Oklahoma man kills beats nurse to death with 2×4 at car wash after days of clashes

Douglas Smitherman’s family remembers a gifted nurse and father as Billy Buford begins the unsuspended portion of a life sentence.

OKLAHOMA CITY, Okla. — Douglas Smitherman returned to Oklahoma City hoping to make a fresh start. More than a year after the registered nurse was found dead at a northwest Oklahoma City car wash, the man who admitted killing him has been sentenced to life in prison with all but the first 16 years suspended.

The sentencing of Billy Buford, 60, brings a legal resolution to a case that Smitherman’s family has described in more personal terms: the loss of a son, father, brother and nurse whose life had stretched from McAlester classrooms to hospital floors across Oklahoma. Buford pleaded guilty in May 2026 to first-degree manslaughter in Smitherman’s death. The plea did not include an agreed punishment, and a presentencing investigation was completed before the court imposed the life sentence. Prosecutors said the first 16 years were left unsuspended. The case ended without a trial on the more serious murder charge Buford originally faced.

Long before his name appeared in homicide reports, Smitherman was known to relatives and friends as “DougE” or “DougE Fresh,” a nickname his obituary linked to the sense of style he developed as he grew older. His mother, Barbara Smitherman, remembered a man who stood out both in appearance and ability. “A good dresser, he dressed nice,” she said in a 2025 interview before describing him as “borderline genius.” The phrase captured one part of the family’s portrait of him, but his relatives also pointed to a record of education, health care work and close family ties that extended across much of his adult life.

Smitherman graduated from McAlester High School in 1995. His obituary said teachers were struck by his ability to maintain a 4.0 grade-point average during his senior year even though he missed many days of school. He later pursued work in fitness, becoming a certified personal trainer and working at a Gold’s Gym in Oklahoma City for about two years. His career then moved toward nursing. He earned his registered nursing degree from Eastern Oklahoma State College, finishing in the top third of his class, according to the obituary. His mother said he eventually served as a house supervisor at McAlester Regional for roughly three years.

His nursing work took him beyond one hospital. The obituary said Smitherman also worked as a traveling nurse at facilities around Oklahoma and became known for the way he treated patients. That professional history is important because the criminal case, by its nature, reduced much of the public record to a victim’s name, an address and a sequence of legal events. The family accounts provide a different measure of the life interrupted on May 2, 2025. Smitherman was 48 when police found him dead at a car wash near Northwest 122nd Street and North Pennsylvania Avenue. He had been in Oklahoma City trying to establish a new chapter.

His mother said that move reflected a belief that he needed to get away from the familiarity of McAlester and begin again. She said her son felt that everyone there knew him and that he wanted a new life. Whatever form that fresh start might have taken was cut short at the An-Son Car Wash. Oklahoma City police were dispatched at 12:36 p.m. after a report of a person found dead. Officers said Smitherman had injuries consistent with homicide. There was no immediate arrest, and authorities initially released little about the circumstances. His death became the city’s 24th homicide investigation of 2025.

In those first days, police publicly described a case with more questions than answers. Investigators knew Smitherman had been killed, but they had not announced who was responsible or what had led to his death. The department sought help from anyone who might have information. Later, investigators focused on Buford and determined that he had repeatedly struck Smitherman in the head with a wooden 2-by-4. Authorities also learned that the two men had been involved in clashes during the preceding days, including an episode in which they reportedly threw bricks at one another. Officials have not publicly established a definitive motive for the fatal encounter.

The criminal case that followed initially put Buford in jeopardy of a murder prosecution. He was arrested after investigators linked him to Smitherman’s death, and reporting on the proceedings shows prosecutors originally charged him with first-degree murder. The case ultimately took a different path. In May 2026, Buford admitted guilt to first-degree manslaughter, a lesser offense. Because the plea was entered without an agreed sentence, the court retained responsibility for deciding his punishment. That procedural choice became especially important when the court later imposed a life sentence but suspended all of it except the first 16 years.

For the Smitherman family, the prosecution unfolded against other recent grief. Barbara Smitherman said she had lost Douglas’ father in September before her son’s death the following May. She described the period as difficult, but her comments about the case also included an unusual expression of sympathy for Buford’s relatives. She said she felt sorry for his family because they, too, faced losing a loved one to the consequences of the case. Her words did not minimize her son’s death or the criminal responsibility later accepted by Buford. Instead, they illustrated the broad circle of people affected by the killing and the prosecution that followed.

The sentencing now places a formal legal endpoint on questions of Buford’s guilt and punishment, but it does not answer every question about the night or morning surrounding Smitherman’s death. Authorities have not publicly explained what triggered the final confrontation. The reported earlier disputes provide evidence of tension between the men, but they do not establish why the encounter became fatal. Nor does the publicly released record detail the full reasoning behind the particular sentence selected after the presentencing investigation. Those limits matter because the known evidence should not be stretched to create a motive or narrative that investigators and prosecutors have not themselves established.

What the case does establish is a progression from discovery to investigation to conviction. Smitherman was found at the car wash on May 2, 2025. Police classified his death as a homicide and initially reported no suspect in custody. Investigators later identified Buford and attributed the fatal beating to him. Buford faced a murder charge before pleading guilty to first-degree manslaughter in May 2026. Months later, the court imposed a life sentence with all but the first 16 years suspended. Because publicly available accounts do not set out every correctional consequence of that judgment, no specific release date can reliably be stated from the sentencing announcement alone.

Smitherman’s family has continued to define him through more than the place where he died. Their accounts describe a high-achieving student, personal trainer, registered nurse, hospital supervisor and father who was trying to reset his life in Oklahoma City. The nickname “DougE Fresh” survives in his obituary as a reflection of his personality and style. The court case, meanwhile, records the final legal response to his killing: Buford’s admission to first-degree manslaughter and a life sentence whose first 16 years were not suspended.

The criminal case has now moved beyond the unanswered early appeals for information that followed Smitherman’s death. Buford has been convicted and sentenced, while no further trial is required on the original murder charge because of his guilty plea. Questions about the exact cause of the final confrontation remain unresolved in the public record. Smitherman’s relatives are left with a different record — one centered on his family, education, nursing career and the new beginning he had hoped to create.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.