Maryland woman sends gunman after grandmother following youth basketball blowup

Anntoinette Jennings’ relatives filled the courtroom as Cassandra McRae was punished for a shooting that also wounded two passengers.

BALTIMORE, Md. — More than a year after Anntoinette Jennings’ relatives began coming to court seeking answers for the grandmother killed after a children’s basketball game, they watched a judge impose a sentence that will likely keep Cassandra McRae in prison for the rest of her life.

McRae, 38, was ordered to serve 140 years for the January 2025 shooting that killed Jennings and wounded two other people, including an 11-year-old child. The formal sentence totaled 150 years, with 10 years suspended, according to local reports and the Baltimore City State’s Attorney’s Office. The first 25 years must be served without the possibility of parole. The punishment followed McRae’s convictions for second-degree murder, four counts of conspiracy to commit murder, four counts of attempted second-degree murder, five firearm offenses and reckless endangerment. For Jennings’ family, the sentencing marked the most consequential court proceeding since jurors held McRae responsible for the attack.

Jennings, 52, was more than the victim at the center of a lengthy criminal case. Baltimore news organizations identified her as a grandmother and a pre-K paraeducator at Waverly Elementary/Middle School. Her relatives repeatedly attended proceedings as the case moved from indictment to trial and then sentencing. During the trial period, siblings Debbie and Eric White spoke publicly about how much they missed her and about the difficulty of waiting for the case to be resolved. At sentencing, family members again described the absence left by her death, turning a hearing dominated by prison terms and criminal counts back toward the person whose killing brought everyone into the courtroom.

Jennings’ husband, Gabriel Jennings, told the court he still saw his wife in his dreams, according to courtroom reporting. Her sister Deborah White told the judge that Jennings’ life had mattered. Relatives packed the courtroom, with some seated in the jury box because of the turnout. Their presence underscored the distance between the brief dispute that prosecutors said began the chain of events and the consequences that followed: one woman dead, two other people wounded, children exposed to gunfire and a family returning to court for more than a year while prosecutors tried to prove who was responsible.

The dispute began on Jan. 22, 2025, at a children’s basketball game involving Jennings’ family. Prosecutors characterized what happened there as an altercation. Surveillance evidence later obtained by investigators showed McRae leaving the game while making a phone call and getting into a gray sedan, according to the state. The sedan then followed Jennings’ Honda CR-V. That movement away from the game became an important part of the prosecution because it connected an argument in a public setting with the encounter that unfolded later on York Road.

Jennings was driving four other people when the vehicles reached the 5400 block of York Road. Video evidence cited by prosecutors showed McRae getting out of the sedan and going toward the rear passenger side of the SUV. Two men approached from the driver’s side. According to a police charging document, McRae touched the vehicle and said, “There they go right there, there they go right there.” Seconds later, one of the men fired into the SUV. McRae and the two men then fled, investigators said. Police responding to the scene found Jennings fatally wounded inside the vehicle.

Two of Jennings’ passengers had also been shot. One was an 11-year-old child. Early police reporting said the second wounded passenger was an adult and that both survivors were taken for medical treatment. A 6-year-old child and another person in the SUV were not physically struck. Those facts became central to the prosecution’s portrayal of the attack at sentencing. The state argued that the gunfire had put an entire group at risk, not only Jennings, and the jury’s verdict reflected that broader exposure through four attempted-murder convictions and multiple firearm counts in addition to the murder conviction.

The investigation did not lead to the same outcome for everyone accused. McRae and Tavon Singleton were indicted together in March 2025 on first-degree murder and numerous related charges. Prosecutors initially said both could face life without parole plus additional prison time if convicted as charged. At trial, however, jurors acquitted Singleton of all charges while convicting McRae on a series of lesser and related offenses. McRae was not convicted of first-degree murder. She instead was found guilty of second-degree murder and the other offenses that ultimately produced the extraordinary aggregate sentence.

That split verdict remained a major issue when McRae stood before Baltimore Circuit Judge Dana Middleton for sentencing. McRae continued to deny responsibility and said she had been wrongfully convicted. Her attorney, Michael Tomko, asked that the punishment be capped at 25 years. He pointed to McRae’s lack of a prior criminal record and argued that she should not effectively spend the rest of her life behind bars simply because she was the defendant the jury convicted. The defense also emphasized that McRae was not the person accused of physically firing the shots into the SUV.

Prosecutors saw her role very differently. Assistant State’s Attorney Megan Gallo argued that McRae had orchestrated the chain of events and sought a maximum sentence totaling 295 years, according to courtroom reporting. The state’s theory focused on what McRae did between the basketball-game dispute and the gunfire: making the phone call, traveling in the vehicle that followed Jennings, approaching the SUV and identifying it just before the shots. The prosecution argued that those acts made her responsible for the violence even without evidence that she had pulled the trigger herself.

Middleton sided with the state on the central question of culpability, describing McRae as the catalyst for what happened. The judge also noted that jurors had listened to McRae testify in her own defense and had not accepted her version of events. The resulting sentence was less than the maximum prosecutors requested but far beyond the defense recommendation. Although some accounts described the punishment as 150 years while others called it a 140-year sentence, the figures refer to different parts of the same judgment: the court imposed 150 years and suspended 10, leaving 140 years to be served.

Baltimore City State’s Attorney Ivan J. Bates later said the punishment reflected the devastating consequences of the case. He cited the death of a grandmother, the injuries to two passengers and the presence of children as evidence of what he called a disregard for human life and the safety of innocent children. Bates’ office had highlighted the age of the victims from the beginning, including the 11-year-old wounded in the attack. The prosecution’s public statements treated the case not simply as a single homicide but as violence that endangered every person inside Jennings’ SUV.

The criminal case also changed significantly between indictment and sentencing. The initial charges accused McRae of first-degree murder and attempted first-degree murder, among other crimes. The jury’s verdict narrowed that case, rejecting some of the most severe allegations while still finding her criminally responsible for Jennings’ death and the danger to the other occupants. That distinction matters because sentencing followed the offenses actually proved to the jury, rather than the entire list prosecutors had filed at the outset. Middleton then stacked the penalties for those convictions into a term measured in well over a century.

For Jennings’ relatives, the sentence cannot reverse what happened on York Road. It does, however, close a major stage of a prosecution that began with police arriving at an SUV containing a dead grandmother, wounded passengers and children. McRae remains convicted and faces 140 years to serve, including 25 years without parole eligibility. Singleton’s acquittal remains in place. Any challenge McRae makes to the verdict or punishment would now move through the post-trial and appellate system, while Jennings’ family leaves the trial court with the judgment it had waited to hear.

Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.