Philadelphia mother backed boyfriend’s car crash lie after he fatally beat her 4-year-old son

Damari Carter’s relatives pushed for answers after weeks without seeing him, setting in motion an investigation that ultimately led to two murder convictions.

PHILADELPHIA, Penn. — Before police had a homicide case, before detectives had surveillance footage and before anyone knew where 4-year-old Damari Carter’s body was, members of his family were asking a basic question: If the boy had really died in a car crash, where was the evidence that the crash had happened?

Nearly three years later, the explanation that troubled Damari’s relatives became a central piece of a murder prosecution. A Philadelphia jury convicted his mother, Dominique Bailey, and her boyfriend, Kevin Spencer, of third-degree murder and a series of related offenses in the child’s death. The verdict followed evidence that prosecutors said showed Damari was abused in Spencer’s West Philadelphia apartment, disappeared from surveillance footage, and was later carried from the building in the same type of duffel bag in which his remains were eventually found. Sentencing is set for Dec. 4 before Common Pleas Court Judge Roxanne Covington.

Damari’s family had last heard from him around his fourth birthday in late November 2023. By December, relatives were becoming increasingly worried. Bailey told them the boy had been struck and killed by a vehicle, prosecutors said. Instead of accepting that explanation, family members sought confirmation. They circulated missing-person posters and contacted local news organizations. Damari’s father, who lived in Texas, also contacted hospitals and medical offices looking for information. There was no readily verifiable record that the traffic death Bailey described had occurred.

The family’s outreach eventually reached Philadelphia police in an unusual way. The Special Victims Unit opened an investigation on Dec. 30, 2023, after a local news organization contacted authorities about the missing child. Detectives then treated the alleged crash as something that could be checked against official records. They contacted hospitals, the city medical examiner and the police Crash Investigation Unit. Prosecutors said none had a record matching the supposed death of a 4-year-old boy. That failure to corroborate Bailey’s account shifted the investigation from a reported accident toward the question of where Damari actually was.

When detectives located Bailey on Jan. 4, her explanation changed, according to the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office. She first said she had been walking with Damari near 40th Street and Lancaster Avenue when he dropped a toy and was struck by a vehicle. After investigators challenged parts of the account, prosecutors said, Bailey told them Spencer had instead been the last person with the child and had been walking with him when the supposed collision happened. Detectives then located Spencer, who initially denied knowing Damari before offering a similar account of a fatal crash.

The story became more elaborate rather than more verifiable. Prosecutors said both Bailey and Spencer told police that an ambulance had taken Damari to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, where he died, and that the hospital had somehow lost his body. Investigators found no evidence to support those claims. A search of the Reno Street apartment where Bailey and Damari had been staying with Spencer also produced another concern: detectives found no sign of the boy and no children’s belongings, according to prosecutors. The absence of a documented crash, hospital record or body left investigators looking for an entirely different explanation.

That explanation emerged from evidence inside and around the apartment. A downstairs neighbor told investigators that she had heard a child crying and sounds she believed were repeated beatings during the first week of December. She recorded some of what she heard and contacted the city’s Department of Human Services on Dec. 7. A hallway camera supplied a visual timeline. Prosecutors said Damari was recorded entering the apartment on Dec. 5 and was never seen on the camera again. The system continued recording in the following days, including audio that prosecutors said captured the child crying and being abused.

Investigators also examined Spencer’s cellphone. Prosecutors said forensic work recovered deleted videos from Dec. 7 showing Damari with injuries to his head and face. One video described during court proceedings showed the child sitting in front of breakfast while Spencer confronted him. Prosecutors used that evidence to argue that the boy had been subjected to escalating mistreatment while Bailey continued her relationship with Spencer. Bailey’s lawyers disputed the prosecution’s effort to tie her directly to the fatal violence and later argued that she was not present when Damari died.

The hallway camera supplied another part of the chronology after Damari was no longer seen. On Dec. 8, prosecutors said, Spencer was recorded leaving the apartment with a large trash bag. On Dec. 9, he was seen carrying a black Puma duffel bag. At the time, no one watching the recording could yet connect that bag to a recovered body because Damari’s remains would not be found for more than three months. But the footage eventually became one of the prosecution’s most important links between the apartment and the location where the child was discovered.

Bailey and Spencer were arrested in January 2024 while Damari was still missing. Police believed he had been killed, but investigators had no remains to examine and no confirmed location where his body had been left. That uncertainty lasted until March 18, when city workers cleaning an area behind the 600 block of North 38th Street found a black duffel bag containing badly decomposed remains. The condition of the body prevented immediate identification, and police initially described the victim only as a young child.

DNA testing later supplied the answer Damari’s family had been seeking since December. Police announced in May 2024 that the remains belonged to the missing 4-year-old. The bag was discovered only a short distance from the Reno Street apartment. Investigators also said Damari was found wearing clothing that matched what he had been wearing in cellphone video recorded shortly before his death. The medical examiner classified the cause as homicidal violence, giving prosecutors medical findings to add to the digital, surveillance and witness evidence that had accumulated during the investigation.

By the time the case reached trial in 2026, the prosecution no longer depended on any single piece of evidence. Jurors heard about the family’s unsuccessful attempts to verify the crash story, the defendants’ changing accounts, the neighbor’s recordings, hallway surveillance, recovered cellphone videos, the disappearance of Damari’s belongings, the movement of the duffel bag and the later recovery of his remains. Prosecutors argued that Bailey had allowed Spencer to abuse her son and then joined him in concealing what happened after the boy died.

The defense tried to separate the defendants from the prosecution’s most damaging interpretations. Spencer’s attorney emphasized that no witness testified to directly seeing either defendant beat Damari and challenged how much the downstairs neighbor could know from noises heard through the building. Bailey’s defense argued that she was not present when her son died, that the sounds the neighbor described were generally heard while Bailey was away at work, and that Bailey’s inconsistent statements to investigators reflected confusion rather than a deliberate cover-up. Both defendants had also sought separate trials, but Covington denied those requests.

Jurors ultimately drew a line between first-degree and third-degree murder. They acquitted Bailey and Spencer of first-degree murder but convicted both of third-degree murder. The jury also found them guilty of conspiracy to commit murder, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal use of a communication facility, false reports to law enforcement, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse. The verdict therefore rejected the most serious degree of murder presented while still holding both defendants criminally responsible for Damari’s death and the conduct that followed.

The case also left an unresolved institutional question about a warning before Damari died. The downstairs neighbor testified that she contacted DHS on Dec. 7 because of what she was hearing. At a preliminary hearing in 2024, prosecutors said it appeared no one from the agency intervened before the child’s death. A city official said Damari was not in DHS custody and was not receiving agency services. Confidentiality rules limited further public disclosure. That issue was part of the case’s history, but the murder trial focused on the criminal responsibility of Bailey and Spencer.

The story that first brought Damari’s relatives to police — a fatal car accident that investigators could not find — became evidence of concealment rather than an explanation for his absence. The family’s refusal to stop asking about the boy led to a news inquiry, a police investigation, the discovery of surveillance and digital evidence, and eventually the identification of his remains. Bailey and Spencer now await sentencing on Dec. 4. Spencer has asked his lawyer to pursue an appeal, according to an interview his attorney gave after the verdict. No sentence has yet been imposed.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.