Witness says man shot 31-year-old Colorado woman then threatened her family into silence

Faith Smith’s recovery behind an Amarillo garage followed a fast-moving investigation that later produced a murder charge and a separate federal gun case.

AMARILLO, Texas — The recovery of Faith Smith’s body from behind a detached garage was not where the Amarillo homicide investigation began. Detectives first had information about a shooting and an unknown burial site, then worked through witnesses, a suspected vehicle and a brief police pursuit before finding the 31-year-old Colorado woman.

That chain of events is central to the case against Leonard Torres, 48, who is now charged with murder. Authorities allege Smith was shot while riding in a vehicle in late September and later buried at a residential property on Orange Street. Police found Torres driving the vehicle investigators associated with the shooting and arrested him Oct. 1 after a short chase. Investigators then obtained information directing them to the burial site. Court documents later added two consequential allegations: a cooperating witness said Torres fired the shot and threatened her afterward, while Torres himself allegedly acknowledged shooting Smith but maintained that it happened accidentally. He also admitted burying Smith, according to the records.

Smith’s identity became public after investigators excavated the burial site behind a detached garage that was under construction in Amarillo’s Hamlet neighborhood. Police said the Homicide Unit and Crime Scene Investigation Unit went to the Orange Street property after Torres was taken into custody and officers learned more about where the woman had been buried. The body was recovered and an autopsy was ordered. Police subsequently identified the victim as Smith, a Colorado resident. The reports reviewed for this story do not provide a detailed public biography of Smith or explain why she was in Amarillo, and authorities have not publicly supplied a complete account of her movements before the shooting.

The case had opened earlier on Oct. 1 when Amarillo police received information that a woman from Colorado had been shot in a vehicle and buried somewhere in the city. Homicide detectives identified people who might have information and said they confirmed details of the initial report. Investigators then identified Torres as a possible suspect. The development was important because detectives did not yet know where the alleged burial had occurred. Instead, the investigation initially depended on connecting witness information to a person and a vehicle that officers could locate. Police said they ultimately spotted Torres operating the same vehicle they suspected had been involved in Smith’s shooting.

Additional reporting based on an arrest report placed the vehicle at the Rama Motel on East Amarillo Boulevard before officers attempted to stop Torres. Police obtained a warrant and followed him as he left the motel and later a nearby convenience store, according to the report. Officers attempted a traffic stop after he allegedly failed to signal during a turn. Authorities said Torres did not stop and instead fled briefly. The pursuit ended when another police vehicle moved into position and blocked his path. He was initially arrested on allegations that included evading arrest or detention with a vehicle and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. The murder charge came later as detectives developed the homicide case.

A cooperating witness supplied investigators with a narrative of the alleged shooting. According to court documents reported by NewsChannel 10 and Law&Crime, the witness said she was driving a blue Fiat while Torres and Smith were passengers. The records place the alleged shooting on Sept. 27 as the vehicle traveled north on North Mirror Street. The witness told investigators Torres fired a handgun at Smith. She further alleged that he then pointed the weapon at her and threatened to kill her or her family if she told anyone what had happened. Investigators also said the witness gave them information about where Smith had been buried. Those statements are allegations, and the witness’ complete testimony has not been tested at trial.

The physical discoveries described by police gave detectives several points against which they could compare that account. Torres was found with the vehicle investigators linked to the case. Smith’s body was recovered from the burial location identified during the investigation. Police said Torres later admitted that he had buried her there. Those facts do not by themselves resolve every question about the shooting, but they help explain why the investigation progressed from a tip about a possible killing to a formal murder accusation. Authorities have not released a complete forensic inventory from the Fiat or burial site, nor have the reports reviewed here disclosed the full autopsy findings or every laboratory result obtained during the case.

The most direct conflict in the emerging record concerns Torres’ description of the shooting. Court documents say he admitted shooting Smith in the head but told investigators it was an accident. Prosecutors nevertheless charged him with murder. The available reports do not contain a full transcript of his interview or a detailed explanation of what he claimed made the discharge accidental. They also do not establish how prosecutors intend to rebut that account in court. The distinction matters because an arrest affidavit and criminal charge describe the government’s allegations; they are not findings of guilt. Torres is entitled to the presumption of innocence unless and until the charge is proved beyond a reasonable doubt.

The investigation did not stop with Torres’ murder charge. Evidence obtained after his arrest led authorities to examine whether a firearm connected to his brother might have been involved. Police found several phones in the Fiat, including one belonging to the cooperating witness. Court records say Leonard Torres had used that phone to call his brother, Salvador Torres. Afterward, Salvador Torres sent a message referring to wanting his “strap” back. Investigators understood the word as a reference to a gun and began looking into the possibility that Leonard Torres had access to a firearm associated with his brother. Salvador Torres later said the message referred to a BB gun, according to the records.

Police searched a family home and reported finding 9mm ammunition in Salvador Torres’ bedroom. The following day, Salvador Torres contacted an investigator and said he had found what he believed police were looking for, the court records say. Officers returned and were shown a Taurus 9mm handgun wrapped in a red bandana that Salvador Torres said he had discovered beneath a dresser. Crime scene testing found reported blood residue on the gun. Investigators also examined phone messages concerning the purchase of a firearm and ammunition. Because Salvador Torres has a felony conviction, federal authorities later charged him with being a felon in possession of a firearm. That prosecution is separate from the murder charge against his brother.

The existence of that gun does not settle the homicide case. Public reporting reviewed for this article does not establish that forensic testing conclusively identified it as the weapon that killed Smith, and Salvador Torres has not been charged with her killing. The development instead shows how evidence generated by one investigation can produce a separate criminal case while the original homicide inquiry continues. It also creates a potential line of evidence prosecutors and defense attorneys may examine if testing connects the weapon, ammunition, DNA, blood or other material to Smith’s death. Authorities have not publicly disclosed all such laboratory findings.

Leonard Torres remains in the Potter County Detention Center with bond denied, according to the most recent local reporting reviewed. Salvador Torres was separately being held on the federal gun allegation. The murder prosecution still leaves key matters unresolved in public: the complete circumstances of the shooting, the strength and extent of forensic evidence, the legal significance of Torres’ accident claim and whether the recovered 9mm can be conclusively tied to Smith’s death. Smith’s recovery behind the Orange Street garage provided investigators with the victim and crime scene they had been searching for, but the courts will determine what the collected evidence ultimately proves.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.