phase. Prosecutor Dan Holstein questioned her about what she did when Kyneddi’s condition became visibly serious. Stone said she had believed the girl’s mother, Julie Miller, was responsible for deciding whether Kyneddi should receive treatment and said she was uncertain what authority she had to take her granddaughter for care on her own. Asked whether she could have called 911 when the teenager was in obvious distress, Stone acknowledged that she could have and that she should have done so. The exchange shifted the hearing away from whether a crime occurred and toward how jurors believed Stone should be punished for it.
The mercy decision came after a five-day trial in which prosecutors portrayed Stone not as a distant relative but as a caregiver who lived with Kyneddi and had a duty to act. The state argued that the teenager’s physical decline was prolonged, severe and visible. An autopsy determined that Kyneddi died of severe malnutrition, and prosecutors said her deterioration had developed over months or longer rather than suddenly. Authorities said she weighed about 58 pounds when she died. The state maintained that the seriousness of her condition was such that any adult regularly caring for her should have recognized the need for medical intervention.
Stone’s defense was built around a narrower view of responsibility. Attorney Tim Gibson told jurors that a tragic death did not automatically make every adult in the household guilty of a crime. He argued that Miller, Kyneddi’s mother, controlled the major decisions about her daughter’s medical care and education. Gibson also focused jurors on the mental-state requirements of the charges and challenged the prosecution’s contention that Stone’s failure to act amounted to murder. In closing arguments, he pointed to Stone’s eventual 911 call as evidence that she wanted emergency workers to try to save Kyneddi, while prosecutors argued that seeking help only at the end did not erase earlier failures.
The distinction mattered because Miller had already admitted criminal responsibility before Stone went to trial. Miller pleaded guilty in November 2025 to death of a child by a parent, guardian or custodian. Judge Nowicki-Eldridge sentenced her in February to 15 years to life, the maximum term available on that conviction, with lengthy supervision required if she is ever paroled. During Stone’s trial, Miller testified for the defense and described herself as the person making most decisions concerning Kyneddi. She said she considered taking her daughter to a hospital in the days before the death but did not do so after believing Kyneddi had improved.
Miller’s account of those final days provided some of the trial’s most important evidence about what people inside the home knew. She testified that Kyneddi had fallen several days before her death and that, when she helped her, she noticed how light the teenager had become. Miller said she could feel a protruding bone through her daughter’s robe and recognized that Kyneddi needed help. She nevertheless decided against immediately going to the hospital after Kyneddi resisted and later appeared to eat and drink. Miller testified that she planned to take her daughter for care after she slept, but Kyneddi never woke. Prosecutors argued that those circumstances supported their claim that the emergency was apparent before the 911 call.
The jury also heard evidence about how isolated Kyneddi had become years before her death. Investigators said the girl had rarely left the Morrisvale property during a period of roughly four years. Family witnesses said they had not seen her in person since around 2020 and were repeatedly told she feared COVID-19 or did not want to interact with others. Kyneddi had left public school and was being homeschooled. The isolation meant that teachers, relatives and other adults who might otherwise have regularly seen her had fewer opportunities to observe changes in her health. The circumstances became important not only to the criminal case but also to later questions about whether outside intervention had been possible.
One such opportunity came in March 2023, when former state trooper Charles Sutphin conducted a welfare check after a relative expressed concern about not seeing Kyneddi for years. Sutphin testified that he entered the darkened room where the teenager was staying and required her to get out of bed so he could see her. At that time, he said, she did not appear physically malnourished. He was concerned, however, by what he described as her continuing fixation on COVID-19. Sutphin said he went afterward to a local Child Protective Services office to discuss those concerns. A state child welfare employee testified that the visit was not entered as a formal abuse or neglect referral because such referrals were required to go through a hotline.
Evidence about the family’s attempts to contact Kyneddi added another layer to the question of what Stone knew. Terry Miller, Kyneddi’s father, testified that his access to his daughter sharply diminished after 2020. He said that toward the end of Kyneddi’s life, most communication with the household went through Stone. According to his testimony, she reassured him that Kyneddi was healthy but did not want to see people. He also described unsuccessful efforts to arrange a psychological evaluation and said he had contacted child protective authorities. Defense questioning established that he did not file court papers seeking a custody change, illustrating how several people had concerns but no intervention restored routine contact with the teenager.
After weighing that evidence, the jury convicted Stone on Oct. 19. The panel’s decision made her the second member of the household to be held criminally responsible for Kyneddi’s death. Stone’s husband, Jerry Stone, was also charged but was found incompetent to stand trial in 2025 and committed to a mental hospital. That left Donna Stone’s trial as the proceeding in which jurors directly examined whether a grandparent who helped provide care could be guilty even when the child’s mother remained the primary parent and had already accepted responsibility.
The following day’s mercy hearing asked a substantially different question. Prosecutors did not have to prove the crimes again, and the defense could not undo the verdict. Jurors instead considered whether Stone should retain any chance of release. Her attorney cited her age and serious health diagnosis, and Holstein told reporters afterward that justice can include mercy even when a conviction is warranted. With the recommendation, Stone would first become eligible for parole after 15 years, when she would be in her 90s. Parole eligibility does not guarantee release; it allows consideration under the state’s parole process.
For Stone, the practical effect of the jury’s mercy decision will not be known for years. She must first be sentenced Dec. 8 and then serve the period required before she can seek parole consideration. The recommendation gives her a future opportunity to ask for release; it does not promise one, leaving the immediate consequence of the verdict a lengthy prison term.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.