Investigators pieced together Kashan Crawford-Chatman’s final day from digital evidence, medical findings and conflicting accounts of his sudden collapse.
COLUMBUS, Ohio — The murder case against an Ohio home daycare operator was built without video showing the fatal act itself, instead drawing on deleted text messages, recovered home footage, medical evidence and a timeline showing a healthy-appearing infant deteriorating while in her care.
That evidence ultimately led a Franklin County jury to convict Tammra R. Straughter, 54, of murder and child endangerment in the death of 5-month-old Kashan Roman Crawford-Chatman. Judge Bill Sperlazza sentenced Straughter on Oct. 7 to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 15 years. The sentencing resolved the trial-court phase of a case investigators began assembling after an Oct. 9, 2023, emergency call from Straughter’s Reynoldsburg home, where prosecutors said she was caring for Kashan, his twin brother and six other children by herself.
Investigators first had to determine what happened during a period in which Kashan went from appearing well to struggling to breathe. Straughter told police that the infant arrived at her home smiling and without visible injuries. According to an affidavit reported by local news outlets, she said Kashan later became fussy and wanted to be held. Straughter said she eventually placed him on his back while she attended to another child. When she returned, she said, he had spit up and appeared to be aspirating. She described using a nasal aspirator and a bib, giving back pats and rescue breaths and calling 911.
The medical crisis did not end when paramedics arrived. Reports based on the affidavit said first responders found Kashan breathing and appearing to be in normal condition after the initial emergency. He was released to his mother, Stacia Crawford, who took him to an urgent care center for further evaluation. There, Kashan’s condition rapidly worsened. He went limp, and an ambulance transporting him for hospital care diverted to Mount Carmel East after he went into cardiac arrest and required extensive resuscitation. He was later transferred to Nationwide Children’s Hospital, where the focus shifted from a possible choking event to signs of serious trauma.
Doctors identified severe head injuries and other signs that prompted hospital staff to report suspected physical abuse. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office later classified Kashan’s death as a homicide and attributed it to a closed head injury consistent with shaken baby syndrome. He died Oct. 13, 2023, four days after the emergency at the daycare. At a court hearing the following year, prosecuting attorney Scott Sugarman said a deputy coroner regarded the swelling in Kashan’s brain as unusually severe and believed the findings strongly pointed toward abusive head trauma caused by violent shaking.
Detectives then compared the medical findings with the account Straughter had given them. One important source was video recorded inside the home. A prosecutor said at Straughter’s 2024 arraignment that she had denied having camera footage, but a search of the home uncovered video showing Kashan during the day. The footage reportedly showed him appearing fine earlier on Oct. 9 and documented the broader period before his condition changed. Later reporting about the criminal trial said the cameras did not capture the act that prosecutors said caused the fatal injuries. That made the footage important primarily as a timeline rather than as a direct recording of the abuse.
Investigators also examined Straughter’s mobile phone with her permission. The detective found deleted text messages in which Straughter expressed frustration about the twins being fussy, according to an affidavit. The messages took on added significance because Straughter had described Kashan as increasingly fussy during her police interview. Prosecutors did not need the texts to contain a direct confession for them to become part of the case. Instead, they were one piece of evidence that jurors could consider alongside her account, the recovered video, the timing of the child’s collapse and the medical testimony about how his injuries occurred.
The investigation continued beyond the first police interviews. Hospital personnel notified Franklin County Children Services after Kashan’s injuries raised concerns about physical abuse. A wrongful-death lawsuit filed by Crawford later said the agency substantiated allegations of physical abuse involving Straughter and found allegations involving Crawford and Kashan’s father, Jontue Chatman, to be unsubstantiated. That administrative determination was not a criminal verdict, but it became part of the documented history surrounding the case. Police and prosecutors separately developed the evidence that was eventually presented in Franklin County Common Pleas Court.
A grand jury indicted Straughter in February 2024. The indictment accused her of murder and endangering children, and she was arrested that month. At her arraignment, Kashan’s parents appeared with supporters as prosecutors outlined the early evidence in public court. Sugarman told the court that the infant had been in Straughter’s care when his condition changed and described the medical conclusion that he had suffered severe abusive head trauma. The prosecution’s theory was that Straughter violently shook the baby. Straughter’s earlier account focused instead on the possibility that Kashan had spit up and choked while she was occupied with another child.
By the time the case reached trial in August 2026, jurors were asked to evaluate a body of circumstantial and medical evidence rather than a recording of the fatal act. Reporting during the case showed that lawyers also fought over whether other home-surveillance footage, including footage involving Straughter’s treatment of a cat on the same day, could be considered. The available reports do not establish that any camera captured what happened to Kashan. What jurors did receive was enough for them to find Straughter guilty on Aug. 20 of both murder and child endangerment.
The evidence had another dimension because of the number of children prosecutors said were in the home that day. Straughter was allegedly caring alone for Kashan, his twin and six additional children. Ohio regulates family child care settings according to the number and ages of children present. State guidance currently says unlicensed care in a provider’s home may cover no more than six children, with no more than three under age 2, while licensed family-care homes operate under separate capacity rules. The sources reviewed do not show that a licensing violation was among the charges for which Straughter was convicted, so those regulations provide context rather than an additional criminal finding.
At sentencing, the focus shifted away from proving what had happened and toward the consequences. Kashan’s father spoke about placing his trust in Straughter to protect his sons. Crawford told the court that she had lived with anger, heartbreak and questions since her baby’s death but did not want her statement to be dominated by the person convicted of killing him. Kashan had been born prematurely with his twin on April 25, 2023, and spent weeks in neonatal care before going home. He died at 5 months and 18 days old.
Sperlazza imposed a life term and credited Straughter with 54 days already served. She cannot seek parole until she has served the required minimum of 15 years, and parole eligibility does not guarantee release. A report published at sentencing said her attorneys had 30 days to file an appeal. No reliable subsequent report located through Nov. 18 confirmed that an appellate court had altered the conviction or sentence. The verdict therefore remains the legal conclusion reached after investigators turned medical findings, electronic records and the reconstructed timeline of Oct. 9 into the prosecution’s case.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 18, 2026.