Mother allegedly joins husband in fatal beating of 9-year-old daughter before hit-and-run story

Prosecutors described evidence of repeated abuse, while India Miller’s lawyer argued she had also endured violence inside the Paulsboro home.

PAULSBORO, N.J. — A judge ordered the mother of 9-year-old Maya Thomas to remain jailed after a hearing that moved the case beyond its disputed hit-and-run story and focused instead on allegations of prolonged abuse, family accounts and the mother’s own claimed exposure to domestic violence.

India Miller, 27, and her husband, Sean Scott, 45, are charged with first-degree murder and related offenses in Maya’s Oct. 13 death. Prosecutors allege the couple assaulted the girl and then misled police by suggesting she had been hit by a vehicle while walking the family dog. Miller’s attorney has challenged the prosecution’s portrayal of her conduct, arguing that evidence gathered by investigators also describes Scott as abusive toward Miller. Both defendants are presumed innocent unless convicted.

The clash became especially clear during Miller’s Oct. 27 detention hearing in Gloucester County Superior Court. Prosecutor Elizabeth Tornese argued that medical evidence and interviews with relatives showed Maya had experienced abuse over an extended period and that Miller participated in or failed to stop it. Defense attorney Justin Moore urged the judge to consider Miller’s circumstances inside the home, saying supplemental investigative material included accounts from people who described Scott physically abusing Miller. The hearing did not determine guilt. Its purpose was to decide whether Miller should remain detained while the criminal case proceeds.

Tornese presented the case as one in which warning signs existed well before Maya’s death. According to The Philadelphia Inquirer’s account of the hearing, a relative told investigators that Miller said she and Scott had struck Maya before the child lost consciousness. Another relative reportedly described seeing verbal and physical mistreatment during a visit months earlier. Miller’s mother also told investigators she had previously taken custody of Maya after witnessing alleged physical abuse by Miller, Tornese said. Prosecutors relied on those accounts alongside medical findings they said showed injuries in different stages of healing.

Moore sought to complicate that narrative. He said relatives and friends had separately described Scott abusing Miller, including one account of Miller fleeing the home and seeking refuge elsewhere. The defense argued that such evidence mattered when evaluating Miller’s statements to investigators and her ability to act independently while Scott was nearby. Moore acknowledged that Miller may not have initially given police an accurate account but argued that her fear and Scott’s alleged behavior had to be considered. The prosecution has not accepted that explanation as a basis for releasing her.

The judge ultimately sided with prosecutors on detention. Superior Court Judge Niki Arbittier said the seriousness of the allegations and the potential danger supported keeping Miller in custody. Arbittier also noted that, whatever Miller may have experienced herself, authorities say she gave police a version of events that redirected their attention away from the home. Scott had already waived a separate detention hearing and agreed to stay incarcerated. Those rulings concern pretrial custody only and do not resolve the criminal charges.

The case began very differently. Shortly after 1 a.m. Oct. 13, authorities were told Maya was not breathing and might have been struck by a vehicle. Scott said the girl had been outside with the family dog, while Miller reported hearing a sound resembling screeching tires before Scott found the child near a shed. Police initially responded as though a hit-and-run might have taken place. Dispatch records show officers began searching the neighborhood for a damaged vehicle and urgently sought surveillance recordings that might identify a driver.

That theory weakened as two lines of evidence developed. Surveillance video showed no vehicle traffic matching the reported collision during the relevant period, authorities said. At the hospital, medical personnel told investigators that Maya’s condition did not resemble injuries from a traffic crash. Doctors documented widespread bruising, facial trauma and other injuries, while an autopsy later identified multiple blunt-force injuries, including injuries at different stages of healing. The medical examiner ruled Maya’s death a homicide. She was pronounced dead on the evening of Oct. 13.

Investigators then searched the family’s Swedesboro Avenue residence. Police reported finding wet children’s clothing with suspected blood in a bathroom, as well as suspected blood on tile and cleaning items. Authorities also interviewed Maya’s 4-year-old sibling. According to police, the younger child told investigators that Scott had struck Maya in the face and eyes that night. Prosecutors have incorporated those findings into their case, although individual pieces of evidence have not yet been tested before a jury.

The question of Miller’s responsibility may become one of the more contested parts of future proceedings. Prosecutors describe her as an active participant in abuse and as a parent who failed to protect Maya. Her lawyer has argued that she was living under violence from Scott and points to her efforts to perform CPR as evidence that she tried to save her daughter once the emergency became clear. A detention judge was required only to assess whether release was appropriate, not to decide which account will ultimately prevail at trial.

The criminal case also intersects with a separate child-welfare investigation. The New Jersey Department of Children and Families has said it was examining allegations involving Maya, and Miller’s younger child was removed from the home and placed in emergency care. Maya had been homeschooled, a fact that prompted some state lawmakers to renew calls for stronger oversight of children educated outside traditional schools. Those debates remain separate from the proof required in the murder case, but they have broadened public attention from the events of one night to questions about Maya’s life before her death.

For now, the prosecution’s case rests on a combination of medical findings, witness accounts, physical evidence and what investigators describe as a false explanation for Maya’s injuries. The defense has begun signaling that Miller’s relationship with Scott will be central to its response. Scott and Miller remained incarcerated as the case continued through New Jersey’s court system, with the allegations against both defendants still awaiting adjudication.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.